3 ms·

There are multiple sanctions, affecting government-related personalities and state companies. Why did you decide to make a ban for the total nation despite on t

by yooga 5y ago

There are multiple sanctions, affecting government-related personalities and state companies. Why did you decide to make a ban for the total nation despite on their location, occupation and not same black list of government-related targets?

NamecheapCEO 5y ago
Tax dollars fund that very government whether directly or indirectly. If you have a property this is anti regime or to that effect. We will consider white listng you.
- stanislavb 5y ago
  "Tax dollar"... I don't want to diverge the discussion, but that's the very same reason I've been avoiding "Made in China" products (as much as I can) for several years now.
- concinds 5y ago
  Doesn't every domain name service pay taxes? (including what these users will switch to?) I don't see how taxes are relevant.
- bombcar 5y ago
  I hope you also go forward and ban German domains as their gas payments are still funding Russia.
  - newacc9 5y ago
    Agree, This is some Orwell Hate Week stuff.
mynameisvlad 5y ago
They are a private corporation who is able to choose who to do business with, including blacklisting a full nation. They also have what sounds like a sizeable workforce in Ukraine itself, so it should be pretty obvious why they chose to blacklist the entire nation invading their direct coworkers'.
- hozmoz 5y ago
  If their customers are US persons it's not that simple, because national origin is a protected status. Some US citizens with Russian heritage could have Russian addresses listed like 10 years ago. Would be funny to see this case in court.
  - kube-system 5y ago
    It doesn't work that way. Discrimination doesn't follow the transitive property. To discriminate illegally you have to discriminate for an illegal reason. Discriminating for a legal reason while that person also belongs to a protected class is not illegal.
    - kieloo 5y ago
      What’s the legal reason here though? That’s a genuine question, I don’t know much about US law.
      - kube-system 5y ago
        Given the context of this thread and the current war, I think it's pretty clear Namecheap is turning away customers in Russia's jurisdiction because they don't want to support the Russian regime through taxes. The fact that the people who live under that regime are mostly Russians is tangential. It's just like how Walmart.com doesn't ship to China. That's legal. And if I'm in the US, and I put a Chinese address on my Walmart.com account, and they don't ship me a package, that's not discrimination, that's just a mistake. Now, if Namecheap starts intentionally going after people of Russian origin outside of Russia, that's a different story, but it doesn't look like that's what's happening here.
- friedturkey 5y ago
  It seems like they're banning people who simply have a background in that country. There are a few words for that philosophy, and legality of that business practice becomes questionable.

by yooga 5y ago

NamecheapCEO 5y ago

Tax dollars fund that very government whether directly or indirectly. If you have a property this is anti regime or to that effect. We will consider white listng you.

stanislavb 5y ago
"Tax dollar"... I don't want to diverge the discussion, but that's the very same reason I've been avoiding "Made in China" products (as much as I can) for several years now.
concinds 5y ago
Doesn't every domain name service pay taxes? (including what these users will switch to?) I don't see how taxes are relevant.
bombcar 5y ago
I hope you also go forward and ban German domains as their gas payments are still funding Russia.
- newacc9 5y ago
  Agree, This is some Orwell Hate Week stuff.

mynameisvlad 5y ago

They are a private corporation who is able to choose who to do business with, including blacklisting a full nation. They also have what sounds like a sizeable workforce in Ukraine itself, so it should be pretty obvious why they chose to blacklist the entire nation invading their direct coworkers'.

hozmoz 5y ago
If their customers are US persons it's not that simple, because national origin is a protected status. Some US citizens with Russian heritage could have Russian addresses listed like 10 years ago. Would be funny to see this case in court.
- kube-system 5y ago
  It doesn't work that way. Discrimination doesn't follow the transitive property. To discriminate illegally you have to discriminate for an illegal reason. Discriminating for a legal reason while that person also belongs to a protected class is not illegal.
  - kieloo 5y ago
    What’s the legal reason here though? That’s a genuine question, I don’t know much about US law.
    - kube-system 5y ago
      Given the context of this thread and the current war, I think it's pretty clear Namecheap is turning away customers in Russia's jurisdiction because they don't want to support the Russian regime through taxes. The fact that the people who live under that regime are mostly Russians is tangential. It's just like how Walmart.com doesn't ship to China. That's legal. And if I'm in the US, and I put a Chinese address on my Walmart.com account, and they don't ship me a package, that's not discrimination, that's just a mistake. Now, if Namecheap starts intentionally going after people of Russian origin outside of Russia, that's a different story, but it doesn't look like that's what's happening here.
friedturkey 5y ago
It seems like they're banning people who simply have a background in that country. There are a few words for that philosophy, and legality of that business practice becomes questionable.