3 ms·
An auto loan is a financial product: something that you effectively buy. The dealer not only sells cars, but financial products. They make more money if they se
by kazinator 5y ago
An auto loan is a financial product: something that you effectively buy. The dealer not only sells cars, but financial products. They make more money if they sell you a car and one or more financial products, than if they just sell you a car.
Also, auto loans give them steady income averaged over time, which smooths out their cash flow. If they only sold cars for cash, they would have more pronounced boom and bust cycles in their revenue.
If the rate of their loans is low, it's because the car is overpriced to make up for it. Do the reverse math. Call your bank and ask them what the interest would be for a line of credit equivalent to the loan amount for that car, over the same period. Use the bank's interest part of their loan to deduce what the cash value of the car must be. E.g. say the bank offers you $30,000 over five years at 3%. You're going to pay about $2300 in interest which is 7.6% of the principal amount. OK, so if the car dealer were to offer you close to 0% interest for five years, it means they inflated the car's price by 7.6% (if not more) so that they make at least the same money on the loan as the bank would. You should therefore pay 7.6% less for the car in cash, than what they are asking for under the too-good-to-be-true loan.
- josephcsible 5y agoYou're not a risk-free borrower, so unsecured loans will always have a higher interest rate than secured loans, all other things equal.
- brianwawok 5y agoI am pretty sure the dealer gets the money up front + a fee. Say take out a 35k loan, paperwork clears, dealer gets a check for $35,500.. the $500 being a "bonus" for originating the loan from the lender.
- sonotathrowaway 5y agoDealerships typically get points on the loan - the approving bank will give an approval for x amount, not to exceed y after taxes/fees/warranties. The amount paid to the dealer will vary, but typically = y * points on the loan
- toddmatthews 5y ago> Call your bank and ask them what the interest would be for a line of credit equivalent to the loan amount for that car, over the same period an unsecured line of credit is going to have a higher interest rate than loan backed by the collateral of the car. also, people tend not to default on their primary vehicle (they need it to get around) so its a less risky loan, hence the lower interest rate
- hoffspot 5y agoI would have 1000% agreed with you except I had a very different experience last year. I was out seeking loans for a car and shopping around for low interest. One of the lower ones was from a company branded LightStream but on the back end is really SunTrust/Truist. They had a great rate, no origination fees, and weirdly, asked specifically not to set the loan up so that the car was collateral. Maybe it was a credit rating thing (mine is quite good) and they would incur more costs setting it up that way.
- kazinator 5y ago> an unsecured line of credit is going to have a higher interest rate than loan backed by the collateral of the car. That depends on who you are and what you have, from the bank's POV. If they are actively bugging you to take out this kind of loan, then they probably don't have an issue regarding collateral. A car is not particularly good collateral; it depreciates rapidly, subject to being damaged and stolen.
- sonotathrowaway 5y agoHouses make good collateral. You can’t pick up a house and move it to hide it from the repo man.
- _3u10 5y agoThat’s a bit incorrect from the POV of the dealer, the loan company pays them the cash for the car (and commissions) and takes the cash flow. A 0% loan doesn’t necessarily mean you’re paying more, there are often factory incentives and other issues. Basically modern manufacturing is highly capital intensive with low cost of reproduction. By selling more vehicles they amortize the cost the factory across more vehicles. Also many of the cars have already been produced and the factory and dealer are looking at selling that car new vs selling a year old car with no mileage.
- kazinator 5y agoEven if the 0% loans are there to incentivize people to get into car ownership who can't put up the cash, thereby moving more cars, that makes no difference. That incentivizing costs money, and the car is more expensive because of it. The buyer who is not incentivized by "0% financing for X period", because they are paying with cash, shouldn't have to pay the cost of those incentivies, and thus expects to pay less.