4 ms·
"We'll invade you if you join NATO" loses its power a bit when you invade people who haven't joined NATO.
by ceejayoz 5y ago
"We'll invade you if you join NATO" loses its power a bit when you invade people who haven't joined NATO.
- rhino369 5y agoEven worse, when you invade someone who tried to join NATO, was given the same warning, didn't join NATO, and then was invaded anyway. Finland and Sweden should join now while Russia doesn't have the ability to invade (because their forces are busy in Ukraine).
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoWhether they join or not, Finland and Sweden better beef up their defenses, starting yesterday...
- avgcorrection 5y agoWhat are you talking about? Sweden placed patrolling troops in Gotland right when Russia increased their presence in the Baltic Sea during this buildup.
- CRConrad 5y agoSweden has almost fuck-all to place anywhere compared to what it had a few decades ago. It's not like the Swedish Air Force is the fourth-largest in the world any more...
- Someone1234 5y agoI agree; I think there was this kind of default assumption (due to MAD) that wars in Northern Europe were mostly over. All these recent events have done is prove that nuclear nations will swallow up non-nuclear nations if they don't have a MAD assurance from an alley. Finland and Sweden should decide themselves what is best, but I only wish the best for both countries and after this I cannot bring myself to believe it couldn't happen again. The only major benefit Finland has over Ukraine is geography.
- SAI_Peregrinus 5y agoIt's been clear for years now that nuclear weapons are required to be a sovereign nation. Without enough nukes to be a real threat, the nuclear nations will simply take over when they feel it's worth it.
- bluGill 5y agoAlso relations with NATO. Even if not in NATO directly, the stronger relations are the more likely it is various NATO countries are to come to their aid.
- lamontcg 5y agoTime for Finland and Sweden to do some casual joint military exercises with NATO where a pile of NATO jets get parked on runways all around those countries and some naval vessels pull into their ports. Just military people chilling and shooting the shit with other military people.
- reitanqild 5y agoHappy to say it seems Finland started decades ago and never stopped. Sweden I think is also not to unprepared. Even Norway (who is a Nato member) seems to be somewhat better prepared than last time there was a dictator on the loose in Europe.
- ROTMetro 5y agoUkraine was denied membership by Nato, after the west encouraged Ukraine to depose the Russian backed government, they didn't 'not join'.
- dragonwriter 5y agoPart of the “justification” for invading Ukraine was that they didn't rule out joining NATO in the future, and in fact have an official policy of seeking NATO membership, which puts them farther along the process than Sweden or Finland. OTOH, Sweden or Finland could probably join more quickly and with less friction if they decided to seek membership, and I can easily see the result of this being pushing Sweden and/or Finland into NATO rather than keeping them out.
- mindslight 5y agoI'm sure NATO could come up with some way of quickly accepting a country as something like a protected candidate, making a pledge to defend them against retaliation during the democratic process of deciding to actually join or not. There would be a strong incentive to continue joining NATO afterwards (or face the pending retaliation), but it would certainly mitigate this bullying posture.
- dragonwriter 5y agoI think in the short term, there's a couple NATO countries that have been leary of expansion that Russia doesn't like (I think Hungary particularly), but it's not clear how the situation in Ukraine (and/or, in Hungary’s case, specifically, it's upcoming election) will impact that.
- GoodJokes 5y agoPutin has been saying for the past decade that he would not tolerate further eastward expansion of NATO, a thoroughly anti-russian alliance. It is a reasonable position. No, invading independent countries is not reasonable. One can hold both these thoughts in their head.
- ceejayoz 5y agoIt's not a reasonable position. It's like me telling my next door neighbor they can't be friends with another neighbor. It's none of my business, and I'd be an asshole for demanding it. It also places Russia in direct violation of their own agreements. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum_on_Security_Assurances https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum_on_Securit...
- s1artibartfast 5y agoYou have to also consider that it involves more than just being friends, it also involves putting airbases, missiles, and possibly nukes pointing at your house.
- CRConrad 5y agoA) NATO has had nukes pointed at Moscow for half a century already, so that wouldn't be anything new. B) Ukraine isn't much closer to Moscow than Lithuania is (and hugely father away from Leningrad than Estonia is), so this seems irrelevant. What your neighbours and their friends put on their lawns is none of your business. If it's a lot of stuff usable for defending against arsehole neighbours, maybe in stead of attacking them you should think about what kind of a neighbour you are.
- hnarn 5y ago> It is a reasonable position. It is not. Russia does not have any say in what alliances other nations choose to join -- apart from the "last argument of kings" of course, and what's scary to me is that there are so many people like you around that seem to have this Clausewitz idea of war being "politics by other means" even in the present day. Your comment clearly makes excuses for Russia's actions, so no, in your case you are not keeping both of these thoughts in your head. Would you be so quick to defend the United States in the same manner if they had expressed concerns about Mexico's foreign policies for the past ten years? Or an invasion of an alternate-reality Cuba with a democratically elected government tomorrow?
- tpoacher 5y ago