3 ms·
> but it said Inspired by Remy, and linked to this site. That's not how it works guys, my first email was clear enough, full source code and license, not this c
by tossawaybecause 5y ago
> but it said Inspired by Remy, and linked to this site. That's not how it works guys, my first email was clear enough, full source code and license, not this crap. It really is not that hard to create a new github/gitlab repo, do one initial commit and never touch it again.
Whats the net win to society here? Yet another stale repo floating in the wind? It seems like no one wins in this case. The author is free to choose whatever bone-headed license he wishes, and oppose its rules on whoever breaks them but it seems to me like people that use the AGPL don't want anyone to actually use their code and just want to exercise a power trip.
I know, I know the AWS' of the world like to repackage and resell successful open source services and make tons of money off them. But wasn't that the suggested strategy for open source anyway? To provide support and services?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Shared404 5y ago> but it seems to me like people that use the AGPL don't want anyone to actually use their code and just want to exercise a power trip Alternatively, they don't want anyone who isn't going to play nice to reuse the code. Much like proprietary software, or any other software license, you have to follow the rules for what you're using, and in this case the author wants to make sure any changes get contributed back. Also, this doesn't seem like a good usage of a throwaway account as per the guidelines.
- wussboy 5y agoOr the reason for sharing isn’t anything about reuse. Perhaps it’s about encouraging similar uses or about public accountability.
- dec0dedab0de 5y agoThe win is for the end users. If you're relying on a service from a company, and they decide to stop hosting it, or make a change that it is incompatible with your workflow. It is nice to be able to host your own version of it. I can't even fathom being against it.
- behringer 5y agoIn this example, had the company complied with the license, Dutch speakers could still use the software along with any other modifications made, and the original author could have reintegrated those changes with his version.