6 ms·
I enforced the AGPL on my code (2020)
- jsnell 5y ago(2020) Original discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24845878 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24845878
- adenozine 5y agoThis page is an absolute disaster without an adblocker. Good lord.
- woodruffw 5y agoI disabled mine and didn't notice any changes. What are you seeing?
- ijlx 5y agoI disabled mine on Firefox, didn't see any changes. Switched to Chromium (where I don't have an adblocker) and the number of ads was egregious. I count 8 full-width ads interrupting the text at regular intervals, along with one on the bottom that follows as I scroll.
- eliseumds 5y agoIt is really next-level. I'm seeing a gigantic full-width ad every 3 or 4 paragraphs, plus a bottom-fixed ad (10 total). That's nuts.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Shared404 5y ago> There are many Google Adsense ads on this page, if you dislike that, please use the above links or enable your adblocker. There are so many ads because almost none of my visitors use the above options. At least they're honest about it, and give explicit support to using an adblocker.
- philipswood 5y agoYeah, I also find it a bit funny and a bit discordant that he feels so strongly about free software while at the same time not being triggered at all by the internet ad ecosystem and chooses to use that as a way to monetise this post.
- charcircuit 5y ago>I prefer strong copyleft licenses that force you to contribute There is not a common license that does this. GPL only requires you to give source code to the person you contributed it to. Tony changes only have to go to the person who received the software. The changes don't need to be upstreamed. >They claim full copyright as authors (which is wrong, they're not authors and its not their copyright) These copyright markers don't mean they own the copyright of everything being served to you for that page or at least it's very common that it doesn't. The hosting company did write the translation.
- indymike 5y ago> There is not a common license that does this. GPL only requires you to give source code to the person you contributed it to. Tony changes only have to go to the person who received the software. The changes don't need to be upstreamed. That's why the author used the AGPL, which requires you make source code available to users who interact with your service.
- charcircuit 5y agoThe AGPL does not force you to contribute either.
- oneplane 5y agoI'm pretty sure you can make your code so bad that it being available is hardly a 'contribution'. All the AGPL does is force you to make it available, that doesn't mean that anyone is going to be better off for it.
- _carbyau_ 5y agoTrue, however if a user can see the code being run is "bad" then the user now knows. Not many people are going to exercise this right, but having it as an option is nice.
- michaelmrose 5y agoIf you provide obfuscated code you would be in violation of the license. It might even be a factor in higher damages.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tossawaybecause 5y ago> but it said Inspired by Remy, and linked to this site. That's not how it works guys, my first email was clear enough, full source code and license, not this crap. It really is not that hard to create a new github/gitlab repo, do one initial commit and never touch it again. Whats the net win to society here? Yet another stale repo floating in the wind? It seems like no one wins in this case. The author is free to choose whatever bone-headed license he wishes, and oppose its rules on whoever breaks them but it seems to me like people that use the AGPL don't want anyone to actually use their code and just want to exercise a power trip. I know, I know the AWS' of the world like to repackage and resell successful open source services and make tons of money off them. But wasn't that the suggested strategy for open source anyway? To provide support and services?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Shared404 5y ago> but it seems to me like people that use the AGPL don't want anyone to actually use their code and just want to exercise a power trip Alternatively, they don't want anyone who isn't going to play nice to reuse the code. Much like proprietary software, or any other software license, you have to follow the rules for what you're using, and in this case the author wants to make sure any changes get contributed back. Also, this doesn't seem like a good usage of a throwaway account as per the guidelines.
- wussboy 5y agoOr the reason for sharing isn’t anything about reuse. Perhaps it’s about encouraging similar uses or about public accountability.
- dec0dedab0de 5y agoThe win is for the end users. If you're relying on a service from a company, and they decide to stop hosting it, or make a change that it is incompatible with your workflow. It is nice to be able to host your own version of it. I can't even fathom being against it.
- fao_ 5y agoI did try and read it, but the contrast between the green links and the background make it impossible, and actively painful to read
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aaron695 5y ago
- marcan_42 5y agoYet another example of someone who doesn't understand the AGPL and how it doesn't work to protect your (or anyone else's) rights. It really is an utterly broken, non-free license. I've written about this in the past (read the topmost two replies too): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30044019 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30044019 In fact, the author of this article claims to quote the AGPLv3: > If you run a modified program on a server and let other users communicate with it there, your server must also allow them to download the source code corresponding to the modified version running there But that is absolutely not the text of the license. You can check for yourself. That's not how the paragraph is worded at all. If that were the text of the license, it'd be a non-free EULA, since that wording imposes a restriction on usage, violating Freedom Zero. Instead, the AGPL is a non-free copyright license because it violates Freedom 1, by instead imposing restrictions on modification, as I described in the analysis I linked above. I really wish the FSF would stop pushing this nonsensical license and misleading everyone into thinking it does things it doesn't. Their PR around it absolutely does not reflect the actual wording and consequences of the license. It's deceptive and harmful to the free software ecosystem.
- nine_k 5y agoWhat existing sane license would be free comparably to GPL2 level for "normal users", while also preventing the case of Amazon and MongoDB?
- charcircuit 5y agoNone. Being able to make money using other people's software in any way you want is a fundamental part of freedom 0. People using the software for commercial purposes are just as much of a normal user as anyone else. >“Free software” does not mean “noncommercial.” On the contrary, a free program must be available for commercial use, commercial development, and commercial distribution. This policy is of fundamental importance—without this, free software could not achieve its aims. https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.en.html
- 5y ago
- twoxproblematic 5y ago