3 ms·
>It is unclear why the default position is someone should (1) be doing the similar work as Cratchit (2) possibly with less responsibilities and (3) earning more
by bryanrasmussen 5y ago
>It is unclear why the default position is someone should (1) be doing the similar work as Cratchit (2) possibly with less responsibilities and (3) earning more money in real terms.
Because if he is barely supporting a family in near poverty with a sick child with not system for social spending it follows that he is not able to put money aside for his eventual retirement / sudden death. Thus if he were run over by a horse and carriage and died from his injuries his family would be definitely in poverty and probably go to the poor house.
Also as I recall the story the ghost of Christmas present says that if Tiny Tim does not get treatment he would die, but he is not getting treatment because Cratchit is barely supporting the family as it is.
Finally nobody is saying that social policy should be based on stories like this one, because it is hard to legislate supernatural beings showing up to make misers better people. Stories are used to indicate possible problem areas for which solutions should be formed.
At the end I would agree that near-poverty while supporting family is acceptable as a societal result for a small part of society, as long as there are social systems in place to help in case of the person doing the supporting not being able to support any more or to help in case of severe health problems which near-poverty cannot solve and as long as there exist non-supernatural or not completely luck based means (like winning lotteries) whereby it might be supposed the person doing the supporting might be able to move that family to a middle class lifestyle.
- fuzzfactor 5y ago>legislate supernatural beings showing up to make misers better people. Sometimes this might be the only type of legislation that would have a chance. Since well before the time of Dickens there have been major organizations controlled by influential elites which have always been dependent on the kind of expolitation that can only be maximized up the chain when there exists at least a certain amount of this type of poverty toward the bottom. Even when there are more than enough resources to go around. Even sometimes when there is no maliciousness involved. The tradition is that deeply ingrained. Employed workers like Cratchit were not suffering as badly from the full prevailing poverty at the time. Their financial disadvantages were great, but not nearly as bad as the vast unemployed had to face in order for their services to be made available to elite ventures when needed at relatively insignificant cost with little notice. The unwashed masses really are masses and sometimes will need to include white-collar professions more than others. When it becomes possible for enough working-class people to rise financially through mere education and/or merit, then adjustments will be made by those whose control did not arise from merit in order to keep the distance and maintain the status quo. This seem to be what Dickens was getting at.
- Jiro 5y agoMiserliness is not the same as greed. Miserliness is about refusing to spend money, not about making money. It may overlap with greed when it comes to paying low wages, but miserliness doesn't, in general, mean exploiting people.
- fuzzfactor 5y agoGood point but there is so much overlap. Sometimes exploitation can still be the root cause if it extends far enough up the food chain, many business owners can't afford to spend money any more freely than their employees or those at the very bottom.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoa small note - in the story Scrooge did rise by 'merit' as it were, he came from poverty and succeeded by working longer and harder than everyone else (ruining his life in the process) as well as having a more astute financial sense which he exploited to the detriment of others and his own gain.