5 ms·
Loopholes in the law are like security flaws in programs. Whenever the letter of the law (code) doesn't exactly match the intent, inevitably some attacker will
by ryandrake 5y ago
Loopholes in the law are like security flaws in programs. Whenever the letter of the law (code) doesn't exactly match the intent, inevitably some attacker will find it and exploit it, especially if there is monetary incentive as is the case in business. This doesn't mean the law is wrong, just that the people who wrote it were careless and didn't think about all the edge cases. What most democratic governments lack is a way to do a quick security update to zero-day loopholes as they are found. These things shouldn't be fixed with years-long lawsuits arguing the intent of the law, they should be fixed with a patch to the actual wording of the law so the intent is more clear.
- Breza 5y agoThe Supreme Court under Chief Justice Roberts has made several high-profile rulings in line with this kind of thinking. They've punted a few cases on the grounds that it's the job of Congress to fix certain types of problems and Congress needs to get its act together.
- bombcar 5y agoIt's even more like that, because age old code (law) gets repurposed and reused and something nobody would even bother trying becomes practical. And in both cases the correct solution is fixing the law (code) but often that opens a whole new can of worms ...
- fuoqi 5y agoEven worse, the precedent-based legal system is quite crazy itself, especially to those who lives in the continental legal system. Instead of patching "code" (law) to new times and sometimes removing parts of it completely, the former uses age-old execution artifacts (court decisions) to determine future execution. Not only it bloats "code" with a truck load of pattern matching branches instead of using a lean algorithm, but it also makes it much harder to consciously evolve the system, which is especially important in the current times.
- visarga 5y agoI think it's meant as a system to ensure consistency and limit the rate of change.
- whatshisface 5y agoImagine a world where there was one law, "be good to each other," and the rest was judicial precedent. What would be the problems? 1. There would be no centralized repository of what the laws were. 2. Even the best interpretation of existing precedent could be wrong or overturned, making any action potentially illegal. 3. The size of the entire corpus would grow with every case and make knowing what the law was only possible for people with a lot of law clerks to research it. The complexity of definitions could grow without bound.
- jquery 5y agoIt also leads to greater predictability. >The reliance on judicial opinion is a strength of common law systems, and is a significant contributor to the robust commercial systems in the United Kingdom and United States. Because there is reasonably precise guidance on almost every issue, parties (especially commercial parties) can predict whether a proposed course of action is likely to be lawful or unlawful, and have some assurance of consistency.[76] As Justice Brandeis famously expressed it, "in most matters it is more important that the applicable rule of law be settled than that it be settled right."[77] This ability to predict gives more freedom to come close to the boundaries of the law.[78] For example, many commercial contracts are more economically efficient, and create greater wealth, because the parties know ahead of time that the proposed arrangement, though perhaps close to the line, is almost certainly legal. Newspapers, taxpayer-funded entities with some religious affiliation, and political parties can obtain fairly clear guidance on the boundaries within which their freedom of expression rights apply. >In contrast, in jurisdictions with very weak respect for precedent,[79] fine questions of law are redetermined anew each time they arise, making consistency and prediction more difficult, and procedures far more protracted than necessary because parties cannot rely on written statements of law as reliable guides.[76] In jurisdictions that do not have a strong allegiance to a large body of precedent, parties have less a priori guidance (unless the written law is very clear and kept updated) and must often leave a bigger "safety margin" of unexploited opportunities, and final determinations are reached only after far larger expenditures on legal fees by the parties. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_law
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoThe difference is lawyers are paid to find loopholes. And to persuade judges and juries their creative interpretation is valid. Software lacks the persuasion element. The CPU either runs the code or it doesn't. You fix edge cases by making all possible states explicit, not by arguing with the CPU that it should do something differently to set a precedent.
- ISL 5y agoBug bounties (or zero-day sales) are an expression of that persuasion.
- jka 5y agoA trade-off here is that it seems unlikely for a legal team to be able to humanly attempt tens of thousands of slight variants of a legal argument and still be allowed to participate, whereas with computers and network services, fuzzing tends to scale and continue fairly reliably (partly because it often goes unnoticed).
- renewiltord 5y agoYeah, but the intent isn’t something the legislature knows. The outcome is the intent - since there are multiple participants and they are negotiating.
- nicoburns 5y ago> What most democratic governments lack is a way to do a quick security update to zero-day loopholes as they are found That's not necessarily true. The solution is to give regulatory agencies more leeway to enforce and shutdown these violations. It's only really cultural bias against "big government" (and towards letter-of-the-law rather than spirit-of-the-law style enforcement) that prevents this. If you are consistent enough about doing this, then you massively disincentivise companies from exploiting these loopholes in the first place as they know they're likely to get heavily penalised for it.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>The solution is to give regulatory agencies more leeway to enforce and shutdown these violations. Or just ignore them. No need to get all jackbooty with broad laws and subjective enforcement powers when the basic law and basic enforcement covers 99.999% of cases.
- FpUser 5y agoThis is very slippery slope. It is not my friggin job to figure out the "spirit of the law". I can read letter of law and follow it. If law makers lack mental capacity to "stress test" their creations and incorporate "patches" when bugs are discovered they should find some other job. Otherwise everyone will be on the hook for some imaginary "not following spirit". Might as well hire shamans
- egypturnash 5y agoThere is a grey area between the letter and intent of the law but it takes a special sort of wilful misinterpretation to end up with "driving onto a little cart that goes about two hundred feet along a rail, then comes back" as "travelling by rail". Especially when there is apparently a whole pile of paperwork that had to be done to officially register this little cart as A Canadian Rail Line. These people know damn well what the spirit of the law is and put a lot of time and effort into coming up with a way to violate the spirit but not the letter of it. The only way you can get to that point via a slippery slope is to bring your own barrels of lubricant and spend a while clearing rocks and trees and other obstacles off of your slope. You might even have to put some effort into increasing the grade of that slope.
- _3u10 5y agoit's not a loophole, the law says they have to ship via rail from a different country so that's exactly what they are doing. if the law specifies a minimum distance they will build a circular track and run the train long enough to meet the minimum distance. If it specifies track length they will just build track that long, if it specifies minimum geographic distance they will find a further port. The law is stupid, so this is what it incentivizes, the Jones act is like a Soviet Nail factory. My business gets credits from our vendors if we bring customers from other competitors, if it's a new customer we have a vendor we work with that provides very cheap options so we sign them up with a competitor, before onboarding them with the vendor. If the customer is with one of our existing vendors we switch them to a different one. EVERYONE is happy, all our vendor reps are making their numbers, executives are making their competitive advances, even the cheap company is making bank because none of the customers ever even use the service.
- allturtles 5y agoI'm not sure why you say this is not a loophole. What you're describing is exactly what a loophole is. A loophole means exploiting the technicalities of the letter of the law to dodge its intent.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dane-pgp 5y ago> If it specifies track length they will just build track that long, if it specifies minimum geographic distance they will find a further port. I wonder what the law would have to say to produce the legislators' intended result. Possibly they could require companies to define, for each journey: * Point A - the average(?) location of where the fish are caught, and * Point B - the average(?) location where the fish are sold to the public or stored (for the majority of the time they are stored). Then there could be some requirement that there be two points, C and D, with the following properties: * the fish pass through points C and D on their way from point A to point B, * points C and D are on the main Canadian rail network (such that most rail track in Canada can be reached by a train starting at point C or point D), * the minimum rail distance between points C and D is some percentage P of the straight line distance between A and B, and * the fish travel only by rail between points C and D. The precise value of "P" would have to be chosen by looking at examples of intended paths and thinking of possible unintended paths.
- adolph 5y ago> Loopholes in the law are like security flaws in programs. For a law to have a loophole it must already be misaligned to its user's interests.
- allturtles 5y agoWho are the 'users' of a law? A government might pass a law to reduce air pollution from factories. Obviously this is 'misaligned' with the interests of factory owners, who will seek out loopholes to exploit. However it may be very well aligned with the interests of citizens at large.
- adolph 5y agoLet us consider the users of a law are those entities which are primarily affected by it. A loophole is a legal method that can only be used by some users that gives them some advantage over other users.
- shuntress 5y agoThis is why most good laws are written with the understanding that disputes will be solved by a complicated neural network that draws on distributed resources for consensus.
- mcguire 5y agoKeep in mind that there is an intelligent cut-out in the system: the judiciary. They exist because the law is not a computer program and because loopholes are not like security flaws. In this case, the DoJ (officially) noticed the situation in August 2021, meaning the judiciary has not had time to work its magic. When they do so, they will evaluate a stack of arguments about the meaning and results of the law (in a non-computation sense of "evaluate" and "stack"); what they will not do is interpret the law like a series of if-then statements. At that point, legislators can then "patch" the law if they feel it necessary. (Do you realize exactly how bad "a quick security update to zero-day loopholes as they are found" would be?) (Knowing only the facts in the article, I would be willing to bet that some judge is going to say, "haha, yeah, good try, but no." But then I don't know all of the facts of the case.)
- londons_explore 5y agoTypically when a judge says no to a case like this, they have to come up with a definition of something in the law that is not met. For example, they may say "It does not qualify as travel on a railway if the load does not travel from one station to another station. In this case, since the loading and unloading occurred at the same station, this load did not travel by rail, and therefore the Jones Act was violated". That new decision then becomes part of the law (case law).
- macinjosh 5y agoYou are describing an authoritarian government.