2 ms·
> if I heat my house now with natural gas or oil, am I really doing the environment any favors by switching to electric where in some regions a very high percen
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
> if I heat my house now with natural gas or oil, am I really doing the environment any favors by switching to electric where in some regions a very high percentage comes from coal (and natural gas and oil)?
Yes.
The precise details will vary by location, but for example this was a very common argument used against EVs, they're just coal powered cars! So the Union of Concerned Scientists did reports on exactly how bad an EV in specific locations would be, and even in highly coal dependant areas, it was still better, today, and would only get better as the grid gets greener.
https://blog.ucsusa.org/dave-reichmuth/are-electric-vehicles-really-better-for-the-climate-yes-heres-why/ https://blog.ucsusa.org/dave-reichmuth/are-electric-vehicles...
Lots of people seem unaware that heat pumps are about 4x the efficiency of even modern gas heaters, so just burning the gas in electricity generators would be enough for us to cut out all Russian imports and more.
You are right that insulation, and efficiency are important (e.g. it makes sense to insulate your house properly when planning a heat pump install, and the oldest and least efficient boilers should be targetted first for upgrade) that was part of my point, see the link to the Energy Saving Trust who have in depth details on exactly which things help the most and cost the least, and look up your local equivalent.
- jaltekruse 5y agoFor the record, while its clear you think I'm not with you, I totally agree with this statement. Increasing demand for electricity is absolutely essential to convince politicians to back the scale up of the grid that will be needed as more people have electric cars and home heating systems. Buying electric everything today creates demand that forces the hand of people debating installing new natural gas infrastructure that will be used for 80 years, or finally saying that it isn't worth it because a high percentage of people switched to electric and we can't justify the cost anymore for a few holdouts on gas, we just force the last few to switch to electric at that point. All that being said, today people are dying, and Europe is afraid to do much about it because everyone has been increasing natural gas use to offset coal, it was a cheap solution to part of the problem. We might not agree that resisting Russian expansionism is an important short term objective, but I believe we need to start acting like Russia rewrote the world order a few days ago and we can either fight that or roll over.