4 ms·
Also, on the subject of the dichotomy, I'd quite like to actually see the specific details of the plan to end homelessness, costed, with some sort of serious le
by roenxi 5y ago
Also, on the subject of the dichotomy, I'd quite like to actually see the specific details of the plan to end homelessness, costed, with some sort of serious legwork proving that it hasn't been tried and failed before.
As far as I'm aware we've had centuries of rhetoric where people have promised everything from small reforms to big sweeping programs to open revolt and replacing of governments in various well-intentioned attempts to end poverty. So far, none of them have worked.
There is a shortage of evidence that we can end poverty by trading away rich people having interesting toys. There is a surplus of evidence the other way around; the enlightenment was enlightening and has had an outsized impact on achieving the outcomes people want.
- astrange 5y agoHomelessness isn't caused by poverty in the US (or drugs), it's caused by not having enough homes. This sounds tautological, but the homelessness rate in West Virginia is not that high compared to SF, which doesn't match the poverty rates or the opioid crisis. SF spending even more money on it won't help as long they're willing to do anything except building homes - all they can do is bid up the price of existing ones forever.
- onion2k 5y agoit's caused by not having enough homes California has 9 empty homes for every homeless person. https://www.self.inc/info/empty-homes/ https://www.self.inc/info/empty-homes/
- wbsss4412 5y ago> What is an ‘empty home’? >An empty home is what the government refers to as a ‘vacant housing unit’, which, for whatever reason, is not occupied by a citizen. This can include vacation homes but also properties which have sold but are not occupied. Not sure this implies what you believe it to imply. If you actually look at the data they’ve mapped out in that article, you’d see that California actually has a shockingly low number of “empty houses” per homeless person - the lowest in the nation. Mississippi has 166, Indiana 151, and West Virginia 128!
- onion2k 5y agoThe point is that clearly there are enough homes, they're just not being distributed and occupied by people properly.
- wbsss4412 5y agoExcept your point isn’t at all correct. A home that has no one living in it because it is in the process of changing hands(sale, looking for a renter) is not something that signifies a distribution problem. Your number overstates the actual number that are habitable by those without houses by a unknown, but likely very large factor. Additionally, California is HUGE. Housing location isn’t fungible. You can’t address Bay Area homelessness with empty houses in Redding. The “we already have enough houses” argument is a gross oversimplification, that constantly gets rolled out by people who think the status quo is ok, when it clearly is not.
- astrange 5y agoVacancy truthers are one of the most incorrect groups around for how much they’re convinced of this. A house could be marked “vacant” if the owner is still moving in, or if the inside is gutted and uninhabitable, or if they just didn’t turn in their census form. https://darrellowens.substack.com/p/vacant-nuance-in-the-vacant-housing https://darrellowens.substack.com/p/vacant-nuance-in-the-vac... At least one of the Painted Ladies is counted vacant but actually uninhabitable. But you could solve homelessness this way if you moved everyone to Detroit. Maybe.
- karpierz 5y agoSo, I think there's two classes of homelessness: transient and chronic. Transient is the class that would be fixed by adding more housing. It's when you leave an abusive spouse and have nowhere to go, or you miss one too many rent payments. Chronic is the class that has some more fundamental concern that leads to them being homeless. That's stuff like chronic physical or mental illness, substance abuse problems, etc. That needs more support than just a home. https://www.homelesshub.ca/solutions/prevention/addressing-chronic-homelessness https://www.homelesshub.ca/solutions/prevention/addressing-c...
- astrange 5y agoGiving someone a home - or actually, forcing them into one - is a good step towards ending their substance abuse habit though. Being stuck outside is depressing and they need something to entertain themselves. I don’t think it’s actually always the case that the drug habits cause the homelessness. It doesn’t help that the government tends to steal all their stuff in sweeps.
- Cthulhu_ 5y ago> So far, none of them have worked. Or have they not been implemented? I haven't seen 'housing for the homeless' programs around here yet, at best it's dubious charities like the Salvation Army doing some work for them. The thing is, these programs cost money, time, resources and people. And I think that last one is a big issue, because few people want to actually become a carer for recently-rehomed people.
- TimedToasts 5y agoOn what basis are you listing the Salvation Army as "dubious"?
- coldtea 5y ago>So far, none of them have worked. Half-arsed implementations, without real concern for the homeless from politicians, haven't worked, that's true. Which of them combined free and/or cheap housing, health and mental health services to trouble homeless, community building, job/education plans (for the homeless than are capable), and welfare (for those that aren't, e.g. mentally unstable, or sick, etc), plus innovations in housing, and doing it in non fire-and-forget way that will just build a soon-to-be ghetto? Instead there are fragmented attempts, that touch isolated aspects of the greater issue, and people are often abandoned after a "here's your housing, now bye!" stage, that only works for a small percentage of cases of homelessness.
- eutropia 5y agoBasically: Land Value Tax set to 90%+ of rents. But it would take close to a generation for it to start shaking out in the efficient ways.
- netcan 5y agoSo... "Eradicating poverty" may be a little more opaque than one might think, and context matters a lot. If you live an isolated peasant existence, is poverty nonexistent or is it universal? Is a person living in a shared room tenement "living like a prince" because elements of his material existence are similar to medieval castle life... or does the prince or pauper question have a social/cultural/class element to it Homelessness is less opaque. If you narrow the discussion to this, than there are possible answer. IMO yes, there are plenty of examples/evidence of homelessness being more and less prevalent. You can find both in poor, rich, urban or rural environments. Homelessness is probably never literally eradicated, but 0.1X is achievable, and you can find such 10X discrepancies between different cities, countries, decades and whatever else you might accept as existence proof . I don't think it's possible to "cost seriously" though, at least not fully. These aren't usually the kind of policies that are only or even mostly about direct funding. They also take time, decades, to develop.
- schwartzworld 5y ago> Is a person living in a shared room tenement "living like a prince" because elements of his material existence are similar to medieval castle life... There is no nuance to the answer. There is no meaningful and sincere way to interpret sharing a room in a tenement as living like a prince.