4 ms·
There is no "mainstream Progressive (sic) justification" for discriminating against Asians, because there is no progressive political platform built on discrimi
by woodruffw 5y ago
There is no "mainstream Progressive (sic) justification" for discriminating against Asians, because there is no progressive political platform built on discriminating against Asians.
Many progressives believe in affirmative action, which doesn't say anything about the particulars of the groups that aren't being explicitly included. Nobody at all is interested in exclusion; they are interested in more inclusion.
- gruez 5y ago>Many progressives believe in affirmative action, which doesn't say anything about the particulars of the groups that aren't being explicitly included. Nobody at all is interested in exclusion; they are interested in more inclusion. Seems like a cop-out to me, especially when dealing with scarce resources (ie. admission slots). The policy of "more inclusion" by giving preferential treatment to one group, ends up excluding everyone else. edit: reworded "Your policy" to "The policy" to avoid making it about the parent.
- woodruffw 5y ago> Seems like a cop-out to me, especially when dealing with scarce resources (ie. admission slots). Your policy of "more inclusion" by giving preferential treatment to one group, ends up excluding everyone else. I never agreed to artificial scarcity in the form of admission slots, and so I'm not interested in defending any particular consequence of that system.
- gruez 5y agoSorry for being unclear, the "cop-out" was a criticism with that position (ie. that we can do stuff because they're "inclusive" but ignore the consequences), not with you specifically.
- woodruffw 5y agoYep, this demonstrates (IMO) the actual problem: we want to have our cake (an artificially elite educational system) and eat it too. I want to an artificially elite high school (one of the best in the country), and I would much rather see everyone and not just the presumed elite treated the way I was.
- dahfizz 5y agoAdmission slots are not artificially scarce. You don't have to be a genius to imagine why you can't admit 100 million students into a particular school. You're still avoiding the question. Is your position "I support inclusion, only when resources are not scarce?"
- woodruffw 5y ago> You don't have to be a genius to imagine why you can't admit 100 million students into a particular school. You don't admit 100 million students to an excellent school. You make 1 million excellent schools and admit 100 students to each. There is no reason for there to be a scarcity of excellent education in our wealthy, developed country. I support actions that make the world a more just place in the Rawlsian sense of the word. Affirmative action makes the world a more just place.
- dahfizz 5y agoOkay, sure. In a perfect world we would have enough resources for everything. In the real world, affirmative action policies disadvantage asian people. > Affirmative action makes the world a more just place. The question you have been dancing around: why is it just to disadvantage Asians in favor of other minorities? What is the mainstream Progressive justification for discriminating against Asians?
- woodruffw 5y agoThere is none, because there is no mainstream progressive position associated with discriminating against Asians. You can refer back to my original comment for why that is. Edit: To be clear: what I'm claiming is that the "progressive" position is better associated with improving education overall. It's only through a particularly warped partisan lens does it become this ridiculous squabble over artificially scarce resources.
- gruez 5y ago>There is none, because there is no mainstream progressive position associated with discriminating against Asians. Right, just as there's no political party/government whose position is runaway inflation. Yet, runaway inflation still happens, usually as a result of some sort of government policy. The fact that no one advocates for it directly is irrelevant. If you advocate for a policy, you're advocating for all of its effects, good or bad.
- scythe 5y ago>I never agreed to artificial scarcity in the form of admission slots, and so I'm not interested in defending any particular consequence of that system. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy
- woodruffw 5y agoI don't think there's anything particularly dreamy or fanciful about a more equal educational system. My understanding is that the US, with its uniquely devolved set of educational authorities and standards is alone in the developed world in terms of the inequality of education offered to its children.
- refurb 5y agoI assume you either have little experience with the US school system or other countries school systems. There is most definitely similar inequality in other countries.
- SyzygistSix 5y agoDo they also have a permanent underclass with a high crime rate and result in mass incarceration?
- refurb 5y agoPermanent underclass? Yes. Mass incarceration? Depending on your definition
- scythe 5y ago>the US, with its uniquely devolved set of educational authorities and standards is alone in the developed world in terms of the inequality of education offered to its children. In terms of primary and secondary education, absolutely. In higher education, inequality is common across countries, but higher education has a much smaller average effect on actual life outcomes than childhood education. Yet somehow reforming the school system (and the avaricious correlation between property taxes and outcomes) gets a lot less political oxygen.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoI know Asian Americans who have inquired about AA and are turned away because they aren't the "right kind" of minority.
- shard 5y agoReminds me of this: https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2021/05/22/eugene-chung-says-nfl-team-told-him-hes-not-the-right-minority-in-job-interview/ https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2021/05/22/eugene-chun...
- 300bps 5y agoNobody at all is interested in exclusion; they are interested in more inclusion. If you have limited open positions and you use race to determine who gets them then you are excluding 1 person for every 1 person you are including.
- Manuel_D 5y agoProportional representation is inherently fixed sum. If X% of one group is too low and you want to increase it, then increasing that representation must also reduce the representation of other groups. There's no way around this. The change to subjective admissions criteria that led to a drop from 73% Asians to under 50% at Thomas Jefferson could be said to be more inclusive of the races that saw increased representation. It's also correct to say that it's more exclusive of Asians.
- woodruffw 5y ago> Proportional representation is inherently fixed sum. If X% of one group is too low and you want to increase it, then increasing that representation must also reduce the representation of other groups. There's no way around this. The overall quality of America's educational system is not fixed-sum. We should be creating a dozen more TJs for every one that currently exists.
- Manuel_D 5y agoBut that's not what is happening. What's happening is that Thomas Jefferson is now using race as a factor in admissions, resulting in reduced representation of Asians. To narrow down more surgically on the issue here: > Many progressives believe in affirmative action, which doesn't say anything about the particulars of the groups that aren't being explicitly included. Nobody at all is interested in exclusion; they are interested in more inclusion. This is incorrect. Affirmative action is absolutely just as much about exclusion as inclusion. Advantaging one group is the same thing as disadvantaging all other groups. And yes, the mainstream progressive platform is to advantage minorities other than Asians - which is the same thing as disadvantaging Asians. My company tried to pull this argument when proposing a larger bonus to recruiters for hiring diverse candidates. "Oh it's not disadvantaging any group, it's just being more inclusive towards diverse groups". But it's not. The company phrased is as an extra $250 to ($500 vs $250) to inspire recruiters to be more inclusive towards women and URM. But you could say the normal bonus is $500, but there's a $250 penalty for non-diverse candidates. Advantaging vs disadvantaging, and inclusion vs exclusion. They're all two ends of the same lever.
- TeeMassive 5y ago> Nobody at all is interested in exclusion; they are interested in more inclusion. In a contingency, the inclusion of a group will result in exclusion in other groups.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoThe doctrine of double effect applies here. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_double_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_double_effect
- kerneloftruth 5y agoThere is no "mainstream Progressive (sic) justification" for discriminating against Asians, because there is no progressive political platform built on discriminating against Asians. Oh there is one that's forming, indeed. Asian-Americans are now called "white adjacent": https://www.asian-dawn.com/2020/11/17/school-district-categorizes-asians-as-white-adjacent/ https://www.asian-dawn.com/2020/11/17/school-district-catego...
- thaumasiotes 5y agoSometimes they're called "white adjacent". Mostly they're just called "white", or "lily-white". Here's Eugene Volokh writing about it in 1998: https://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/asian.htm https://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/asian.htm
- scarmig 5y agoI think the preferred practice nowadays for elected officials in more progressive areas is to call Asians "house n****rs." https://missionlocal.org/2021/03/alison-collins-school-board-tweets/ https://missionlocal.org/2021/03/alison-collins-school-board...
- anonymoushn 5y agoI have a difficult time squaring claims like this with the decade-long national conversation about racial quotas for Asians (which has done almost nothing to eliminate these racial quotas) and the recent SF public school policy changes in which gifted math classes were eliminated because too many Asian people were taking them.