4 ms·
As I wrote in another thread today, current EU and US leaders are asleep at the wheel. We have a different dynamic. Talking about sanctions looks almost patheti
by belter 5y ago
As I wrote in another thread today, current EU and US leaders are asleep at the wheel. We have a different dynamic. Talking about sanctions looks almost pathetic.
The analogy here is, you live in a community and one of your neighbors just lost it completely and is shooting and shelling another neighbor. Not to raise the hostilities...you scream at him he wont be invited anymore for the Christmas party and you will complain about the noise to the gated community administration /s
- prettygood 5y agoThis is a very delicate situation that can't be resolved by just sending troops and fighting. Neither the US nor Europe wants to have another world war. Definitely not now nuclear weapons are much more powerful.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI'm pretty sure that we're in World War III. We're just trying to pretend that we're not. We're at least at the buildup to it.
- GoodJokes 5y ago
- tyre 5y agoThis is not a world war. The fighting is specific to a single area. The Vietnam War involved at least double the number of involved countries and wasn’t considered a world war.
- djxfade 5y agoWorld War II also started with fighting in a specific single are, until suddenly it wasn't in a single area anymore...
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y agoBut what about the denominator. All the wars that started in single areas and ended in them too.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> This is not a world war. The fighting is specific to a single area. That was true of WWII, until it wasn't.
- kingofpandora 5y agoAnd it's not true of this war until it is.
- gerikson 5y agoGermany invaded Poland on 29 Aug 1939, and France and Great Britain declared war on Germany on 3 Sep 1939. If a major power declares war on Russia on Monday, we're in World War III.
- CRConrad 5y agoCrimea was the Sudetenland; Ukraine is Poland.
- iso1631 5y agoThe parallels with ww2 are far too easy to draw - the annexation, the failed appeasement attempt, the invasion. The German invasion of Poland tends to be counted as the "start" of ww2, but the militarisation of the Rhineland, annexation of Austria, and invasion of Czechoslovakia all came first on that front. The global reach was due to European colonies abroad (especially in Africa). The Japanese invasion of China also predated the start of war in Europe, but the Pacific war doesn't count as starting until the attacks on Hawaii, Philipeenes, Malaya/Singapore, Hong Kong etc in 1941. Perhaps the next move is Sweden+Finland joining Nato (because clearly not being part of Nato is risky). Either way, perhaps then Russia invades the Baltics (or maybe "Belarus" does for deniability?), triggering wars all along the border. Throw in China using the opportunity to attack Taiwan while America is busy elsewhere, North Korea rolling into South Korea, and various local civil wars (probably instigated by China) in South America to distract the US further, then throw a wildcard like Syria taking a pop at Israel, and it rapidly escalates into a World War. Historians (if any survive) may lump Crimea, Ukraine, and even places like Georgia, as the "pre-war" battles, it's arguable when local wars get enough to be deemed to be a "World War".
- ROTMetro 5y agoThen we should not have been encouraging Ukraine the way we have if we knew we didn't have their back. It really was not fair of us (the USA).
- s1artibartfast 5y agoUkraine had all of the information as well. They were told they wouldn't be defended by NATO, and they were told that they would be attacked by Russia if they didn't renounce their NATO aspirations. It was all a big game of chicken to see if Russia was bluffing
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- causi 5y agoSeven hundred billion dollars a year and we can't even defend the weak unless it looks profitable on the balance sheet. Never have I been more ashamed to be American than I was yesterday.
- unethical_ban 5y agoI don't think money is the primary reason the US is holding off. Perhaps it's the population of the US not yet demanding intervention, maybe it's the idea that Russians and Americans openly shooting at each other means an actual continental war in Europe with nuclear powers.
- systemvoltage 5y ago
- causi 5y agoWould defending Ukraine with US soldiers be good for the US? Absolutely not. The best outcome for the US is if Ukraine turns into a Vietnam for Russia for the next couple decades, with high casualties for the Russians and high casualties among Ukrainian civilians to keep the whole world strongly against Russia. That doesn't make it right, though. The right thing to do is to help other people even when it doesn't benefit you.
- systemvoltage 5y agoLet me refer you to Game Theory 101 by Professor William Spaniel on this very thing you're talking about: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ryYvEOm4eA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ryYvEOm4eA
- octopoc 5y ago> The right thing to do is to help other people even when it doesn't benefit you. Why does it have to be the American men and women getting killed? Russia is never going to cross the ocean and attack us, and if they did they would never win. Why can't the EU defend itself? It ought to be strong enough. If the EU is sustainable it should be able to defend itself without outsourcing 95% of its defense to a foreign power across an ocean. I get that they were weak after WWII but for crying out loud they've had 70 years to recover from that. As an American, I am sick and tired of my nation getting involved in foreign wars because "it's the right thing to do."
- sharken 5y agoYes, this is a very abrupt awakening from the general idea that Corona was handled well and thinking we can do everything. Here is Putin with the might of Russia at his disposal, a very different challenge altogether. As you, i fear that the leaders are not geared towards this kind of conflict at all. I would consider calling Putins bluff by accepting Finland and Sweden as NATO members. But only if the two countries agrees. If indeed there is interest, NATO should admit the two in a day or two.
- watwut 5y agoWhat does this have to do with Corona, exactly?
- sharken 5y agoNothing per se, except the fact that Corona was an unknown virus that challenged leaders in the EU and US. And now there is a new challenge of a very different kind, one that won't go away as easily. That challenge is what we fear that the leaders are unable to find a good response to.
- avgcorrection 5y agoWell, I thought that Putin was bluffing and wouldn’t even officially send troops into Donbas.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> I would consider calling Putins bluff by accepting Finland and Sweden as NATO members. But only if the two countries agrees. Yeah, NATO can't involuntarily admit members anyway. > If indeed there is interest, NATO should admit the two in a day or two. NATO membership is an active issue in both, but not something on which a political decision has been made.
- morpheos137 5y agoWho thinks Corona was handled well? Compare how Europe handled it to China or even Australia or New Zealand.
- belter 5y agoNATO Secretary Jens Stoltenberg press briefing of today: From correct time: https://youtu.be/JvxqTGrZxwQ?t=64 https://youtu.be/JvxqTGrZxwQ?t=64 Partial quote as of time above: "...The Kremlin objectives are not limited to Ukraine. Russia has demanded legal binding agreements to renounce further NATO enlargement. And remove troops and infrastructure from allies that joined after 1997..."
- jopsen 5y ago> ... current EU and US leaders are asleep at the wheel. We have a different dynamic. Talking about sanctions looks almost pathetic. Yes, but NATO clearly stating that they wouldn't intervene in Ukraine probably made events more predictable. Reducing the risk of escalation, and miscalculation. Leaving Ukraine to fight on its own wasn't nice. But it's probably best NATO doesn't bluff too much. Sanctions is probably not a solution, but it's a signal -- well, really it's the only thing that can be done.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoIf I were completely cynical and amoral I'd use Ukraine as a quagmire trap. Take direct intervention off the table, beef up the defences enough to cause a problem, and wait for the Russians to take the bait. Then when Russia is trapped in a continuing guerilla war which is generating huge economic consequences and negative PR at home and abroad, wait for the regime change in Russia to happen spontaneously. It's a risky strategy given nukes, but not entirely unimaginable as realpolitik.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y ago> asleep at the wheel It's worse than that. Some of them are pro-Russia simply because of their knee jerk reaction to be for whatever the president is against.
- _trackno5 5y agoI think a big problem, at least for Europe, is that we played directly into Russia's hands. If they cut off the gas, we are are screwed big time. Blocking Russia's access to SWIFT would pretty much cut off that gas supply.
- alkonaut 5y agoNord Stream 2 being cancelled sounded far fetched. Until suddenly it wasn’t. Sanctioning too Ru heads of state was also unexpected but happened today. Banning Russia from SWIFT was called a “nuclear option” and seemed impossible due to Italy and Germany being against it. That was this morning and this evening it’s already decided. There was talk about the Refugee crisis once again showing division and lack of solidarity in the EU. Instead states have opened their borders completely. If anything, the EU leadership I think looks like it’s showing a very uncharacteristic decisiveness and speed.