9 ms·
Sci-Hub downloads show countries where pirate paper site is most used
- zelphirkalt 5y agoNow it is called "pirate" to access research, which was financed by the people? I don't think we should attribute such action with any negatively connotated words. It is not like they are stealing anything. They are just accessing what should be accessible to anyone anyway.
- rat9988 5y ago> Now it is called "pirate" to access research, which was financed by the people? Yes it is. The fact there was tax payer money involved doesn't mean any contract with the private sector must be free. Up to the people who found the research to require that it should be published in other means. Grant money comes with many conditions and it's usually not one of them. And when it is, it is respected, from my experience.
- periheli0n 5y agoThere is a lot wrong with todays scientific publishing industry. But this does not mean that their service should be free. Access to research is one thing, organising the review process, print layout, marketing another. Most researchers I know share their preprints for free. But the final peer reviewed & laid out product has added value. The problem is the inflated price that researchers have allowed to be charged for their own product. Partly because many care more about their publication list than about anything else. Rather than downloading illicit copies out of convenience, one should download preprints, engage in their discussion, seek out open peer review, share personal copies of peer reviewed papers, and contact other researchers for their papers. We need to build a community of researchers if we want to take the greedy publishers out of the equation.
- The_rationalist 5y ago
- wongarsu 5y agoIn articles downloaded per 1000 citizen (roughly): China: 17 USA: 27 France: 84 Brazil: 13 India: 1.5 Indonesia: 5 Germany: 17 Singapore: 170 Mexico: 8 Iran: 12 That paints a very different picture from the absolute numbers.
- willis936 5y agoWhy normalize by population and not scholarly output? I suggest number of published academic articles, and even that isn't a proper metric, but it does paint a very different picture than yours. https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/20-countries-publishing-the-most-scholarly-articles.html https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/20-countries-publishing-...
- wongarsu 5y ago> Why normalize by population and not scholarly output? I did it out of personal bias: I use scihub for hobby and work but my scholarly output so far has been 0. How you choose to normalize the table is probably a good litmus test for how you view science: if you think the goal of science is to generate insight you normalize by population, if you think it's to communicate in the scientific community you normalize by academic activity, if you think it's to advance society you normalize by GPD (or HDI or GPI).
- willis936 5y agoI don't think the methodology is necessarily colored by my view of science. My assumption is that most of scientific paper downloads are done by people who are employed to do it. Granted, it's a flawed assumption and there are no metrics on "how many papers are downloaded by which demographics", so we don't really have enough information to make a strong conclusion, but the right answer is probably somewhere in between.
- wongarsu 5y ago> the right answer is probably somewhere in between. Almost certainly. All the views I listed are valid in their own right, and their proportion probably shifts depending on discipline. Anecdotally papers around health, well-being or fitness seem to reach an audience of people looking for self-improvement, meanwhile machine learning papers seem to be read by people on or for their job a lot. Some other disciplines meanwhile don't seem to reach a notable audience apart from themselves. Which is fine in it's own right. I would actually love to see statistics on this, but I don't think anyone is in a position to provide them.
- jari_mustonen 5y agoIt would be nice if Nature noted that there should not even be need for Sci-Hub as scientific literature should be open for everyone.
- wongarsu 5y agoIt would have been a good opportunity to highlight how you can publish articles in Nature as Open Access under a Creative-Commons license so people don't need to pirate them (as long as you have €9500 left over from your grant to cover the fee).
- riedel 5y agoActually our university has dedicated funds to cover open access so you do not necessarily need this in your primary grant. However, it is first come first serve and limited. What is worrying me is that there are so many predidatory open access journals out there and the open access advocates haven't understood the need to limit open access funds to journals that are actually read. And they should make sure that a relevant percentage of the money is actually spent on reviewing and/or editorial work. The money for an open access nature paper is probably well spent in the end. Otherwise publishing preprints is probably the better alternative.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoHow about not feeding predatory publishers money? From my understanding: - The actual research and writing work and most of the formatting is done by the researchers. - The reviewing is done by other researchers donating their time, or rather, using work time paid with public money to work for free for these commercial entities. - Most of the distribution is digital. What actual work worth 9500 EUR (plus whatever they get from subscriptions, because until everyone goes open access there will still be subscriptions) do those publishers do nowadays?
- Schroedingersat 5y ago> What actual work worth 9500 EUR (plus whatever they get from subscriptions, because until everyone goes open access there will still be subscriptions) do those publishers do nowadays? Gatekeeping, degrading the quality of research and keeping the reproducability crisis going aren't cheap you know.
- nostrapollo 5y agoNon-researcher here, but does this imply that China is doing significantly more research than the other countries mentioned? I'd imagine it's either that, or the 'legal' article access systems aren't as accessible?
- WilTimSon 5y agoBased on the stat posted above (downloads per 1000 citizens), Singapore leads, which is interesting. Obviously their number of citizens isn't as high as most countries but that's still such a strong number, maybe there's some students who are randomly downloading all papers they're interested in?
- politician 5y agoOr VPNs.
- kergonath 5y agoIt’s a tiny country with a very good university. I am not surprised at all. > maybe there's some students who are randomly downloading all papers they're interested in? You pretty much have to operate that way anyway. There is just too much stuff to do the old-fashioned “read one paper, get its references, and repeat”. It is much better to get many articles, and then sort them by degree of interest using things like abstracts, main figures, conclusions, etc, before reading them fully. It does increase the number of downloads significantly.
- micromacrofoot 5y agoDoesn’t really imply much without additional info, could just be due to a larger population.
- whimsicalism 5y agoChina is the source of a ton of research in the two fields I've worked in (materials science & machine learning)
- gabriel34 5y agoIt is worth noting that some “nations with fewer scientific resources” provide their students and researchers broad access to scientific papers through their public universities and research institutions. That part of the article seems to be affirming the autor’s prejudice without a shred of confirmation
- sebow 5y agoAnyone knows the infrastructure behind Sci-Hub? I'm asking because I feel like they're vulnerable to be taken down in the future.Maybe IPFS/other are not the best options but some sort of hardened network could benefit such project.
- maxmalkav 5y agoMy opinion is solely based on my personal experience, so take it with a grain of salt. I was enrolled in a PhD program (engineering) around the time Sci-Hub started, we were lucky enough to have access to most papers we needed thanks to the University agreements with Elsevier, IEEE, etc. I did not hear about Sci-Hub until a bit later, when I needed access to some academic papers but remote access to my university network was very cumbersome. I ended up downloading my OWN papers from Sci-Hub out of pure convenience. I have to say I always had mixed feelings (if not just hostility) towards the academic publishing industry, so I was actually happy my papers were available there. During pandemic time I decided to enrol in a MBA in the fields of Humanities (because why not). My experience is that Humanity folks are not very aware of Sci-Hub, probably because they are not so tech-savvy in general, but those that discover it are more than happy to count with this extra resource. Said this, my personal impression is that places like my country are not higher in the chart .. just because Sci-Hub is not better known yet.
- kergonath 5y ago> I have to say I always had mixed feelings (if not just hostility) towards the academic publishing industry, so I was actually happy my papers were available there. You can pretty much always make your own papers available. Some journals are ok with you hosting copies on your personal website, and none of them can legally prevent you from distributing the accepted manuscript, either on your website, things like ResearchGate or repositories like Arxiv.
- nceqs3 5y agoIsn't this not accurate at all due to mass VPN usage?
- mohammad_ali85 5y agoPhD student here. Aside from difficulty of accessing articles who don't have institutional access, it's significantly easier to obtain an article from sci-hub. Enter title or DOI - done. To get the same article using uni logins you need to search via database e.g. Medline, then click on the source button. This takes you to different resources you can download from. Once you click through, you can then download the pdf, unless they've decided ePub is the default option in which case you have change this. Rarely, I've had to sign up to attempt to download an article but find once I've done this, my institution doesn't actually have access. The steps are reduced if you're on campus but not much better to be honest. Absolute mess.
- einpoklum 5y agoArrgh, matie! that Sci-Hub clipper, she be no buccaneer vessel. That ship be loaded from bilge to mast with fathoms and fathoms of blimin' books and papers! Take it from this old salt: Them landlubber publishers be tryin' to hornswaggle ya.
- Ansil849 5y ago> And virtual private networks (VPNs), which are often used to circumvent bans in countries such as the United Kingdom, can skew the results by making it appear that users are in a different country. How does this caveat not make the analysis useless, unless known VPN exits are filtered--which there was no indication of.