2 ms·
> A fake guarantee, because it is impossible to actually enforce it for every filesystem in use. For some time now the situation is that a POC exists which wor
by tialaramex 5y ago
> A fake guarantee, because it is impossible to actually enforce it for every filesystem in use.
For some time now the situation is that a POC exists which works just fine against C++ programs, but no longer works against Rust programs with current Rust. That seems much more like a real guarantee to me than a fake one.
> If Rust safety goals is to be dependent typed safety language
Rust does not offer full-blown dependent types today, and so far as I know has no plans to do so, although it would be convenient if it was easy (it isn't easy).
But (safe) Rust does have working type safety and this already meaningfully makes us safer as I explained already.
- ncmncm 5y agoUntil, of course, a very slightly different POC is coded that works against Rust programs built with current Rust. Erecting a fencepost and expecting attackers to run headlong into the fencepost and knock themselves out is not security. Actual attackers just go around. Again, it is unwise to explain things you do not understand to people who do understand them.
- tialaramex 5y agoOf course, just "a very slightly different POC". And let me guess, because you are "people who do understand them" you could certainly conjure up such a thing, but alas, you just don't have the time right? So, Rust is vulnerable to an imaginary attack that Nathan Myers claims to be able to write, while C++ is vulnerable to an actual attack that we know works. As to the fencepost analogy I will note that Rust fixed the problem a little over a month ago and ever since C++ proponents have been running into that particular fencepost quite certain that the resulting brain damage is proof of just how smart they are for not fixing bugs.
- ncmncm 5y agoYou embarrass yourself. It brings me no pleasure to watch it. But it reflects also, perhaps unfairly, on Rust and its creators, who did not ask for foolish promotion.