3 ms·
I'm not arguing that this price is correct, just that the OP was over the top. (In fact, I'm a strong believer that the correct economic equilibrium is for the
by jessriedel 15y ago
I'm not arguing that this price is correct, just that the OP was over the top. (In fact, I'm a strong believer that the correct economic equilibrium is for the grants to pay for the publication process, with all publications being available free of charge.) If Six Flags amusement park takes advantage of their local-monopoly by charging $3 for a Coke on a hot day, this is an inefficient situation but it isn't appalling. A bit of perspective!
On the other hand, if the university was charging the students $10/hour to access journals they needed to read to graduate, that might indeed be appalling. But, as I originally emphasized, students don't have it that bad!
- nitrogen 15y agoOk, I see your point. Still, I can't help but feel like your original counterargument (and the position of the journals) is similar to the argument that getting hit in the head every day with a spoon is better than getting hit every day with a club. It's a tactic used by the copyright industry, for example. They'll say, "Don't like being sued for $1.92mil? How about we shut off your Internet access instead?" Internet disconnection seems a lot less bad than being sued into oblivion, but it's not the only other option (e.g. copyright owners could leave TV shows on Hulu and Netflix instead of teasing with one season, then taking them down). So to sum up, I'm just trying to avoid and counteract the use of some rhetorical techniques I find off-putting, such as https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Door-in-the-face_technique https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Door-in-the-f... https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/False_dilemma https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/False_dilemma