5 ms·
The opening of the video describes the difficulty (impossibility?) of balancing a bike with the handlebars locked. I've had frustrating arguments with engineer
by JKCalhoun 5y ago
The opening of the video describes the difficulty (impossibility?) of balancing a bike with the handlebars locked.
I've had frustrating arguments with engineers on the degree to which the gyroscopic effect of the bicycle wheels are what keep the bike upright. They seemed to think it's the spinning wheels that allow you to balance. (I suppose in their minds this would explain why it is difficult to balance when rolling very slowly.)
Give the bike a brisk shove, I argue, with no one on it and see how far it balances. In my experience, a bicycle balances for about as long as it takes to fall over.
I see the rider+bike as an inverted pendulum ... or like someone balancing an inverted broom on the tip of their finger if you will. Steering is the rather counter-intuitive means by which one moves the contact point with the ground left and right under the larger mass (the rider) to balance it.
Maybe the opening to the video or the Arduino-controlled contraption (lacking gyroscopic wheels) will get more people to re-think this.
- martyvis 5y agoBalancing is hardly anything to do with the gyroscopic effect of wheels. You balance by steering the bike under the centre of gravity. Veritasium : https://youtu.be/9cNmUNHSBac https://youtu.be/9cNmUNHSBac
- vbezhenar 5y agoGyroscopic wheels allow you to have some time to balance, so you won't fall instantly but have few seconds to move your center of gravity. Try to balance on a bicycle which does not move. While it might be possible for experienced acrobat, it's much harder.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoBut when the bicycle is not moving, lost too is the ability to move your point of balance through steering. That alone explains how hard it is to balance when not moving. I do not believe the wheels spinning give you even a modest assistance in balancing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- galkk 5y ago> 've had frustrating arguments with engineers on the degree to which the gyroscopic effect of the bicycle wheels are what keep the bike upright. They seemed to think it's the spinning wheels that allow you to balance. Hmm, why there is even arguing about rhat, given that there is even technique that every even advanced amateur knows: trackstand https://youtu.be/-0VnQJF_WKQ https://youtu.be/-0VnQJF_WKQ
- notRobot 5y agoRelated video: Veritasium: "Most people don't know how bikes work": https://youtu.be/9cNmUNHSBac https://youtu.be/9cNmUNHSBac
- zardo 5y ago> In my experience, a bicycle balances for about as long as it takes to fall over. I bet you can do a lot better than that with a bit of practice.