3 ms·
> If France had had that attitude in the past the United States would likely not even exist. And it probably would have been better that way! The British would
by rayiner 5y ago
> If France had had that attitude in the past the United States would likely not even exist.
And it probably would have been better that way! The British would have ended slavery earlier, and we would have developed like Canada and Australia.
Nobody knows what’s the “right thing” when it comes to the development and history of nations. The United States has good intentions, but it’s foreign policy is tremendously destructive because Americans have a childlike understanding of how the world works.
- cuteboy19 5y agoThat's not how it works. The British would have faced the same problems that the Americans did: Half a country that is deeply dependent on slavery and completely unwilling to let go
- jacquesm 5y ago
- rayiner 5y agoUnlike say Germany, which believes in minding its own business and looking out for its own interests.
- jacquesm 5y agoGermany is still immensely traumatized from WWII, believe it or not, and has lots of internal issues resulting from the reunification, ironically, after the fall of the former USSR. That is why there is tremendous friction before Germany will get involved in anything that looks like a war. This is not exactly news though.
- hollerith 5y agoLooking at its energy policy, I wonder how competent Germany is at looking out for its own interests.
- jacquesm 5y agoI think that Germany could not conceive of the situation that we are in today.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hollerith 5y agoIt is understandable that the average German voter was surprised, but if the German government really could not conceive that Russia might attack one of its neighbors, then it is definitely incompetent.
- jacquesm 5y agoAgreed. I have not seen any indication of either preparations underway or a more coordinated response, it looked like they got caught flat footed. Compared to the intelligence out there, the speech by Biden and the troop movements it seemed to me that the writing was on the wall, but it is possible that the German authorities/BND were given false assurances, there is definitely some precedent for that during this conflict.
- antifa 5y agoNot even just in the past 3 days, I've seen a staggering number of people on HN who apparently don't know the USSR ended in 1989 or that Putin openly dislikes communism, among the plethora of other stereotypes of American arrogance and hubris, so yes, probably unlike the user "rayiner".
- jacquesm 5y agoHaving seen the whole thing from up close and having lots of contacts in Eastern Europe - former USSR countries and also in Russia I have a bit of a home court advantage here but still it boggles the mind how short sighted and detached from reality some of this is. Weirder still how exactly those people are accusing others of not knowing how the world works. The world is a messy, extremely interconnected hairball with several major fraction lines running through it each of which has the power to reduce our population problems in a heartbeat. To ignore that - or to try to live as though these problems do not exist - has to be the ultimate in being willfully blind. It probably is just some kind of fear response, like being told that your safe little haven isn't really safe. But as long as nuclear weapons are armed and ready to go - on all sides - there are no safe places, and any conflict that involves a nuclear power has the potential to spiral completely out of control, more so when autocrats and dictators are involved.