3 ms·
I don't have anything to add about those posts; they're making actual points. Often good ones, with reasoning. But this thread was especially to point out this
by roenxi 5y ago
I don't have anything to add about those posts; they're making actual points. Often good ones, with reasoning.
But this thread was especially to point out this this sort of policy-by-literary-allusion is stupid and also exactly the sort of thing people would try once Dickens quotes get flying.
- Talanes 5y agoYou were content to play the policy-by-literary-allusion game in your top comment. It feels like you only developed an opinion against it after being insulted-by-literary-allusion.
- roenxi 5y agoQuite possibly, it certainly helped crystallise to me why the original article rubbed me the wrong way. It is a relatively subtle problem but argument-by-Dickensian-allegory isn't a path to better politics. Objectives and arguments rooted in the 21st century are a much better approach. It is a setup that subtly frames opposition as "well you're just like the antagonist of a novel!" rather than trying to respectfully sift through the relevant merits and trade-offs. That isn't a good way to think about policy.