2 ms·
If this work as described in the press article, it breaks the second law of thermodynamics, in spite they claim it doesn't. It's based in a research article pub
by gus_massa 5y ago
If this work as described in the press article, it breaks the second law of thermodynamics, in spite they claim it doesn't. It's based in a research article published in 2020, so if they didn't win the Nobel price 2021, it's pretty clear that it does not "generates clean limitless power".
The idea is that at room temperature, the Brownian motion moves the graphene, and that generates a small current in the circuit, so the circuits absorbs some energy from the environment. But there is electric noise in the circuit, and that noise makes the graphene move as a motor and release some energy to the environment. One of the consequence of the second law is that if all the circuit and environment are at the same temperature, the energy absorbed an the energy released are equal, so the net effect is zero.
Now if you look at the resistance, the noise in the circuit makes it release some energy as heat, but the Brownian motion of makes it generate some noise. Again, one of the consequence of the second law is that if all the circuit and environment are at the same temperature, the energy absorbed an the energy released are equal, so the net effect is zero.
And now, considering the diodes, ..., the second law ..., so the net effect is zero.
And now, considering the wires (wires are small resistances), ..., the second law ..., so the net effect is zero.
And now, considering the mechanical support of the circuit (small devices are weird), ..., the second law ..., so the net effect is zero.
The problem is that in spite what the article says, a consequence of the Second Law of Thermodynamics is that if all the device is at the same temperature it's not possible to "generates clean limitless power".