6 ms·
The Effects of Finland's Possible NATO Membership (2016) [pdf]
- jsnell 5y ago(2016)
- belter 5y agoShould have been there. Updated.
- tonymet 5y ago
- Hamuko 5y agoGot any other shitty ideas that have basically zero upsides but almost infinite downsides? A nation of five million people and zero nukes starting an armed conflict with the biggest nuclear power in the world? And for what, a patch of land that basically no one thinks about?
- emteycz 5y agoRussia is big only in land area. It's not that big by any other metric. Definitely not the biggest nuclear superpower. Their tech is outdated and not maintained well. Their command, logistics and planning are chaos. Their usable resources are already nearly depleted.
- csee 5y agoAnyone have estimates on how many people Russia could kill in the worst case situation of a full scale launch? Would it be the extinction of humanity due to the nuclear holocaust that follows?
- jl6 5y agoWorst case? I think it would be hard to guarantee actual extinction. Probably some people would survive. But most wouldn’t, and civilization as we know it would most certainly be over.
- emteycz 5y agoThe question is if the nukes will even be able to get into air, travel to their targets, and correctly perform their function there. I'm increasingly sure it wouldn't work, these people are full of shit. Also, I think the technological gap is now simply too large. The recon capabilities of today + various types of UAV and new kinds of manned aerial vehicles, coupled with new generations of weapon systems, could very well mean we would pluck the nukes from the sky mid-way.
- headmelted 5y agoThis seems like an incredibly bold assumption to roll the dice on, you know, given you’re talking about almost all life on Earth. I’ve also never heard of a defence system that can pluck that many missiles out of the air. The closest I’ve heard of is the Iron Dome - which would not be able to stop what you’re talking about at all. I would think the nation that has that capability would make it known for geopolitical reasons.
- jl6 5y agoWhile I agree that anti-missile technology is extraordinarily unlikely to be as effective as hoped for upthread, if it did exist at that level of capability, the owner may still wish to keep it a secret. If it becomes known that your enemy possesses the capability to neutralize your primary weapon, you are likely to take counter-counter-measures, which could undo the advantage.
- histriosum 5y agoCitation needed... As far as I know, no country today has a viable anti-ballistic missile defense system that works well enough to stop even a small percentage of the number of nukes that would be triggered by a MAD style endgame. What technology are you talking about?
- jl6 5y agoI wouldn’t bet literally everybody’s life on that. They’ve had 30 years of fat oil revenues to rebuild capability.
- emteycz 5y agoSeems like they corrupted it away. The market won't innovate as well if it's not technological merit but money under a table that decides which company gets a defense deal, and when a considerable portion of that money is embezzled. And you can't get as much military resources built with these obstacles. Maintenance becomes non-existent, or done only for show. Etc. Russian military is also brainwashed with their pseudo-scientific geopolitical propaganda, your army simply can't work well if it thinks that bullshit is true, just look at the idiotic "tactics" they're using right now.
- kitten_mittens_ 5y agoHow Finnish is Karelia still?
- skrebbel 5y agoIn that it has pine trees and lakes, very. Otherwise, not at all.
- doikor 5y agoEffectively all finns left Karelia after the war. Those few who did not got moved to some shithole in Siberia by Stalin. edit: This is what Stalin did to most non slav peoples in Russia close to any major/important city or resource. (in this case Saint Petersburg)
- Hamuko 5y agoI don't think Russia has really made any efforts in Karelia, so it might basically look the same as when Finland lost it 80 years ago.
- tonymet 5y agoThere are few. I have friends who go there a couple times a year to bring clothing and supplies.
- nwah1 5y agoMaybe if they had their own RS-28 Sarmat weapons
- gumby 5y agoI remember this coming up at the end of the USSR when Finland said that they didn’t want it. Word was also spread around that it was polluted with nuclear crud etc so wasn’t worth taking back. The explanation that all the Finns had left 100 years ago makes more sense (though the nuclear pollution argument is sadly at least plausible - USSR was not particularly careful in that regard)
- Ekaros 5y agoAnd also realistically we couldn't afford it. Not with trade with USSR being gone and Finland being in recession. And really, we have enough forest already, nothing too valuable in there anyway.
- GoodJokes 5y ago
- enw 5y agoFor those unaware, the attempted Soviet invasion of Finland in 1939 was an embarrassing failure for the USSR. They managed to take only a small part of the country while suffering tremendous loss, despite a much larger army.
- belter 5y ago"Winter War" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winter_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winter_War
- cryptonector 5y agoSee also the Continuation War.
- kcb 5y agoIn a way it also lead to the German invasion of the USSR. Seeing the disaster the Soviet army faced during the Winter War gave the Germans the confidence to invade.
- Sebb767 5y agoAnd then they ironically failed due to the winter. Quite funny that the USSR has been on both sides of this.
- belter 5y agoI only now noticed, Leningrad ( St Petersburg ), is only 35 Km (21 Miles) from the Finish border. Yeah, joining NATO is really going to piss them off...
- AnssiH 5y agoYou must be looking at pre-WW2 borders. Large areas were ceded to USSR in 1940: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_Peace_Treaty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_Peace_Treaty (and again with some more in 1944: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_Armistice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_Armistice)
- jimbob45 5y agoNATO seems like it’s fulfilling the role that the UN was supposed to fulfill if we hadn’t allowed China and Russia in.
- jb1991 5y agoNATO is strictly a military alliance. The UN has never been that.
- InsaneOstrich 5y agoThat's not entirely true; Allied forces fought against North Korea under the banner of UN
- jb1991 5y agoFascinating, that's indeed true: https://www.unc.mil/History/1950-1953-Korean-War-Active-Conflict/ https://www.unc.mil/History/1950-1953-Korean-War-Active-Conf...
- dragonwriter 5y ago> NATO is strictly a military alliance. The UN has never been that. In practice, somewhat true; in design, well, see Chapter VII, and particularly Articles 42-47, of the Charter.
- perihelions 5y agoThere's a petition that just passed that I understand is a significant step towards a national referendum: https://yle.fi/uutiset/3-12043017/64-3-56998 https://yle.fi/uutiset/3-12043017/64-3-56998 (Finnish-language) - "The citizens' initiative, which calls for a referendum on Finland's NATO membership, has collected more than 50,000 statements of support." - "This means that the citizens' initiative is being considered by Parliament. The initiative was launched on Monday of this week." - "The citizens' initiative states that a consultative referendum will be held in Finland on Finland's NATO membership."
- enw 5y agoMeanwhile Russia is threatening military action if Finland joins NATO: https://ria.ru/20220225/nato-1775114040.html https://ria.ru/20220225/nato-1775114040.html
- ericbarrett 5y agoThey're going to open a second front in Northern Europe with 1/3-1/2 of their army locked up in Ukraine?
- Sebb767 5y agoAnd possibly immediately cause NATO action. Russia is really not in a powerful position right now.
- headmelted 5y agoThey have nukes. They’ve indicated they will use them.
- ceejayoz 5y ago"Give us Poland, or we'll nuke you." "Now Czechia, or we'll nuke you." There comes a point where that bluff has to be called, and we're approaching it.
- nabla9 5y agoAs it says there, the membership process itself would be problematic. Russia would use maximum pressure before Finland joins. One possible solution currently considered is to ask Article 5 protections from NATO for the duration of the membership process.
- ceejayoz 5y agoDo it fast, then, and now, while Putin is massively tied up and likely to be for a decade pacifying a well-funded and equipped insurgency. https://yle.fi/news/3-12272467 https://yle.fi/news/3-12272467 > "If Finland and Sweden applied for membership, we could decide on it overnight. You could be a member the very next day because you meet all the necessary membership criteria," said Rasmussen, who was Nato Secretary General from 2009 to 2014.
- laurent92 5y agoIf half of the world can be at war at once because of a single soldier being killed in those countries, then haven’t we repeated the 1914 mechanism?
- ceejayoz 5y agoNo; we've tested this numerous times. Turkey shot down a Russian aircraft in 2015 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_Russian_Sukhoi_Su-24_shootdown https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_Russian_Sukhoi_Su-24_shoo...) without a world war; there've been US on Russian engagements in Syria as well.
- fmajid 5y agoThey did wait for him to (probably inadvertently) fly for a few minutes over sovereign Turkish air space. They wouldn't have dared if he had stayed entirely on the Syrian side. More interesting is that just a couple of years later all is forgotten and Russia is selling Turkey its most advanced S-400 air defense system, thus precipitating a diplomatic crisis with the US. Middle Eastern politics: never a dull moment.
- 323 5y agoA very important point made by a previous Finland prime minister today on Sky News: > FINLAND IS NOT NEUTRAL. That's a common misconception. Finland just doesn't belong to a military alliance. But it is definitely aligned with EU/NATO. > We are members of the EU. Use € as our currency. Have a close partnership with Nato. Have a military which is more Nato compatible than most of its member states. Participate in Nato exercises and crisis management. Purchased F-18 and F-35. Part of JEF, etc, etc. NOT NEUTRAL. https://twitter.com/alexstubb/status/1497619756760895489 https://twitter.com/alexstubb/status/1497619756760895489
- duxup 5y agoEven during the Cold War they cooperated with NATO counties and their planning involved assuming they would get support from NATO nations. Russia wasn’t in the dark about it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- InsaneOstrich 5y agoThe original article says the same thing multiple times
- 323 5y agoPeople don't read the article, especially when it's a PDF.
- belter 5y agoYes but note also from the Report ( pag 20/21 ) "...Irrespective of this, the Atlantic Alliance makes it clear that the organisation’s security guarantees apply to members only. Full access to collective defense planning, decision-making and military structures can only be reached via full membership. This leads to the main paradox of the NATO partnership, namely that in the worst case it can be seen in the eyes of external actors to strengthen an ever-closer association with NATO without, however, supplying the deterrence provided by Article 5..."
- savant_penguin 5y agoReally curious, now that Russia is fighting in a front in Ukraine what would stop the US from growing NATO? Would they fight a war with a second front?
- ceejayoz 5y agoBack in the 1990s I remember seeing a meme "For every animal you don't eat, I'm going to eat three." Perhaps we should take that approach for NATO membership.
- gundmc 5y agoThe US can't unilaterally grow NATO. It requires consensus among its members, many of which would hesitate to take such provocative measures.
- yashap 5y agoBelarus need to join NATO immediately, but I think it’s pretty urgent for Finland too. Putin is a vicious, unpredictable dictator who has already invaded one large European nation. People think he won’t invade Finland, but they also thought he wouldn’t invade Ukraine. When you share a huge border with an aggressive psychopath, whose army is massively larger than yours, you need strong military allies. Edit: nevermind, clearly my understanding of Eastern European politics is weak, shouldn’t have commented
- snuxoll 5y agoBelarus is allied with Russia, they aren’t going to join.
- cryptonector 5y agoBelarus is with Putin. How is Belarus going to join NATO?!
- Hamuko 5y agoBelarus could join NATO, but it would really require a successful revolution.
- cryptonector 5y agoIt's pretty clear that such a revolution isn't coming now. There is probably little grass-roots support for such a thing in Belarus, but more importantly, Putin would absolutely quash such a revolution now. Therefore all talk of Belarus joining NATO is fantasy. Fantasy isn't going to stop war in Ukraine. Fantasy can only cause war. Time to get real.
- nkrisc 5y agoBelarus is a very close ally of Putin, why would they ever join NATO? Ukraine was invaded from Belarus by Russia.
- Ciantic 5y agoFinnish political parties believe in a policy of "Nato-option", where major parties have kept saying to population it's option we can choose. Almost on instant anytime we want. With war in Ukraine, it doesn't look a credible policy, because they can't anymore say it's an option Finland can choose in case hot conflict is ongoing. Currently as things stand, Finland most likely joins in few years. Next parliamentary election is most likely won by center-right who favors it, and president is from same faction. It's a bit situationally dependent, if threats from Russia is seen as violent, it could change their calculus. However even center-left figures already agrees it's necessity, just not now. It could be seen as provocative. I have always thought that Finland would be in NATO already if it was not seen meddling in middle east. It has really burned it's view among leftists.
- oblak 5y ago"meddling" in the middle east? The US-UK straight up invaded two countries under the flimsiest pretexts. I don't remember the world condemning the aggressors in any serious way. No sanctions, nothing. Bush and Blair should've gone the way of Milošević - mysterious death while awaiting trial. Wishful thinking, I know. This hypocrisy is prevalent and disgusting.
- InsaneOstrich 5y agoThe wars in Iraq and Afghanistan were repugnant, but comparing the invasion of countries with brutal authoritarian regimes with the invasion of a functional liberal democracy seems disingenuous.
- oblak 5y agoWhy can't I? Are you implying the Afghani wanted their torn up country invaded by yet another superpower? They haven't seen anything resembling normal life in generations. Or that Iraqis deserved to get their well developed country almost completely destroyed? What are you saying?
- 5y ago
- bsd44 5y agoI don't see a problem with Finland joining NATO on a reciprocal basis; as long as Russia can set up a military base on Cuba. Of course the United States will start a world war before they allow that to happen, but then we can't reasonably expect any different from Russia?
- nate_meurer 5y agoPutin will use this as a pretext to invade the Baltics. This has already started; yesterday a Kremlin spokeswoman threatened military consequences if Sweden or Finland join NATO. In his big speech last week, Putin said it was "madness" that the Baltic nations were allowed to become independent nations. Their re-conquest is next on his list.
- lamontcg 5y agoHe's having trouble taking Kiev. Germany seems to be smelling which way the winds are blowing and is sending 1,000 antitank arms and 500 stinger missiles to Ukraine. The question right now probably isn't who else Putin invades, but how long he manages to last in control of Russia.
- nate_meurer 5y agoThey need to act fast while air superiority is still up for grabs.