6 ms·
Why did we think it would be a good idea to stick a computer between the brake pedal and the physics equation? Passive systems like ABS are pretty much the onl
by bob1029 5y ago
Why did we think it would be a good idea to stick a computer between the brake pedal and the physics equation?
Passive systems like ABS are pretty much the only thing I have ever found value in, and even then it's been a mixed bag when operating near limits. Never heard of a car locking up on the freeway because an ABS fuse went out...
- riskable 5y ago> Why did we think it would be a good idea to stick a computer between the brake pedal and the physics equation? Because human beings have such a terrible track record that even "dumb" computers running code written by shabby programmers can do better. Even with these errors the computers are still doing a better job. The NIH studied Automatic Emergency Braking systems and found that, "With a 100% market penetration rate, fatalities could be reduced by 13.2%, and injuries could be reduced by 9.1%." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7037779/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7037779/
- Wiseacre 5y agoThat just underlines the problem of being so reliant on our death-prone cars in the first place.
- tenuousemphasis 5y agoYes, absolutely. Does that mean we shouldn't make them safer? Car manufacturers don't have a say in urban planning.
- crims0n 5y agoWhen a human does something stupid, it's the humans fault. The human has to accept responsibility. When a computer does something stupid, who is to blame? How are they held accountable?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- stubish 5y agoWhen the computer fails its job it is the same responsibility as any other car component when it fails to do its job. You are responsibile unless you can shift the blame to the manufacturer or a mechanic or God. Nothing new, same as air bags going off when they shouldn't.
- dahart 5y agoI actually agree with your question, but allow me to play devil’s advocate, perhaps. We only have 1 side of this story - that a few people have been surprised and had accidents. We don’t have the stats on how many people the active braking has saved from a collision. (BTW I have a CRV, and have experienced sudden braking myself, both with and without something in front of me, but it hasn’t caused an accident yet.) ABS is a computer between the brake and the physics, and there’s widespread agreement about the benefits of this arrangement. So maybe the problem isn’t the computer, or the idea to use them in the loop. Maybe the problem is an incomplete understanding of people, or maybe it’s just a sensor defect or manufacturing issue. (Which, I would agree, absolutely should be considered when plugging things into a computer controller.) We have lots of computers in the physics loop, and very few of them give any of us pause. ECUs are standard these days and are critical to fuel efficiency and reducing environmental impact. Self driving cars are on the way and are a whole new level of computer control. I think I’m still in favor of self-driving cars and the potential they have to reduce traffic, collisions, and environmental impact...
- bob1029 5y agoImpact is the key function in my mind. Assume you are traveling down the 405 at 80mph during rush hour. What is the worst case scenario for an ABS failure mode? What is the worst case scenario for an emergency braking failure mode?
- dahart 5y ago> Assume you are traveling down the 405 at 80mph during rush hour. Okay, bad driving choice there. You are 1.5x more likely to die in a collision driving 80mph than if you were driving the speed limit (65mph), since collision energy is proportional to velocity squared. ;) Worst case for ABS failure vs emergency braking failure? Seems like both can easily result in death, and I don’t see reasons yet to believe one is more likely than the other. We probably have a lot more data on the number of deaths lack of ABS has caused over the years than computer braking systems, and the good news is that we can fix computer braking systems right now and forever. The big difference here is control, not outcome. Having brakes seize suddenly is surprising, whereas going from static to dynamic friction when slamming on the brakes isn’t very surprising. Of course we strive to minimize surprise, and of course it’s preferable if cars don’t slam on the brakes without cause.
- rideontime 5y agoIt's a tradeoff. My rental car recently had the fancy modern lane-centering, radar cruise control, etc. I found the car-following radar cruise control to be really nice on a 5 hour drive, but the lane centering was garbage, and I just couldn't get used the drive-by-wire steering. I still prefer to actually be in control of my vehicle. That said... I had the rental because of an accident that would have been avoided if my own car had frontal collision detection and automatic braking. Assuming it had worked.
- slaw 5y agoDid you get Infinity? That’s the only brand I know that offers drive by wire steering.
- QuercusMax 5y agoI had it in my Nissan Leaf - the cruise control was great, but the lane following felt like I was a bowling ball in a game with bumpers. It wanted to just bounce back and forth off the sides of the lanes.
- slaw 5y agoNissan Leaf has regular rack and pinion steering not drive by wire.
- QuercusMax 5y agoThe model I leased for 2 years certainly had auto steering.
- sfteus 5y agoWe borrowed a 2020 4Runner to haul a camper on a 300 mile drive, and the radar-enabled cruise control was really nice on that trip both ways. Seemed like it did a good job of breaking early enough to keep it only providing mild input, but it wasn't super distracting or anything. Also possible that any input from the automatic trailer break controller overshadowed the what the cruise control was doing. It either didn't have lane-centering or it was disabled, but I think in general that's a way more noticeable input than braking. If you have a weird input in steering (ie, a strong gust of wind) your instinct is to steer the opposite way, but in general I think most people that have weird input with acceleration/braking tend to respond with just braking universally.
- burnt_toast 5y ago+1 Unexpected surprises can be dangerous. I feel like safety related systems really should be as simple as possible. I like ABS but in one of my vehicles I had an issue with it randomly engaging when it shouldn't due to rusted and cracked tone rings. It's actually pretty scary losing the majority of your braking power when you desperately need it.
- bob1029 5y ago> It's actually pretty scary losing the majority of your braking power when you desperately need it. Agreed. It's bad both ways. I would say the more dangerous failure mode is the one which results in the most unexpected amount of delta between input and output. If you are already in the process of trying to stop, there is going to be some finite difference between expectation and reality, even if the braking system does not perform perfectly (or at all). Your brain is already thinking "ok let's find a way to slow this thing down". You might have a few precious milliseconds to go for a shoulder or other external soft-stop opportunity. If you are inputting zero braking signal and receive a 100% stop force arbitrarily, that is pretty much an infinite level of surprise. Incidentally, this may also provoke any adjacent ABS failure modes.
- madengr 5y agoBack in the last century, we had these levers called emergency brakes. Then they went to parking brake pedals. Now parking brakes are on a button. I want the lever back.
- twblalock 5y ago> Why did we think it would be a good idea to stick a computer between the brake pedal and the physics equation? I think it's a great idea for the driver behind me to have such a system. It makes them less likely to rear-end me.
- jjav 5y ago> > Why did we think it would be a good idea to stick a computer between the brake pedal and the physics equation? > I think it's a great idea for the driver behind me to have such a system. It makes them less likely to rear-end me. Yes. But it's a scary idea for the driver in front of you to have such a system. If they (their car) suddenly goes into hard braking for no visible reason on the highway, you might be rear-ending them.