5 ms·
I've been wondering, why write like this? This comment makes no sense to me and, I bet, most other commenters. I have a friend who also talks like this, he's a
by stavros 5y ago
I've been wondering, why write like this? This comment makes no sense to me and, I bet, most other commenters. I have a friend who also talks like this, he's a conspiracy theorist deeply lost in his web of conspiracies.
It's almost like it's the conspiracy theorist's dialect, where it's information- and reference-dense but transmission-poor, because all conspiracy theorists in one group speak the lingo so they all understand the random words scattered about.
- kragen 5y agoI suspect you're replying to someone suffering from schizophrenia, which makes it difficult to organize speech and writing clearly sometimes. But maybe they just speak English as a foreign language, and not very well?
- stavros 5y agoOh hmm, that would be bad, though it looks more like my friend's writing (who, now that you mention it, I'm not entirely sure doesn't have schizophrenia, hmm) than, say, TempleOS's comments. It's coherent, just uses way too many references for outsiders to understand. Maybe you're right, though, thanks for clarifying!
- kragen 5y agoIt's at least somewhat coherent, but who is Melian? Are we talking about the residents of Melos? (That would make sense in context if we take Thucydides' word of what happened in the Melians' negotiations, but I wasn't familiar with the history.) Why is "Piper" capitalized and "chinese" not? What's with the "spooks leaders" grammatical incongruency?
- stavros 5y agoNow you've made me wonder how much overlap there is between schizophrenia and the conspiracy theory community. It's interesting to think that it's possible that a few people with schizophrenia started it (they'd be likely to, I guess) and everyone else who joined just copied their writing style.
- croon 5y agoMy sibling suffers from schizophrenia. They're not involved or take any interest in any conspiracy theory or related community, but their delusions are definitely similar to those of conspiracy theories (but even less coherent). I wouldn't be surprised if involvement or stumbling into a conspiracy theory community could feed those delusions, but can't speak to that.
- stavros 5y agoHmm that makes sense, thank you.
- kragen 5y agoSo here are two alternative hypotheses: ① Language use is an ingroup signifier, and by writing like this, they are identifying themselves as the sort of person who knows Putin's career began in the КГБ; knows that the Rasputitsa foiled Napoleon, the Mongols, and Hitler; has read enough of Thucydides to know what arguments the Athenians used to justify mass-murdering the Melians; and doesn't particularly care about capitalization, punctuation, spelling, or grammar. Perhaps on rereading the comment thread they feel self-satisfaction in the contrast between their knowledge and my floundering ignorance, or perhaps they are hoping to signal to other people who share their background. Moreover, this sort of shibboleth is a fairly reliable signal; outgroup members who attempt to imitate the ingroup will invariably slip up and use the wrong punctuation mark or something. ② By referencing bits of common knowledge rather than explaining each one, they can lay out their theory of the causality of these geopolitical events in three lines rather than six paragraphs. This is both less effort to write and, for their ingroup audience, less effort to read. In both cases a necessary condition is lack of interest in communicating with the outgroup. I just did something similar (though, I hope, less extreme) in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30505214 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30505214. I figure that if someone doesn't know what CNG, Fischer–Tropsch, Teamster OOs, Jet A-1, fleet organizations, bunker fuel, etc., are, they can google them; if I tried to explain them it would just get in the way of understanding my already overlong sentences with too many nested clauses which frequently overflow the stacks of the brains of the humans.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoI don't know what comic book you read about schizophrenia, but that speech pattern has nothing to do with the profound mental illness. My MIL (RIP) had it all her adult life, and she never sounded anything but British.
- kragen 5y agoI don't have experience with having schizophrenia (I'm fairly sure), but I've had some experience with other people who have it. It can manifest in different ways. My condolences about your MIL.
- mech422 5y agoI actually thought it was just one of those AI bot rambles... I keep seeing articles on here about how good the new AIs are at writing, but it always seems pretty incoherent to me...
- catchclose8919 5y agoI don't know if you're realizing it, but you're being quite offensive to the parent poster... I don't know who (s)he is, but I know this "communication style" and it's also my preferred default way of communicating when I don't have to talk with people I don't share much context or to whom I may want to sell/advocate something :| It's about being dense and DRY while still saying a lot by painting a rich and nuanced context. Sure, it might be more prevalent amongst conspiracy theory people, but it's not a hallmark of them. Professionals like eg. surgeons also use dense jargon + funny-ish allegories and references when talking to each other. It's basically like writing Perl, or dense Haskell, but for human2human communication... there's a beauty to it :)
- stavros 5y agoWhat's the offense? I didn't mean any. > It's basically like writing Perl, or dense Haskell, but for human2human communication... there's a beauty to it :) Sure, it's great when you're in a room of people who you know share your jargon, that's why jargon exists. I wouldn't bat an eyelid if someone here talked about AES or LTV or conversions or funnels, but I bet that very few people here understood what the GP was talking about.
- catchclose8919 5y ago> why write like this? This comment makes no sense to me > transmission-poor You're insulting their communication skill, but some (I'd say possibly many) people actually enjoy reading/listening to this kind of communication. I actually really enjoyed it and found it funny and witty, and satisfying especially because it made me google for ~30sec to find out about Thucydides and Melos to be able to decode "old Melian", and then more to solve the puzzle of the "Piper" - although native Enlish speakers are more familiar with the The Pied Piper of Hamelin I'd guess or at least with the "pay the piper" expression. I actually find regular low-density conversations excruciatingly boring so tuning the density way up and sprinkling some puzzles in there improves my ability to focus and not tune out as I do in many conversations. It's a form of communications that helps AHDHed-techno-creatives like us follow and enjoy conversation and reading more actually, not transmission-poor but on the contrary more like transmission-enhanced, but probably only for a subset of people with brains wired a particular way. (Now that I think about it, even the sci-fi literature that I enjoy reading, eg. Charlie Stross, Vernor Vinge is a bit like this comment, although way more diluted probably to appeal to a greater audience... and yeah, I guess conspiracy theories are the lower end trash version of "sci-fi appealing to ADHDed-techno-creatives", so it kind of makes sense.) ...come to think about it, I'd pay an arm and leg for access to a news outlet that would summarize latest news in this writing or talking style + a subtle injection of dark humor into it, and I'm probably not the only one! ...I imagine it with a Tom Lehrer background intro https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=frAEmhqdLFs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=frAEmhqdLFs :)
- cryptonector 5y agoGP's writing is as you describe it, but the idea was quite clear. Right or not, I've no idea, but GP's meaning was clear. I thought it was insightful, in fact -- again, I don't know if it's remotely correct, but it's a possibility I hadn't considered, and that makes it interesting.
- stavros 5y agoWhat was the idea? I honestly have no clue what it's saying, I don't know who the Chinese engineer leaders are, what the idea is, and why it somehow failed? I'm just completely lost.
- cryptonector 5y agoI understood that comment to suggest that China was willing to support Russia regarding Ukraine if the whole operation went smoothly and quickly presented the world with a fait accompli, but that if the whole thing drags on or worse then China might leave Russia flapping in the wind. Is that the case? I've no idea. The comment, however, was interesting.
- stavros 5y agoOh I see, thanks for explaining!
- cryptonector 5y agoMeanwhile the comment in question is flagged and removed. Too bad, now it's hard to understand this entire sub-thread. Aside from being written a bit obtusely and with language HN does not approve of, the comment was, nonetheless, interesting -- at least as I understood it, and I gather you understand as well now. IMO it should not have been removed.
- stavros 5y agoI agree, actually. It wasn't spam or inflammatory.