3 ms·
You might think Johnstone's assertions are wrong, but you too are lying when you say they are unsupported; in the sentence you are referring to, she linked to h
by kragen 5y ago
You might think Johnstone's assertions are wrong, but you too are lying when you say they are unsupported; in the sentence you are referring to, she linked to her own previous article which explains the history https://caitlinjohnstone.substack.com/p/experts-warned-for-years-that-nato https://caitlinjohnstone.substack.com/p/experts-warned-for-y... as well as some guy named "Aaron I Killed" on Substack https://mate.substack.com/p/the-ukraine-crisis-sponsored-by-us?s=r https://mate.substack.com/p/the-ukraine-crisis-sponsored-by-... and, more credibly, a FAIR backgrounder by Bryce Greene https://fair.org/home/what-you-should-really-know-about-ukraine/ https://fair.org/home/what-you-should-really-know-about-ukra....
These do in fact support the assertion. "Aaron I Killed" in particular seems perhaps partisan enough that his assertions should be handled with tweezers. The FAIR article is pretty solid and reliable; the only criticism I'd make is that, as progressives often do, it overstates the importance of the neo-Nazi movement in both Ukraine and in the US, for example neglecting to mention that the Ukrainian neo-Nazis lost all their parliamentary seats in the last election.
I haven't been watching RT so I don't know firsthand how much they're lying, but see a lot of secondhand reports that they're lying an enormous amount, and those seem reliable.
- dash2 5y agoIt’s a good idea, and IIRC part of this site’s guidelines, to “assume good faith”. If you find the linked articles more convincing than I do in making the case that NATO had a hand in starting this war, then maybe say “I disagree” rather than “you are lying”.
- kragen 5y agoNormally I would do that, and I considered that, but the only possible alternative to you lying in this case would be that you didn't notice the three separate rather conspicuous links in the sentence you quoted, or didn't realize they were links to supporting information, or that they weren't there when you read the article, perhaps because Johnstone added them after you read it. This seemed extremely implausible to me. If that were the case, presumably you would have said, "I didn't see those links" instead of just "It’s a good idea, and IIRC part of this site’s guidelines, to “assume good faith”. If you find the linked articles more convincing than I do in making the case that NATO had a hand in starting this war, then maybe say “I disagree” rather than “you are lying”." Therefore the presumption of good faith in this case has been comprehensively overcome. Blitzkrieged, really. And you still haven't expressed any remorse, just complained that it's ill-mannered of me to point out your lie. Perhaps I shouldn't have talked about my evaluation of the reliability of those three articles, because the point about your lying is that, even if all three of those articles were nothing but lies, Johnstone's assertion still wouldn't be "unsupported", as you falsely claimed it was. It would be "supported only by lies". But I mentioned my evaluation of the reliability because I think the question of whether what's going on in Ukraine is much more important than the question of whether you were lying about what Johnstone said. Which, to be clear, you were. Please own up to it and don't do it again.
- dash2 5y agoOr, I read the links and thought their arguments were ridiculous. I’ll stop this conversation here: I see no point in arguing with someone who won’t offer me the basic assumption of good faith.
- kragen 5y agoThat's not a valid reason for asserting that the links weren't there at all.
- native_samples 5y agoThe assumption of good faith has to be earned, it's not a right. On this site users are mostly anonymous and so there is a rule that you assume good faith by default but that is not a license to say whatever you like and then get upset when called on it. It's especially vital for upholding the default assumption of good faith that people try hard to be precise in their words. In this case you said clearly that the assertions were unsupported which doesn't mean "supported but I don't like it". You did in fact say something untrue and if that's because you use language badly, that's a problem you are creating for everyone else. So stop it - admit your claim was wrong and move on to explaining why you don't like the support used.