5 ms·
Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger are 91 and 97 years old respectively and have famously bad diets and do no exercise yet are both healthy and productive. Many
by paulpauper 5y ago
Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger are 91 and 97 years old respectively and have famously bad diets and do no exercise yet are both healthy and productive. Many other examples, like William Shatner, who is 91. Or Henry Kissinger, 98. I think much of conventional wisdom about weight, diet, health is wrong. Outcomes are influenced much more by genes than anything else. That's how these old guys keep going when the 'conventional health wisdom' by the experts says they should be dead.
- marvin 5y agoHard to reason from world-famous anecdotes. They could also just have supremely healthy genetics, thus explaining why they’re able and willing to work very hard far beyond the normal retirement age. You’d need large studies to learn more.
- victor106 5y agoThis also surprises me. Is this survivorship bias? Also, I think a stress free happy life could be equally or more important than diet and exercise.
- JackMorgan 5y ago> Is this survivorship bias? I'm not sure if you mean this in jest, but yes it is. So if you meant it as dry humor, you made me chuckle. It's almost too on the nose, considering we're talking about the habits of literal survivors being taken out of context.
- zemvpferreira 5y agoIf you're interested in learning more about the factors influencing ageing, you could do worse than listening to dr Horvath talking about epigenetics: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A_aaBKubJnA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A_aaBKubJnA The summary as I understood is that hereditary factors will determine about 40% of your ageing rate. Doing the right things (eating your greens etc) will affect maybe 10-15% of your ageing rate if you're generally healthy. Avoiding the bad stuff (obesity, smoking, alcohol) will drastically affect your healthspan and lifespan. It's hard to take these men as an example not to care. Who knows what genetic cards they were dealt, and who knows how much luck or invisible preparedness they have with their bodies. The conventional health wisdom you mention is borne of millions more examples and unequivocally points in the direction of keeping your body in as good a shape as possible through your whole life.
- reducesuffering 5y agoI'd posit that more important to longevity than diet, is the relation to retirement and work. It may not be much of a coincidence they're working and living until their nineties. I've noticed too many people decline precipitously after retirement when there was nothing in the way anymore of TV and sedentarism, which is the natural state of things in modernity.
- anon2020dot00 5y agoThis is completely unsupported. Instead of jumping to conclusion that conventional wisdom is wrong, maybe show the evidence about their supposedly bad diets? The big assumption in this statement is that they have a poor diet but where is your collaborating proof? The only famous bad diet attributed to them is drinking the occasional soft-drink (Coca-Cola) and that can hardly qualify as a bad diet. Unless you have first-hand knowledge on their diets or detailed second-hand sources that go beyond the occasional soft-drink. Your claim about debunking conventional wisdom on diets such as not over-eating or avoiding excess sugar is totally bonkers. I'm pretty sure they have a healthy diet, avoiding junk food and such but I may be wrong (since I don't have first-hand knowledge) and so better to post sources when making such contrarian claims such as dismissing the entire consensus of healthy and unhealthy eating.
- nostrademons 5y agoBuffett is famous for his fast-food heavy diet. Here's one article that quotes Bill Gates: "Warren Buffett's close friend, billionaire and Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates, says Buffett mostly subsists on a diet of hamburgers, ice cream, and Coke. Celebrating 25 years of their friendship in 2016, Gates wrote in his blog, Gates Notes, "One thing that was surprising to learn about Warren is that he has basically stuck to eating what he liked when he was six years old." He recalled a time when Buffett stayed at his and his wife Melinda Gates' house, and opened a package of Oreo cookies for breakfast." https://www.mashed.com/240851/this-is-why-warren-buffett-really-eats-so-much-fast-food/ https://www.mashed.com/240851/this-is-why-warren-buffett-rea... https://www.gatesnotes.com/About-Bill-Gates/25-Years-of-Learning-and-Laughter?WT.mc_id=07_05_2016_10_25YearsWarrenBuffett_BG-LI_&WT.tsrc=BGLI https://www.gatesnotes.com/About-Bill-Gates/25-Years-of-Lear... Anyway, I think the medical establishment is very much aware that genes matter more than diet, exercise, or anything else they can do. I had one extremely socially awkward PCP who, upon intake, was like "Asian? That's good, it means you'll live longer. Good genes." The problem is that such comments are both off-putting, potentially illegal, and completely unhelpful, because patients can't control their genes but can control their diet and exercise. There are a lot of statements that are true but useless, and discourse tends to select against them.
- 5y ago
- kuhewa 5y ago> I think much of conventional wisdom about weight, diet, health is wrong. If they weren't alive, it would be a few other old people you would use as examples. Even if conventional wisdom on those topics was bang on, you'd still be able to use this reasoning thanks to survivorship bias.
- itzprime 5y agoWhile he does not live "healthy", I read somewhere that he is particular about getting a certain amount of calories each day.