2 ms·
Look, P&F's putative results cannot be the same thing as what these NASA guys are claiming. The NASA people are claiming ordinary DD fusion reactions are occur
by pfdietz 5y ago
Look, P&F's putative results cannot be the same thing as what these NASA guys are claiming. The NASA people are claiming ordinary DD fusion reactions are occurring, just at an enhanced rate. P&F's putative heat excess would have killed P&F from neutron radiation if it had been the ordinary DD reactions.
Physicists knew P&F's nonsense was garbage because it required multiple miracles (that fusion would occur, that the ordinary fusion reactions would not, that some weird non-standard fusion reaction would occur instead.) Far, far more likely was they just were bumblers. And when replication failed (and it did fail; other vaguely similar but different sporadic results are not "replication") that prior was validated.