8 ms·
Are smartphones serving as adult pacifiers?
- vangelis 5y agoIf you're at a rave, pacifiers are serving as adult pacifiers.
- nonrandomstring 5y ago> Are smartphones serving as adult pacifiers? Absolutely yes! I wrote plenty about it in Digital Vegan but there's only time and space to touch the surface of the psychology and research in a short accessible book. https://digitalvegan.net https://digitalvegan.net I'm working on a new study with attachment theory experts looking at the ways we form emotional bonds with digital devices and how they become transitional or proxy objects.
- MandieD 5y ago“Digital Vegan contains 50 short chapters suitable for daily reading…” Hey, just about right for this year’s Lent, in which I intend to closely examine my relationship with technology, because I can’t tell where “mommy brain” stops and where a deeper problem with attention and concentration driven by how I’m using the internet begins. I’m kicking it off with Carr’s “The Shallows,” but your book might be a good way to ensure I get through something every day.
- nonrandomstring 5y agoFWIW Mandie, here's my list of modern pop tech critique, all topics that DV touches at least tangentially. Far more than 40 days and nights worth of reading Shoshana Zuboff Big Other (surveillance capitalism) Virginia Eubanks Automating Inequality Sophie Brickman Baby Unplugged Cory Doctorow Radicalized Mike Monteiro Ruined by Design Nick Srnicek Platform Capitalism Paul Kingsnorth Life versus the machine Heather Burns Understanding Privacy Roger McNamee Zucked: Waking Up to the Facebook Catastrophe Siva Vaidhyanathan Antisocial Media: How Facebook Disconnects Us Catherine Price How to Break Up With Your Phone Thomas Kersting Disconnected: Protect Your Kids Against Device Dependency Nicholas Kardaras Glow Kids Zeynep Tufekci Twitter and Tear Gas Lelia Green Technoculture Douglas Rushkoff Team Human Jaron Lanier Ten Arguments For Deleting Your Social Media Carissa Véliz Privacy is Power: Why You Should Take Back Control Xiaowei Wang Blockchain Chicken Farm Jenny Oddell How to Do Nothing: Resisting the Attention Economy Wendy Liu Abolish SIlicon Valley Jonathan Taplin Move Fast and Break Things Andrew L. Shapiro The Control Revolution Lawrence Lessig Code and Other Laws of Cyberspace David Shenk Data Smog Douglas Rushkoff Cyberia Paulina Borsook Cyberselfish.
- MandieD 5y agoThanks - ones dealing with children and tech are especially interesting to me, as I've got a toddler who I've so far been able to (mostly) keep away from the glowing screens, but who has already started grabbing my tablet and smacking the keyboard when I'm working from home and he's not at daycare. I've seen the effects of too much device access at too young an age on younger relatives, and I really, really don't want that for my kid.
- nonrandomstring 5y agoSame situation, 5 yo daughter. I'm very split on this. So, after the keyboard bashing I gave her a disused keyboard to play at while I work. Soon she wanted to join me and type so we actually turned it to a positive. She can type her name and lots of other words aged 5. Those must be good motor skills, and I am not too worried because there's' lots of bike riding, jui-jitsu and climbing in our lives too. Then I created a special "OS" (in bash/python) just for her - obviously no network but she can start her favourite music my typing "music" and stuff like that. I think it's the small screens, swiping and infantile apps that bother me. I have no smartphone or tablet, so she doesn't see behaviour to copy. Some of her friends have phones (I am furious at those parents) but we laugh at how they "get stuck on them" and that "phones are for babies". She tells her friend she's a "real hacker" - which I am sure will lead to some fun situations at school at some point. My theory is that it's about how much of an interest you take. I forgot to mention Sherry Turkle too. She has some good ideas on technology, attachment and kids.
- leobg 5y agoAt first glance: Very intriguing way to look at it. On second thoughts: The analogy doesn’t seem to hold. People who put their phone away for the weekend actually report feeling happier and more relaxed. I don’t think that would be true of a baby if you take its pacifier away (provided the baby is conditioned to use one for emotional self regulation).
- nicoburns 5y agoIf you took a baby's pacifier away and actually gave it your full attention it probably would.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- leobg 5y agoVery true. Wouldn’t need a pacifier in the first place then!
- LeifCarrotson 5y ago...are you a parent? Apparently not! Two parents can give a child their full attention, but infants can be fickle, picky creatures. I've been stuck in quite a few situations where the pacifier got driven off in Mom's car and the backup isn't in my bag - stranded away from supply lines without the required materiel. My son would only pull on his thumb or mine for a couple seconds before wailing...and, yes, trying again, but it was a pretty short attempt and a high duty cycle on the crying. You do parents a disservice and assume the worst, probably based on a few narcissistic jerks, sure, but if there was anything I or many other parents could do for their kids we would do it. If I could have made my son comfortable in those situations I would have. Sometimes they don't want Mom and they don't want Dad, they don't have to poop and they don't want to sleep, they don't want to play, they don't want to eat, they don't want to bounce, they don't want to sing....they want their pacifier. Nothing else will do. Not even Grandma...
- leobg 5y ago
- mike50 5y agoIs legacy media wasting my time with click bait?
- zeroonetwothree 5y agoWhen hasn’t it done so
- WhompingWindows 5y agoClick bait from all content producers exists to waste our time. The one goal of clickbait is to get you to click so their ads load and they make a few cents. Has anyone seen this trend on YT recently? The videos are much shorter and much more click-baity. I do worry that it's pushing our attentions down down to the lowest common denominator, which seems to be 30-60 seconds.
- genewitch 5y agothere was an indication that YT shorts was able to be gamed, and it was unstoppable. I tested the theory and it was true for a short while, but it looks like google was able to "stop it". If you uploaded a #shorts tagged video it would be fed to everyone seemingly "at random" and you would get a ton of views and interaction. I uploaded a dumb 8 second video about the local mail truck and it got 800 views, far more than any other video i've uploaded in the last decade. I don't know that google even actually fixed it, i think the idea that it could be gamed sort of fixed it by deluge of #shorts videos, this diluting the pool so that your video was less likely to appear at random. This is simplified a bit; but the point is, once upon a 2008ish, youtube decided that monetization should be harder, and this was around the time that fully monetized videos were required to be 10 minutes long. This was a paradigm shift, considering that in the old days there were length limits to individual videos imposed on youtube (and google videos), first being quite short (possibly even 10 minutes) and eventually ran out to 30 minutes, and now where i'm unsure if there's even a 'real' limit on video length. I know there are some 20+ hour videos on youtube. So in order to appease advertisers, youtube made it so content producers had to fill their time with fluff, which is why there was an adage that still holds true - on a computer, when a youtube video starts, press "3" to skip the irrelevant stuff (hey guys its... hit the like and...). Tiktok and instagram have brought back the drive-by short videos, youtube attempted to capitalize on the short video craze (originally vine et al started the trend, but further back even ytmnd and .webm did it as well), and now it's a race to the bottom. I fully expect the most popular video by view count and impact to be less than 8 seconds long in 2022.
- atomicnumber3 5y agoI'm currently watching a major military conflict unfold in near real-time via Reddit, so I'm going to go with either no, or yes but the definition of pacifier is really weird. Glibness aside, I think sure, for some people all of the time, and for all people some of the time, a phone is just a pacifier. But it's also our window into basically the entire wealth of human knowledge, indexed better than it has ever been in all of history. So I really think that's something worth not selling so short.
- jt2190 5y ago> But it's also our window into basically the entire wealth of human knowledge… Yes, true, but the article discusses how physical presence of the device itself reassures its owner, and conversely how upsetting it can be for the owner to be without their device. Part of that reassurance may come from, as you say, having a window into the entire wealth of human knowledge, or from having a connection to friends and family, etc.
- AniseAbyss 5y agoI recall that the Japanese were the first to make waterproof mobile phones so that people could keep chatting while taking a shower. On a personal observation: in the beginning I frequently forgot my phone. Now it is as standard to me as a wallet or keys. I can subconsciously feel its weight in my pocket.
- jrumbut 5y agoInterestingly I forget my wallet and keys all the time (to the extent it is possible since most trips require driving where I am). My phone and wedding ring are the only items that give me the "something is missing" spidey sense.
- fein 5y ago> But it's also our window into basically the entire wealth of human knowledge If you're consuming all of your coverage through reddit, I think you're conflating one side's propaganda with "knowledge". It (the internet) used to be a window into a wealth of human knowledge, but at the current state of things it is merely another vector to help you mainline <insert large company's> propaganda engine and, for most that don't run ad blockers, stuff you full of advertisements. Ten, maybe 15 years ago your statement would have been more true, but the internet has become progressively smaller and the content more curated by big money interests than any time in the past.
- zeroonetwothree 5y agoPacifiers aren’t necessarily bad. We all need some help feel better
- chiefofgxbxl 5y agoThe analogy to pacifiers may be overly condescending (equating adults to children), but in general I have adopted the view that smartphone usage in public is essentially second-hand smoke, and that hopefully within the next 1-2 decades the public will finally begin to recognize this as widespread addiction and begin setting some limits. I got into computers when I was in early elementary school, and that began my track toward exploration and software development. There's no doubt that my mom's worries of me being addicted to the computer were absolutely true - entire summers were spent on the computer. What's different about computer addiction and smartphone addiction is that computer usage is more limited in where you can do it. My computer-addicted young self would not have been able to whip out a desktop computer at a restaurant, barbershop, or waiting in line to pick up an order. But with smartphones essentially being "pocket computers", people can use them anywhere - even driving. I do believe in personal choice, so I don't want to be heavy handed, but I imagine our society will need to grapple with this problem. I see couples on dates with each other in restaurants, both on their phones nearly the entire time scrolling through endless feeds. I watch sports events where any small break in play people need to pull out their phones. There is no presence anymore, and public space (along with suburbanization) has rapidly eroded over the past 10-15 years since smartphones were invented. Now commercials for phones/5G normalize the idea that you should be able to download/stream a movie on your phone walking down a sidewalk. There's a balance that needs to be struck here, and it's going to be difficult to reach because we're still relatively in the infancy of these fancy electronic gadgets. Particularly in the US where individualism and personal choice is so deeply part of our culture, it will be difficult to restore the public space so that we can come to expect if you go out in public, people are actually... present and there. But somehow we eventually came to the same conclusion with banning smoking in restaurants et. al.
- themodelplumber 5y ago> essentially second-hand smoke Even if we took this as a valid statement on its face, it's also - A personal safety tool used by vulnerable people to protect themselves, from joggers to the mentally ill - A way of checking in on one's family member suffering from illness - Access to information that is contextually important like specific venue masking guidelines - A means of spending time with family; as long as work knows they can reach you, you are good. Etc. I think it's a good idea to ask not only if we still want to be "blame the tool" people, or "blame the people" people, but also whether we want to open up this general context where we enshroud efforts to project values in a casement that looks like generalized blame of device and person both. IMO we can do better than methods that turn into "see something, shame something" especially when so many details matter.
- blululu 5y agoQuick take: this is second rate research (b-school professors have all the irrelevance of real academics with none of the substance). The research from UPenn seems blissfully unaware of any previous research on attachment objects from psychology. They start with a click bait title and then try to bolt on some poorly construed studies. You would never throw away an attachment object after 2 years. A smartphone is a meta object that acts as a portal to a great variety of potentialities. Trying to describe it in terms of a physical object ignores the last 50 years of media theory.
- anothernewdude 5y agoYou literally throw away actual pacifiers and replace them.
- shephardjhon 5y agoThere is the CS's famed eletism and gate keeping. Just because its not Harvard or Stanford its not relevant? I am a CS grad myself but there is so much toxicity in the community when looking at places like HN. And I am not saying anything about your point. Maybe you are right, I just hate that you start off with 'b-school bad' argument.
- ciphol 5y agoI think what they actually said was "Just because it's business school it's not relevant"
- blululu 5y agoMy initial vitriol against academics was perhaps unnecessary. The research is clearly uninterested in the large body of serious research around this subject. It is perhaps unfair to say that low quality research is inherent to business school academics in general.
- recuter 5y agoWell, somebody can just falsify that claim by posting some well known excellent scientific research written by business school academics.
- civilized 5y agoAs they say on Twitter: it's bad on purpose to make you click.
- themodelplumber 5y agoIt's funny to see words like "isolation" when so many people use their phone for what they'd more likely describe as "solitude," but also "protection," and in many cases things like "connection," etc. So instead of allowing ourselves to be railroaded by someone's unfortunately one-sided choice of descriptors, maybe we should ask: - Pacifier _and also_ therapeutic assistant? - Adult _and also_ continually developing human? Otherwise, playing one side of the dichotomy is by its nature demonstrating something far worse than a smart phone, which itself is a practical ocean of different engagement levels, options, and tools. It's demonstrating a single engagement level, a single option, a single way of using a tool.
- kosasbest 5y agoIt amazes me that the form factor of a phone has stayed with us for so long. I genuinely thought there would be some brain-computer interface by now that is invisible and we could interact with Google et al when we needed to quickly summon information about a topic / situation.
- beebeepka 5y agoNueralink and their ilk haven't killed enough animals yet. That's why you don't have these devices attached to your head. Give it a decade or so
- superkuh 5y agoIs radio serving as an adult pacifier? Are newspapers serving as adult pacifiers? Are books serving as adult pacifiers? They're ways of distributing information and how you use them is entirely up to you. I'm sure some people are. Some aren't. It has very little to do with mobile computers with wireless modems.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoFair point. I might need an actual pacifier that says, "Just look back down to your cell phone" on the front.
- mickduprez 5y agoIt's not the smart phones, it's the social media app's on them. I don't remember anyone staring into their nokia 3110 every 5 minutes (except for a quick game of snake in the waiting line perhaps :) )
- ivansavz 5y agoarchive link https://archive.is/QuZGr https://archive.is/QuZGr
- kkfx 5y agoI know a thing well: smartphones do serve very well for deep and spread surveillance. They are almost substantially mandatory (many banks in many country mandate their own app for web auth, for instance) and they are macro-spy instead of micro ones, that instead of being payed bye the one who spy are payed by the one that get spied who also ensure proper power and connectivity. Other side effects are far, far less relevant...
- cyanydeez 5y agois the republican party serving as pacifiers for political action?
- bjoli 5y agoOff-topic anecdote: I made one of those smartphone magnetic stands/hand supports with a pacifier just to annoy younger colleagues that were glued to their phones. I got a pacifier with a solid base, clipped off any small pertrusions, sand papered it flat, drilled a small pit and glued a magnet in. Smoothed out the edges, applied a thin layer of epoxy as lacquer and support. The best part is that I used a strong magnet so that I could hold the phone in my mouth by the pacifier whenever I needed both hands. Anyway, fashion changed and suddenly my pockets became a little bit too tight, so I stopped using it.