3 ms·
So this is trolling from pro-Russia, and/or anti-renewable activists right? From their 'what not to do' section: > Argue about what led up to this energy situ
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
So this is trolling from pro-Russia, and/or anti-renewable activists right?
From their 'what not to do' section:
> Argue about what led up to this energy situation. Yes, Germany shut down nuclear plants; yes, green energy targets pushed the USA and others to reduce domestic oil and coal production.
If you actually want to do something to help, how about following the "Electrify everything in your house guide":
https://www.rewiringamerica.org/ https://www.rewiringamerica.org/
- jaltekruse 5y agoI can assure you I am not pro-Russia. I'm happy to take suggestions on edits for the website. I do support green energy targets, but I believe this situation proves the world did some math wrong. Russia is much more aggressive than we were willing to accept even a few weeks ago. The west has been increasing its purchasing of Russian gas and oil despite the fact they had annexed Crimea and supported the separatists. I think we need to talk about what needs to happen in the short term right now. Most of the discussion I am seeing everywhere is people on the right taking shots at Biden and Germany for shutting down domestic production and caring about green energy targets. Part of what I'm trying to get everyone to realize is that the left and right are on the same side. Conservatives that are taking a second to stop mocking the green energy movement are also shouting "this is why energy independence is national security". I'm trying to bridge 2 sides of the debate, I think us lefties need to accept that energy independence in any means possible might be more strategically important in the short run.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoAssuming you are genuine, there's plenty of sensible advice out there already on how to cut your fossil fuel usage. Linking that to the current story of Russia's oligarchs using their fossil profits to invade and kill democratic neighbours gives people an impetus to do things that will actually make their own life better, but that they may not have heard about, because right-wing propaganda has drowned it out. As I shared recently, most countries will have the equivalent of https://energysavingtrust.org.uk/energy-at-home/ https://energysavingtrust.org.uk/energy-at-home/ Which will tell you ways to save money, and keep your house warmer while also reducing fossil fuel usage. Find and disseminate that, the wider knowledge of fossil fuels being an expensive con will do more to destabilize Putin than anything I've read on your page currently. If you want people to tie it closer to Ukraine, point out that these sites will often tell you how much money you will save by making these choices, get people to donate that money to Ukraine or an organisation that is helping us to move off fossil fuels.
- jaltekruse 5y agoBut obviously people aren't doing this on a massive scale. Despite appliances getting more efficient, energy consumption continues to rise faster than population increases. I'm trying to mobilize a wartime effort of massive reductions to increase western soft power. If just 2-5% of the buildings currently being heated in the world could have their thermostats effectively off that would change the calculus that pretty much all of Europe is struggling with. It is the exact reason we were slow to cut off SWIFT, and we are still holding back on anything like a proactive oil or gas embargo from our side. Those options are totally off the table if we cannot rally widespread support for righting Russian aggression, maybe even going further than lighting up buildings with colors and sending money to a out-manned nation that is under siege.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoEnergy consumption isn't a problem. Only fossil fuel use. And it only benefits Putin to conflate the two of those things, as they are quite distinct.
- jaltekruse 5y agoIn the short term the two are interchangeable, we cannot build enough solar panels and batteries to help the people being killed in Ukraine today.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoSo this is just anti-renewable trolling which happens to help Putin then, ok, carry on and have fun.
- ejb999 5y agoHow does electrifying your house solve the problem? That electricity still needs to come from someplace, and more often that not it comes from a combination of coal, oil, natural gas and nuclear. Maybe someday when we can generate 100% of what we need from renewable sources - but we aren't even close to being there yet, and in the meantime, people still need energy.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoBecause electrical things are more efficient, cleaner and cheaper and just generally better than any alternative that burns fossil fuels directly, so less fossil fuels get burned and less fossil fuels get bought and oil-based economies can't get away with flying 747s into tall buildings or invading their neighbours any more. I don't think this is particularly complicated, but I did just link to a whole book on the topic if you're not getting the general gist.
- sofixa 5y agoIt solves tomorrow's problem. Currently most electrical grids are moving to less carbon intensive electricity generation methods ( even if many still use coal, oil and gas power plants), and if you electrify now, your carbon emissions will drop with the grid's, and the job of "greenify"-ing everything would be done. Furthermore, if you live in a country where electricity produces very low amounts of carbon ( like France or the Nordics), it already makes sense.
- ejb999 5y agoStill think it silly to think that will make any difference - if I heat my house now with natural gas or oil, am I really doing the environment any favors by switching to electric where in some regions a very high percentage comes from coal (and natural gas and oil)? and the more people that switch to electric, and the faster they switch it will increase even more the amount of coal being burned - it just gets burned in someone else's neighborhood instead of my own. IMO, money and effort would be much better spent modernizing and insulating homes and replacing really old appliances (including furnaces and boilers) and thus reducing the overall demand for energy - regardless of the source of the fuel. Reducing the need is hard to argue with - changing where it comes from - when very little comes from renewables doesn't even move the needle.
- Lochleg 5y agoIt would have to be very subtle trolling since mentioning a certain pipe in Canada would definitely have rustled some jimmies.
- sudden_dystopia 5y agoWouldn’t a pro Russian troll be telling you TO argue about those things to divide us??? And why in gods name would an anti renewable activist want to advocate for an energy boycott?? If anything, your comment sounds like a Russian troll by derailing and deflecting the conversation off topic
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoBecause it's been a long standing tactic of fossil fuel booster to make a big deal about how we need to give up stuff in order to fight climate change? Because they know people won't like that message. Whereas, buy an EV or an induction hub, or underfloor heating with a heat pump, insulate your home and your life will get better at the same time as fighting climate change and fossil-fueled dictactorships?
- kkfx 5y agoPersonally I've built my new home, insulation/airtightness/VMC/* and domestic p.v., being full electric and with a small lithium backup enough for passing an evening+night at minimum services (8kWh) + an emergency generator if needed... I doubt I can be considered a "anti-renewable activists", at least, I do that not because of an ideological cause but because I think that's good for me in practical terms (big initial investment, but ars covered for a not so marginal period of time and in case of troubles I expect in service disruption in the future), also I'm not one of the many that think to be environmental friendly because they live in cities and shop by feet few meters away, completely ignoring and rejecting if told, that such lifestyle demand a far big pollution they do not see, just outside their walled garden and sight, not much differently than the classic Orwell phrase: "Those who 'abjure' violence can do so only because others are committing violence on their behalf" but anyway... Also coming from an Italian WWII Partisan family (nephew of) I doubt I can be pro- any dictatorship, but exactly because of what I learn from my family I know how important is distinguishing "the real enemy", it's soldiers, some of them "without their knowledge", and it's own people... The "so called green tech" can be theoretically cheap, but it's not really cheap on the market for various reasons, and while can work very well in certain sites can't do the same everywhere. For instance being in French south p.v. is effective, if it became legal here a hyper-small Pelton in the creek can push me toward real self-sufficiency for the MTBF of such system at least, but elsewhere? In EU most people live in dense cities, no chance for effective and substantial energy improvement of buildings, their are tight and not "well oriented", there is not much room for renewable in general there. People living north if they do not have options for combined hydro+wind do not have much choices either, and they need far more energy to heat for a much bigger time period. That's JUST to talk about private housing. Now if we also put on the table industry needs and EVs... We can't even with all nuclear, coal, oil, ... combined produce enough electricity for all. Not only: so far lithium tech is good enough for certain appliance BUT is not really recyclable (yes, experiments, startup do exists but they are experiments and startup not well established tech and developed industry at scale) and batteries does not last longer. If only they can last 20 years buying lithium storage, not just as a very expensive home-wide UPS, can be interesting for full autonomy, but that's not the case so far, and even if prices have fallen much in "historical terms" it's still too expensive for its lifespan. Even to stabilize the net it's then not an option, and that's a big problem if we really push renewable. Most people ignore the fact that to keep AC systems alive supply and demand MUST match, at a certain scale demand tend to be constant enough to offer network stability, below and above that it's extremely hard to keep the power on-line. Long story short: I like much the idea, but I still have to see a fully working implementation for the masses or anything that can scale for industrial needs everywhere. Even at residential, individual home level, the sole practically usable at a certain scale today the balance is not really green: hot water is made with a heat-pump + classic resistance (and that's the best for solar since it's load remain almost flat, no phasing effects) it's not really complex but have a 10 years life expectancy and it's not much recyclable. Solar panels theoretically last longer, BUT practically if evolution continue it's not much interesting keep them more than 10 years, batteries last 5-8 years for EV, perhaps 8-10 for p.v. usage if not much stressed. Again really hard to recycle, mining what's needed for them is not cleaner than digging for oil and so on. Essentially we do not have anything really circular at actual population scale. We can be "long enough and recyclable enough" only for a far smaller population that being smaller can use certain resources on scale at a renewable level. If you do not propose a big genocide... There is no real "solutions", only different paths toward the unknown.