4 ms·
"You can get a Kindle Fire and a new top-of-the-line e-ink Kindle Touch for less than the price of an iPad. It’s a very different take." But few will want to c
by ctdonath 15y ago
"You can get a Kindle Fire and a new top-of-the-line e-ink Kindle Touch for less than the price of an iPad. It’s a very different take."
But few will want to carry both. This is the one problem with non-general-purpose tablets. Various discussions I've seen today imply, by intent or by chance, getting more than one tablet. To succeed in the long run, users must see the device as My One Tablet - which will include anywhere/anytime Internet connectivity (note the absence of a Fire 3G).
- tsm 15y agoIf I have the money, I'd be just as glad to separate my ebook-reading from everything else. When I read an ebook, I do want an eInk screen, ridiculous battery life, and no distracting apps or websites.
- wanorris 15y agoMy problem is that I ultimately find an e-ink Kindle too limited as a reading device. I have a substantial number of ebooks in PDF format, and only a minority of them are effectively readable on my 2nd gen Kindle. (There are other use cases like comics and cookbooks where e-ink falls down on the job as well.) Honestly, my Android phone with ezPDF is a better reader. So something like this looks just about perfect.
- tsm 15y agoMy completely subjective personal preference is better than your completely subjective personal preference! No, in all seriousness you make a good point about PDFs. I eventually realized that reading, say, a programming book was best done with a dead tree and that I should stop struggling with my Kindle. As a PDF, the text was a bit too small. As a converted document, the reflowed text killed the formatting, which was also no fun. Full-size PDF would be nice.
- redthrowaway 15y agoI currently carry around an MBP and a kindle. I could see (in some hypothetical, far-flung future where touchscreen keyboards weren't utter crap) dropping the laptop for a tablet, but I could never see dropping eInk for anything suitable for a general-purpose tablet. Barring some eInk-led hybrid, I simply can't see using a general-purpose tablet as a reading device. The kindle is simply far too good. I've been reading ebooks on my laptop for years, and I've read more books in the six months since I've gotten my kindle than I had in the 6 years prior. It's just that good. The kindle isn't a tablet. It's your library in your pocket. Don't confuse form with function.
- cageface 15y agoI currently have a MBP and an iPad but I really dislike reading on the iPad and I think it's quite likely my next round of devices will be a MB Air and e-ink Kindle. Ironically the new MB Air is so light and portable it undercuts most of the value of the iPad for me but I'd still like a comfortable reading device, preferably one I wouldn't be devastated to lose at the beach.
- Someone 15y ago"tablet. To succeed in the long run, users must see the device as My One Tablet" I do not think that is the only solution. Windows 8 aims for "a device that, on my request, can behave as if it is mine". That aims at a future where tablets/laptops/phones/ebook readers are plentiful, and, oftentimes, the only thing users carry around (if even that) is the key that makes those devices 'theirs' on demand (see also: Star Trek. Ever seen anybody there who said: hey, that's mine!?)