4 ms·
I wonder, if Russia wins the war and claims Ukraine is part of Russia…. do they assume responsibility for Ukraine’s debt?
by duxup 5y ago
I wonder, if Russia wins the war and claims Ukraine is part of Russia…. do they assume responsibility for Ukraine’s debt?
- johnebgd 5y agoHard to see them losing a ground war to take the territory with such numerical superiority but it's been done before in Israel. Even if they lose the ground war initially a long term insurgency will develop and Russia will have trouble swallowing it.
- HWR_14 5y agoDo the Russians really have numerical superiority in the theater? I thought Ukraine had 250,000 troops (which includes the conscripts) and Russia had 150,000 in the area.
- ch4s3 5y agoThe Russians seem to only have air superiority and some advantages in armor. It's not clear they're going to win this.
- redisman 5y agoIf they buy more time they’re getting thousands of anti armor and anti air weapons very soon.
- ncallaway 5y agoThey haven’t even had unchallenged air superiority. Many Russian planes have been shot down (including two troop transports flying into contested airspace ?!), and Russian conveys have been successfully targeted and destroyed by Ukrainian air strikes. I think it’s fair to say that the Russians have air superiority, but most analysts expected them to have unchallenged air power by this point, and they definitely don’t have that
- ch4s3 5y agoYeah, they're really putting up an impressive fight. Ukrainians should feel really proud right now. I hope the incoming weapons make a difference, and I'm hoping we're getting them good intelligence.
- dijonman2 5y agoMy wife is Ukrainian, her family is currently safe. They’re a strong group of people. I’m proud of her, her country, and all they stand for. They know what true suffering is, having lived through multiple disgusting periods of abuse. We’re chatting here on HN from the safety of our chairs pontificating and pretending to be smarter than we are and they’re out there fighting for their lives. I hope Americans take notice and realize how crucial freedom is, and what it really takes to defend it.
- psyc 5y agoFreedom? Or sovereignty? Because I bet Americans would die for sovereignty. But we take liberty so much for granted that we continually debate trading it to boost all manner of hypothetical social utilitarian metrics.
- ch4s3 5y agoYeah, for sure it’s easy to talk thousands of miles away. I really want them to succeed and I’m looking for ways I can help. At the very least I’m trying to be a public voice in support of military aid, and cheering them on in general.
- ergocoder 5y agoInsurgency can be easily handled if you don't have to consider the humane aspect. Saddam handled insurgency pretty effectively.
- pcwalton 5y agoThe Soviet Union didn't, in Afghanistan.
- brap 5y agoThe Israelis knew that if the Arab armies, which greatly outnumbered them, won and conquered the land, then the holocaust would pale in comparison. They had nowhere to go, they had to fight. The Ukranians are not in the same place (the Russians will not slaughter them), but they are definitely fighting for their home, and they also have nowhere to go. Fear is a very powerful motivator. Now in contrast, imagine what the Russian soldiers are thinking. Forced to kill people so similar to them. They don’t even want to be there. I don’t think it’s unlikely that Russia will lose this one in the long term.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y ago> The Ukranians are not in the same place (the Russians will not slaughter them) In other circumstances, I'd agree with you. But everybody is wondering what Putin's options are? His Blitzkrieg didn't work at all, he tried several times and failed. What is happening now is a regular war on several fronts with civilian casualties. So what is going to happen if months pass and Ukraine is still fighting? Will he be able to swallow it? Many people are afraid he is too megalomaniac to do that and when pressed can start being more brutal than he is now. He is regarded as a war criminal already, what else does he have to lose? Those who listen to Russian propaganda will believe all he says anyway; the rest can be kept in order by an extended police state.
- zie 5y agoLOL. Zero chance :)
- vkou 5y agoI don't know about that, but if that happens, I do know that Ukraine will definitely, and unfortunately assume responsibility for Russia's sanctions.
- sovietmudkipz 5y agoDidn't that already happen when the Ukraine split away from Russia in the 90s? It would be funny if it happened again.
- HWR_14 5y agoIt's not a corporate merger. Who is going to make Russia pay Ukraine's debt?
- lostdog 5y agoThere's a long history of other countries deciding that your country still owes them money, and that they're entitled to collect. In Mexico, for example, Benito Juarez's faction won a civil war, and then refused to pay the debt run up by the enemy faction. The French, who loaned the money, didn't care, and invaded Mexico. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benito_Ju%C3%A1rez#Ju%C3%A1rez_and_the_French_Intervention_(1862-67) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benito_Ju%C3%A1rez#Ju%C3%A1rez... When Venezuela defaulted on its debt in 1902, Germany sent a fleet to blockade its port, demanding that Venezuela pay customs duties on every good that passed through the port until the debt was repaid. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venezuelan_crisis_of_1902%E2%80%931903 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venezuelan_crisis_of_1902%E2%8... Countries have been forced to repay debts that maybe they didn't deserve, and penalized in extremely severe ways when they didn't pay. You could imagine the U.S. and Europe lending Ukraine a ton of money right now, and then claiming that it becomes Russia's debt if Ukraine is conquered, and seizing assets to force repayment. It would be a pretty crazy thing to do, but hey, the 21st century is already chill so whatever.
- HWR_14 5y agoSorry, a large country can certainly enforce debt collections. Part of me is thinking how depressing, but realistic, it would be that the west would be more aggressive in seeking repayment than punishing Russia for invading. Thanks for your examples. I was thinking about post-WWI Germany. The breadth of examples certainly helps move away from that kind of punitive and world war starting example. Which makes it more realistic. Maybe a statement from the West that this will be the case can encourage Russia to not aim for totally conquering the Ukraine. I can see a second salami slice by Russia as an option.
- TrapLord_Rhodo 5y agolol - with such fragrant disregard for international law in attacking the nation and you think they are gunna give two fucks about who the previous regime owed money to?
- mFixman 5y agoIf Russia wins the war the government will probably not claim that Ukraine is part of Russia. They can make a couple of puppet states that take Ukraine's old debt plus the cost of the Russian invasion.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> If Russia wins the war the government will probably not claim that Ukraine is part of Russia. Putin already made that claim (blaming Lenin for creating Ukraine as a polity from properly Russian territory and Stalin for transferring additional properly Russian territory to it) when announcing the war, as did Russian state media just today, in what seems to be a pre-written victory announcement that was then deleted.
- int_19h 5y agoRussia won't annex Ukraine outright. The most likely scenario is establishment of a puppet state after ripping off some territories - Donetsk and Lugansk, almost certainly, and likely also a land corridor to Crimea. The fact that Belarus is onboard makes me think that there might also be some plans of some kind of "East Slavic Union" faux-confederation into which the new Ukraine puppet state would be forced, perhaps within the already-existing framework of the Union State of Russia and Belarus.