3 ms·
roenxi: I'm not sure the minimum wage needs to be high enough to raise a 3 person family. And the strategy should look something like a Plan-Do-Check-Act rather
by roenxi 5y ago
roenxi: I'm not sure the minimum wage needs to be high enough to raise a 3 person family. And the strategy should look something like a Plan-Do-Check-Act rather than arguing about 1850s literature.
[???]
> I am, and I suspect parent is as well, reminding you that your argument sounds cruel and miserly.
Not really sure how we got from there to here, but I continue to hold this up as an examples of how polite and rational conversation would have been a much better bet rather than calling me names. It isn't an argument, it doesn't have evidence behind it and it is drawing the conversation away from discussing the very real non-fictional issues. It also isn't true. Argument by allusion isn't reasonable.
- marcellus23 5y ago> I continue to hold this up as an examples of how polite and rational conversation would have been a much better bet rather than calling me names The only comment in your thread that you responded to was the one calling you names. You didn’t respond (as of this posting, at least) to any of the half dozen other comments that bring up valid points. Who’s drawing the conversation away?
- roenxi 5y agoI don't have anything to add about those posts; they're making actual points. Often good ones, with reasoning. But this thread was especially to point out this this sort of policy-by-literary-allusion is stupid and also exactly the sort of thing people would try once Dickens quotes get flying.
- Talanes 5y agoYou were content to play the policy-by-literary-allusion game in your top comment. It feels like you only developed an opinion against it after being insulted-by-literary-allusion.
- roenxi 5y agoQuite possibly, it certainly helped crystallise to me why the original article rubbed me the wrong way. It is a relatively subtle problem but argument-by-Dickensian-allegory isn't a path to better politics. Objectives and arguments rooted in the 21st century are a much better approach. It is a setup that subtly frames opposition as "well you're just like the antagonist of a novel!" rather than trying to respectfully sift through the relevant merits and trade-offs. That isn't a good way to think about policy.
- AussieWog93 5y ago>polite and rational conversation would have been a much better bet rather than calling me names Parent's comment was a gentle poke in response to what was frankly an offensive and inflammatory statement on your part. You brought up some seriously sore points for millions of people and somehow managed to not acknowledge the human aspect of it at all. In one sentence, you mention an (admittedly fictional, but also completely realistic) example of a man who in one future sees his sick son die because he couldn't afford the treatment, and in another sees his son make a full recovery after Scrooge has a change of heart. In the next, you say it's "unclear" why someone doing similar work to Cratchit should receive a (mandated) higher wage. In spite of this, the worst name that anybody has called you in this entire thread is "Ebenezer". If you want a specific argument as to why you shouldn't pursue this idea, without mentioning works of fiction: - Chronic poverty is a horrific experience, and if you needlessly inflict it on tens of millions of people eventually they'll get angry and chop off your head with a guillotine. If you want to see what an unrestrained, impolite response to your comment looks like, walk into a country pub on a Saturday night and share it with the blokes there.