3 ms·
Look, RIPE have been neutral in every conflict so far in their lifetime, as far as I'm aware, and for communications rather than payment services it is actually
by pjc50 5y ago
Look, RIPE have been neutral in every conflict so far in their lifetime, as far as I'm aware, and for communications rather than payment services it is actually an advantage to have a neutral to keep the lines of communication open. It also lets us talk to them and keep the flow of actual news into Russia going, rather than lock them in a room with their own propaganda.
I understand the desire to throw everything including the kitchen sink at Russia, but remember that sanctions are primarily directed against the ordinary public of the country, and that cutting Russia off from RIPE is not going to stop their military.
(The sheer suddenness of the flip on Russia, and its scale, surprises me. We didn't do it when they shot down a passenger jet, or carried out several terrorist attacks with chemical weapons outside the country, or when they supported Assad in Syria, or even the previous time Russia invaded Ukraine. Perhaps if something more graduated had been done earlier we wouldn't be in this position)
- alangibson 5y agoThis is the right answer. Communication with those on the other side is a good thing. Yea they can get their message out, but so can dissidents on their side of the border. Those on our side can also get news and information in to those that don't support the war.
- formerly_proven 5y ago> (The sheer suddenness of the flip on Russia, and its scale, surprises me. We didn't do it when they shot down a passenger jet, or carried out several terrorist attacks with chemical weapons outside the country, or when they supported Assad in Syria, or even the previous time Russia invaded Ukraine. Perhaps if something more graduated had been done earlier we wouldn't be in this position) Back then I was shocked that one can just invade and annex part of a country in Europe and virtually nothing happens. Sure, a few minor sanctions here and there, but really nothing that would have an effect. Obviously, the idea was to to appease Russia and try to involve it economically in order to ultimately have it become more liberal and democratic. If you look at Merkels actions in particular, she was using that exact playbook that the US had been using after WW2 in Europe and Germany in particular to great success, but failed in China, and also Russia. So I think all previous actions have to be seen under this strategy. The full-scale invasion of Ukraine, and direct lies on the diplomatic level before that ("just an exercise, won't invade, calling troops back" etc.) forced the West to concede that appeasement and economic inter-dependency as a strategy failed and that if Putin's Russia succeeds with the invasion in Ukraine, Eastern Europe will be next. So the strategy changed to "Putin cannot be allowed to win in Ukraine".
- pjc50 5y ago> Back then I was shocked that one can just invade and annex part of a country in Europe and virtually nothing happens We allowed them to slice that particular bit of salami, to warm the frog a little; I guess they thought it was a green light to slice further. Heck, their plan came very very close to working; the assumption was that they could land commandos at Kyiv airport, kill Zelensky, install a puppet (as previously) and then muddy the waters in the news (as previously) while the new president of Ukraine thanks them for liberating his country from the Nazis. (this is a statement of what I believe their plan to have been, not an endorsement!)
- gruez 5y ago>The sheer suddenness of the flip on Russia, and its scale, surprises me What do you mean by this? My impression is that most western countries responded mostly the same way: with more sanctions. Are you referring to all the voluntary actions taken by NGOs/corporations?
- Arnt 5y agoUkrainian pilots are in Poland right now taking delivery of fighter jets. That's amazingly fast. I think the key is that the Ukraine is a democracy. Quite recently it had a president backed by oligarchs, voted that one out, counted the votes fairly, and he left office (not without some pushing and shoving, but he left). That makes this like Hitler's attack on the Czech, not like shooting down a plane or behaving atrociously in Yemen.
- mardifoufs 5y agoDidn't Poland deny they'll send fighter jets to Ukraine?
- Arnt 5y agoI haven't read anything about Polish fighter jets. https://www.flightradar24.com/blog/a-look-at-some-military-activity-in-airspace-around-ukraine/ https://www.flightradar24.com/blog/a-look-at-some-military-a... suggests that an airport in Poland is being used as hub for deliveries from other countries to Ukraine.
- pjc50 5y agoA bit of both, really: more sanctions, going all the way up to Iran / North Korea levels, for a country much more interlinked with the Western world. Contrasting to the lukewarm response to all the previous incidents. The NGOs have snowballed as well - FIFA! The notoriously money-driven international organisation that's holding the World Cup in a Gulf monarchy in a stadium built by possible forced labor has suddenly got a conscience? The IOC, who let Russia back in after a doping scandal under a weird compromise?
- rosndo 5y ago> Look, RIPE have been neutral in every conflict so far in their lifetime This is the first significant conflict during the existence of RIPE.
- tablespoon 5y ago> (The sheer suddenness of the flip on Russia, and its scale, surprises me. We didn't do it when they shot down a passenger jet, or carried out several terrorist attacks with chemical weapons outside the country, or when they supported Assad in Syria, or even the previous time Russia invaded Ukraine. Perhaps if something more graduated had been done earlier we wouldn't be in this position) All those things were awful, but relatively small and often confusing compared to the undeniable full-scale invasion they're doing now. Previously they took small bites, usually through proxies. Now they're taking a big bite, directly.