2 ms·
This is excessively hostile towards a relatively small field in physics. Yup, lots of people have criticisms of string theory and related theories, but the imp
by colechristensen 5y ago
This is excessively hostile towards a relatively small field in physics. Yup, lots of people have criticisms of string theory and related theories, but the implications that this is all that physics has been doing in that area is very false. Lots of people work on lots of other things and they’ve continually made decent progress, just not the explosive progress which happened at the beginning of quantum physics.
This emotional attachment to certain fields is very unscientific and not at all helpful.
- mrjangles 5y agoYou need to read the article to understand my comment. It is specifically about the crisis in high energy particle physics and cosmology. My comment specifically mentions advances in other areas of physics. In case it wasn't clear, I am saying these advancements, such as imaging and understanding glass (and quantum computers, semiconductor tech...etc), are currently the edge of science and our understanding of the universe. It is progressing, albeit slowly, it just doesn't get any hype like the pseudo-science stuff does.
- colechristensen 5y agoAnd my point is, be more charitable to scientists you think are wrong who are acting in good faith. There is a long history of people like this being right despite the oppression on occasion. You want other things to be studied, go help yourself.
- mellosouls 5y agoThere is a long history of people like this being right despite the oppression on occasion. A dominant school of thought producing no observable results over decades, instead apparently relying on career pressure to conform and perpetuate the path would normally be considered dogmatic rather than oppressed, and doesn't immediately spring to mind as a model for "a long history of people like this being right".