5 ms·
My problem with cameras is as a human I'm well aware there are things that I can't see and so i rely on faith. I've driven in dense fog trusting that nobody el
by bluGill 5y ago
My problem with cameras is as a human I'm well aware there are things that I can't see and so i rely on faith. I've driven in dense fog trusting that nobody else would be stupid enough to do the same (fortunately taillights can be seen through fog, but not many other dangers that normally are not on the road, but if so they are dead). I often drive with sub in my eyes at dawn/dusk and trust that the road is clear. I come of the top of hills and trust there is nothing on the other side where I can't see until I'm over the top and it would be too late. Backup cameras have been very useful, and take away something I would have said a few years ago.
The above is situations I know of offhand hand were my vision isn't up to the task yet I do anyway - because I don't really have other options. If other sensors can outdo me then I want them.
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 5y agoi hope you at least slow down around blind bends and corners. that shit is scary. see people racing over such obstacles all the time. i assume there will instead be a crash or deer or corgi or child hiding behind every obstacle
- epgui 5y agoThat doesn't sound like behaviour that is made safer just because a human is at the wheel.
- kelnos 5y agoI don't think that was the parent's point. These things could be made safer with other detection technologies beyond plain cameras. A human driver can make a conscious, nuanced decision to make these "faith-based decisions", but a computer may not be able to. So perhaps it might just completely refuse to drive in those situations if all it has is a camera, but it can't see anything due to fog or terrain, even if it would be somewhat safe for a human to drive in that situation.
- epgui 5y agoIt's really not clear to me what gives a human the nearly-magical ability to make decisions that a computer could not possibly make. If anything, I think we've seen that computers are much better than humans at making decisions in an ever-expanding set of narrow contexts (eg.: chess, go, protein folding...). It's not so much a matter of "can a computer do it better", it's more a question of "when are we going to figure out how to break down the problem in a way that a computer can solve much better than a human".
- bluGill 5y agoExactly humans are bad drivers.
- 2muchcoffeeman 5y agoYour examples are things that can mostly be broken down or modeled logically though. Chess are Go are hard so I guess it seems like AI for them means there some sort of fundamental break through. But consider how a human or even a dog catches a ball. You can study physics and learn that a ball will follow a parabola when thrown and the the shape of parabola is determined by the velocity as it leaves the throwers hand. But none of that matters. You try and catch a ball. Miss a bunch of times. Practice. And then you get better at it. And then you can catch all manner of things coming at you at various velocities. You can unconsciously predict a ball's path accurately enough to catch it without even knowing any physics. Some people can even rely on their instincts. This line of thought is moving goal posts, but I think even for people that have some understanding of what AI is, the current state of the art doesn't pass our intuition about all the things a human does to drive a car. And the sorts of mistakes that current self driving makes don't really seem better than a human.
- epgui 5y agoI absolutely think the type of decision we're talking about can be modelled. I'm not suggesting it's trivial, and I'm not saying there's a nice and tidy closed analytical solution, which is what you appear to be focused on with your parabola/physics-based example, but I absolutely think statistical methods (or "AI/ML" if you prefer) can be applied to the problem. It's pretty much how your brain solves these sorts of problems too, there's no magic to intuition or human decision-making.
- joenathanone 5y agoLiDAR can't see through fog either, Radar and Ultrasonics can but from my understanding those are only used as secondary sensors.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoRight, though IIRC Tesla at least has now stopped using radar.
- joenathanone 5y agoWhich I personally think is a mistake. I'm in the FSD beta and previously Tesla bounced the radar off the ground and was able to see a few car lengths ahead, vision only, not so much. The effect is when stuck in heavy traffic on surface streets FSD beta will think it should try to go around a lead car that is stopped, not knowing there is a long line of traffic ahead of the lead car. I don't see how they can overcome that issue with vision only, especially given current camera placement.
- ec109685 5y agoHow is camera placement worse than what we can see as a driver?
- bastawhiz 5y agoHumans can turn their heads. We also have stereoscopic vision that is able to gain visual clarity with minor movements. Our eyes also mechanically adjust the amount of light they receive, can focus dynamically, and are self cleaning. Could you do this with cameras? Possibly, but it would be a lot of cameras and a lot of mechanical parts—not ideal for a car.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoIt's probably not, but humans have a mental model of the world that cars don't, even ones with relatively advanced computers. Using more and better sensors is an attempt to compensate for the shallow mental model, so you'd have cars still being 'dumber' than human drivers, but if they're all-knowing, that doesn't matter quite as much.
- paganel 5y ago> I often drive with sub in my eyes at dawn/dusk and trust that the road is clear Not sure how to say it, but try to never do that going forward, please, for your sake and for the sake of the others who share the same road with you. Yes, driving "blind" for one second, maybe two seconds (even though it's uncomfortable for me at this point) from time to time is not the end of the world, particularly if you're driving straight and you had "scanned" the road in front of you beforehand, but driving while "trusting" in others will get you into accidents. Never drive faster than you can see.
- chrononaut 5y ago> I often drive with sub in my eyes at dawn/dusk and trust that the road is clear For others left wondering what this meant, I think GP meant "I often drive with [the sun] in my eyes at dawn/dusk .."
- repsilat 5y agoAnd why beholdest thou the floater that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the submarine that is in thine own eye?
- faeyanpiraat 5y agoTo make it more precise: You have to see the point where the end of your braking distance is. This is still not 100% safe (especially in blind corners), but this is the minimum One should do.
- gcanyon 5y agoA younger, stupider me was riding a motorcycle on highway 99 near Merced. It was just after dawn on a Saturday, with literally no one else on the road for miles. So as an experiment, at 70 mph I put my face down on the gas tank: I could see the highway lines on either side, but literally nothing ahead. I wanted to see how long I could hold that position without freaking out. Answer: about twenty seconds. This is far from the only experiment I did back then, I’m lucky to be alive.
- 5y ago
- tintor 5y agoThe problem with lidar + radar is that it can't distinguish between soft drive-able things (smoke, steam, paper bag, grass, water splashing) from hard collide-able things.
- andbberger 5y agoI don't wish to come within 100km of you as a pedestrian
- bluGill 5y agoIf there is anything about what I wrote that is unique to me it is that I'm honest enough to admit to them. Everything I wrote applies to everyone who drives more than a few km in their lifetime. They might not happen everyday, but they happen to everyone on a somewhat regular basis. I really wish transit was better. Even in cities that have what we call good transit, it is still bad enough to too many people drive. (Note, the above issues with human drivers apply to bus and tram drivers.)
- andbberger 5y agoyou should be driving slow enough that your braking distance matches your line of sight. I think most people do, especially in dense fog. there are plenty of cities with great transit, just not in the states
- bluGill 5y agoPeople slow down in dense fog, but they slow down to see taillights distance which isn't enough for anything unlighted. People don't slow down for sun glare - that would be dangerous as the car behind you isn't - instead they assume there is nothing there, or they can figure out something is happening from the other lanes that aren't in the sun glare. Even in cities you consider to have great transit there is room for improvement.
- cameronh90 5y agoThe solution to most of your issues is to drive slower. You should be driving at a speed such that you could stop if anything unexpected is beyond your visual line of sight. If that means you can only drive at 10mph in dense fog, so be it. I personally refuse to drive on a motorway in dense fog becuase there are always pile ups. Honestly, there are just conditions where we shouldn't be driving and society should accept that. Same reason we sometimes cancel flights, busses and trains. As far as Tesla goes, I disagree with their decision to remove sensors from their cars, however I also don't think Lidar, Radar, etc. would help all that much. Radar isn't high enough resolution for driving through dense fog, and Lidar doesn't work in fog. Driving in fog is just hard.