9 ms·
The whole point of a public blockchain is for it to be trustless. Why do you even need to factor in achieving 'Large scale trust' with the largest Ethereum stak
by rvz 5y ago
The whole point of a public blockchain is for it to be trustless. Why do you even need to factor in achieving 'Large scale trust' with the largest Ethereum stakeholders to not say, attempt to revert a massive hack in 2016 to save the investors lost money?
Why should I have to trust them to not do that again if another hack happened, even if they migrate to PoS and it causes a giant fork once again?
- anonporridge 5y agoThere's some nuance here. A public blockchain is supposed to be "trustless" in that you don't have to trust humans to be honest, because the system is harshly fair and enforced by computation and the laws of physics that no one can trivially bullshit their way around. The important function of proof of work is that it solves the Byzantine generals problem such that everyone can trust the system without caring much about who else is using or controlling it. Proof of stake is problematic because it shifts the burden of trust back into the hands of humans, and we all know that "the hearts of men are easily corrupted".
- thebean11 5y agoMiners are run by humans too, though, who could also theoretically attack the network. In both PoW and PoS they are incentivized not to.
- anonporridge 5y agoThe difference between miners and stakers... If miners start acting bad, anyone else on the planet can acquire chips and electricity to peacefully countervail their power. If stakers start acting bad, the only options you have are 1) abandon the monetary system or 2) violently coerce the top stakers and torture them into giving you control of their stake. This is why bitcoin is the only cryptocurrency likely to become the truly global, monetary asset that nation states use for trade and monetary reserves. No way in hell nation states will trust Vitalik and his gang to honestly secure their money.
- etherael 5y agoAnd why would you trust Greg Maxwell and his gang?
- anonporridge 5y agoThere's no intrinsic part of bitcoin that requires you to trust them. He might own a large amount of bitcoin, or have some sway in bitcoin core development, but that does not equal unilateral control authority of the protocol.
- etherael 5y agoSo next time they organise a soft-fork and have their crony exchanges insist on allocating the ticker to their soft-fork for whatever, that's not going to consist of a "failure of trust" on their part at all? And before you claim it couldn't happen, keep in mind they already did it to keep the chain locked to maximum of 7 tx per second. If you can convince people to let that slide, you can convince them to let near anything slide. It fundamentally makes the currency useless. For all Ethereum's flaws, at least people understand the limitations of their trust model and their processes. The mythology built around BTC is completely unhinged from reality and people have no clue how inaccurate it is when compared with the facts on the ground.
- thebean11 5y agoYou realize if there is a fork in Bitcoin, your coins would exist on both sides of it right? If they do something you don't like you can continue using the other fork, there is literally nothing stopping you or anybody else, and you did not lose any funds. > they already did it to keep the chain locked to maximum of 7 tx per second Are you talking about Bitcoin Cash? Bitcoin Cash forked off of Bitcoin, not the other way around.
- etherael 5y ago> You realize if there is a fork in Bitcoin, your coins would exist on both sides of it right? In theory. In practice a lot of people will never bother to track splits, understand the intricacies of what a given fork means; case in point here where you claim that Bitcoin Cash split off BTC despite their pursuing the original architecture of Bitcoin proper, and BTC going a completely different direction with lightning forced in as a core part of the architecture and total on chain throughput permanently limited to a level which makes it useless as anything more than a toy. > If they do something you don't like you can continue using the other fork, there is literally nothing stopping you or anybody else, and you did not lose any funds The important thing is that they can set the characteristics of the monetary base of BTC to arbitrarily whatever they want without limit, and this has effects on what that monetary base is able to accomplish. For example; they can force it to never be used as a peer to peer electronic currency for the world, it doesn't take much of a reach to imagine who might want to do such a thing and what other goals and projects they might want to steer BTC toward, that may well have nothing to do with the interests of BTC holders nor the reasons they've convinced themselves that they're holding it. Their interests don't matter though, and the reasons they think they're holding it don't matter either. What matters is what the core council of developers announce from on high is the future direction of the chain, all else be damned, that's what you're going to be stuck with. At the moment you think "I've been duped" your options are either to divest and have your goals thwarted, or fork off and lose enormous amount of momentum and historical record and most likely if history is any example, only one in a million will even notice what happened and what your fork was for. You come out ten years later as a settlement layer for central banks and shake your head wondering what the hell happened, then you realise you never really understood it to begin with.
- thebean11 5y agoI mean trusting the network (to continue working, to not have large reorgs etc). I don't mean trusting individuals.