5 ms·
How does SSL work with this? Wouldn't a lot of certificates get broken?
by colinprince 15y ago
How does SSL work with this? Wouldn't a lot of certificates get broken?
- mildweed 15y agothe SSL would have to stop in the EC2 instance where the bulk of the 'browser' is. Its then up to the Silk infrastructure to ensure the transmissions from the Fire to EC2 would be secure as well.
- thepumpkin1979 15y agoSounds like a "secure" man-in-the-middle "hack"...?
- mike-cardwell 15y agoOpera Turbo is a similar service to this, but it doesn't intercept https connections. Hopefully Amazon's service will behave the same way. If not, there will be a privacy shit storm.
- johnpaulett 15y agoFrom the FAQ [1]: What about handling secure (https) connections? We will establish a secure connection from the cloud to the site owner on your behalf for page requests of sites using SSL (e.g. https://siteaddress.com). Amazon Silk will facilitate a direct connection between your device and that site. Any security provided by these particular sites to their users would still exist. [1]: http://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html//ref=amb_link_357584342_3?ie=UTF8&nodeId=200775440&pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_s=center-21-0&pf_rd_r=0TVXTAYDDY8QCBJQHQB1&pf_rd_t=201&pf_rd_p=1321395082&pf_rd_i=B0051VVOB2 http://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html//ref=amb...
- raganwald 15y agoI’d like to hear more about what “facilitate” means. Is the connection from the device right through EC2 out to the site secure, even from Amazon? Or, is the connection from the device to Amazon secure, and the connection from Amazon to the site secure, but Amazon is acting as a man-in-the-middle? Or, is the connection from the device to Amazon insecure, Amazon is acting as a man-in-the-middle, but the connection from Amazon to the site is secure? I may be having a slow neuron day, but the wording of the FAQ doesn’t seem to definitively state which of these three cases holds?
- johnpaulett 15y agoIt sounds like Amazon is a effectively a man-in-the-middle. Hopefully the device-to-Amazon connection is secured by Amazon, but I can not find any details. The privacy implications of all SSL traffic being decrypted on AWS are a bit scary. I am guessing the end user will never see broken SSL certificate warnings (as you would expect in a regular browser), since Amazon can add a "Amazon MITM" root CA certificate to the browser.
- srdev 15y agoIf Amazon does, in fact, act as a MITM, then that's a deal-breaker as far as I'm concerned. Edit: The more I think about it, the more I think it is likely that they are just passing along the connection. SSL is designed to prevent MITM attacks. They would have to provide their own certificate which would cause browser warnings. They could write their browser to ignore certificate problems for Amazon certificates, but that strikes me as a pretty gaping hole.
- raganwald 15y agoWhat you say is very true, however when you say that SSL prevents MITM attacks, you are assuming that “their browser” always lives entirely within the device. If their browser has code operating on the device and in the cloud, then their browser won't generate certificate warnings because there isn’t a man-in-the-middle between their browser and the site, there’s a man-in-the-middle between the device in your hands and the site. It would be insecure against Amazon snooping or modifying the communication, but still generate the appropriate warnings about bad certificates. I think the answer is, run “off-cloud” when you want privacy from Amazon.
- srdev 15y agoYes, I hadn't considered that possibility. The picture in my mind was some sort of hybrid operation where some of the work was offloaded, in which case you would still have to properly support device-to-site SSL links. So I guess the issue of privacy still remains up in the air. I was hoping to be an early adopter of this, but I think I'll wait to see how the SSL via Silk situation pans out before putting down cash.
- mike-cardwell 15y ago"We will establish a secure connection from the cloud to the site owner on your behalf for page requests of sites using SSL (e.g. https://siteaddress.com https://siteaddress.com)." So they are MITM'ing HTTPS connections. "Amazon Silk will facilitate a direct connection between your device and that site. Any security provided by these particular sites to their users would still exist." So they aren't MITM'ing HTTPS connections. What the hell? Which is it?