4 ms·
The other choice is a siege. See the Siege of Sarajevo [1]. A dramatically numerically inferior force (by 5:1) laid siege to a numerically superior, but poorly
by somenameforme 5y ago
The other choice is a siege. See the Siege of Sarajevo [1]. A dramatically numerically inferior force (by 5:1) laid siege to a numerically superior, but poorly equipped, force that was intermittently supported by the UN/NATO. It lasted just under 4 years, and ended in a stalemate and some absolute horror stories from survivors.
And of course if a city under siege cannot get sufficient resources in and is not self sufficient (let alone while under siege), then a siege can end a conflict extremely quickly.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Sarajevo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Sarajevo
- mderazon 5y agoDoesn't apply to Gaza apparently
- ethbr0 5y agoThe problem with Gaza is as one of my friends from the Middle East summarized it: no government* really cares about the Palestinians. Sure, they'll use them for propaganda purposes, and to rail against Israel, but when it comes to taking actions with limited resources? Well, they don't care that much. * Except maybe Iran. But there are a lot of mixed motivations (and religious baggage) between Hamas and Iran.
- 7373737373 5y agoTime for a (drone) Kyiv Airlift? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berlin_Blockade#Start_of_the_Berlin_Airlift https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berlin_Blockade#Start_of_the_B...
- anikan_vader 5y agoNot easy to do an airlift when your opponent has air superiority. The United States had guaranteed air corridors to Berlin.
- thelittleone 5y agoAlthough not suited to an airlift of heavy items, a swarm of drones would be super difficult to defend against in an urban environment. Have them drop thermite or pipebombs or just draw fire to find enemy positions, or distract them during an assault.
- xorfish 5y agoPutin doesn't have the time for a siege. The propaganda machine still speaks of a special operation to liberate Ukraine. You can't keep up this picture for long. There are too many communication channels between Ukranians and Russians that will chip away at this warped image of reality.
- realusername 5y ago> You can't keep up this picture for long. There are too many communication channels between Ukranians and Russians that will chip away at this warped image of reality. Especially that on Putin's side, they are only "defending separatist regions", just about any picture of the conflict contradicts the official narrative, there's no way to spin it, they can't even talk about any victories.
- kkfx 5y agoCutting aqueducts in most cases means people running out of water in short time, considering the actual whether. While it's perfectly possible to store non marginal quantity of water most people do not do that in cities, exactly where water is less available. Contaminating water with mild bacteria not enough to kill 99% of the people, but enough to reduce their capacity is another quick and easy task, water tend to be much controlled nearby sources, not as much below, sure boiling it suffice, but boil demand energy and in most cases having energy in a city it's not that easy, not much wood, almost nothing to produce it in place. Food might last longer but not that longer: most people are not really combatant and do not want to fight till victory or death. Consider a thing: modern society is hyper fragile respect of the past, especially cities where very few people can block many others, almost the opposite of a very large slice of human history. Also modern society are not much ideologically propelled and widespread corruption of most actual government do make most people thinking that one or another does not change almost anything. There is a minority of fanatic, that's what they are, nor really Patriots, who accept a fight at any price, but those tend to be unpopular in their own people even more than in the enemies. Also smart people know that there is no point in fighting a lost war, it's better to inject themselves in the winning order to undermine it slowly from the inside.
- 5y ago