5 ms·
> It can't be just a number on a computer in a bank, right? It really is, but to answer your second question, it's important to consider *which* bank. There's
by lxgr 5y ago
> It can't be just a number on a computer in a bank, right?
It really is, but to answer your second question, it's important to consider *which* bank. There's reserves (i.e. balances of banks at the Federal Reserve) and bank deposits (which really are just numbers in banks' databases).
Having an account at the former is effectively what makes numbers in the database of the latter "real USD".
> Otherwise some Russian bank could just increase that number to whatever they like. And say "Look, we own 100 Trillion USD. Now let's go shopping.".
They could, but these assets/liabilities would not be backed by any reserves linked to the USD payment rails.
Reserves are theoretically irrelevant (though practically regulated) as far as transfers between accounts of a single bank are concerned. But as soon as a second bank comes into the picture, i.e. for inter-bank transfers communicated via SWIFT or otherwise, all transfers will ultimately be backed by Fed account to Fed account transfers in the background.
> So I guess USD needs to be recognized by the US somehow?
Indirectly so, yes: What makes USD "real" is the ability to transact with the larger ecosystem of US and offshore banks that have a shared agreement on what "real" USD are.
Practically, this means being connected either directly (via a Fed account) or indirectly (via a bank that itself does have a Fed account) to that system.
> Could the US simply "void" all USD that are owned by Russia?
Indirectly, yes: They can force every bank holding USD balances for embargoed beneficiaries to freeze these assets. Failing to comply could, in the absolute worst case, lead to that bank's Fed accounts being frozen as well (which would take away its ability to settle in USD with other banks).
- anonporridge 5y agotl;dr, what makes electronic USD "real" is a system of consensus like bitcoin, except it's a node of 1 (the US Fed) with a handful of spokes (banks with Fed accounts) for scaling off that base node.
- thomasahle 5y agoI suppose what OP was arguing is, when bank A transfers to bank B, does bank B check with the Feds that the money from bank A is "real"? And is a transfer from A to B really a transfer from A's account at the Feds to B's? In that case, why would the US have to act "indirectly", threatening bank A not to work with bank B? They could simply deny any transfers to and from bank B's account at the Feds, which would make any transactions impossible?
- lxgr 5y ago> when bank A transfers to bank B, does bank B check with the Feds that the money from bank A is "real"? Yes, unless the banks have mutual accounts with each other that they can use to settle instead. So, if bank B is accepting to be owed money by bank A for any transfer from A to B, they don't need to settle – but there's practical limits to that, imposed by both risk and regulatory concerns. Eventually, they'll need to settle up if funds flows A -> B and B -> A don't largely cancel each other out. > And is a transfer from A to B really a transfer from A's account at the Feds to B's? For wire transfers and ACH, it is. > They could simply deny any transfers to and from bank B's account at the Feds, which would make any transactions impossible? Yes – that's in fact exactly what a freeze of that bank's Fed reserves is!
- thomasahle 5y agoThanks for clearing this up for me! > unless the banks have mutual accounts with each other that they can use to settle instead. So this is just based on trust that the other bank will keep a truthful score of the transfer, and there won't be a dispute at settlement time? If the banks are often willing to trade with each other "on trust alone" like that, I suppose that shows why the Feds can't always directly block dollar transfers, but have to rely on threats of account freezes.
- lxgr 5y ago> So this is just based on trust that the other bank will keep a truthful score of the transfer, and there won't be a dispute at settlement time? Exactly: Either there is trust (and external settlement is not required), or there isn't, in which case banks will usually only credit incoming transfers to their customers once the underlying funds have settled. Practically, trust is a spectrum, and banks might only settle once the outstanding balance in either direction has become too large (that's then called "netting"). > If the banks are often willing to trade with each other "on trust alone" like that Bank balances are ultimately only be useful to their accountholders if they can effect some payment with them. There is therefore also a spectrum of fungibility of USD balances. If you think about it, what makes USD useful is the fact that they can be used to pay for imports from the largest economy in the world. Only very few US companies would be willing to trade with you when being paid in USD balances at some foreign bank that they can't, as one significant example, pay their taxes with.
- tony_cannistra 5y agoI am astounded at how much I just learned about banking from you -- Thank you!
- rosndo 5y ago> Indirectly, yes: They can force every bank holding USD balances for embargoed beneficiaries to freeze these assets. Failing to comply could, in the absolute worst case, lead to that bank's Fed accounts being frozen as well (which would take away its ability to settle in USD with other banks). They could also go much further. US has the power to force any bank that wants to transact in USD to freeze all Russian assets no matter the currency. This is a very big stick.
- mohanmcgeek 5y agoIsn't that what blocking them on SWIFT actually is? Or do they have another way?
- Slartie 5y agoNo. Swift is "just" a messaging system. No money is transferred over it. Blocking Swift access makes it very inconvenient for banks to perform international settlement, because banks today rely on automated Swift messages to coordinate such transfers. However, even before Swift, international transfers were possible: by phone or telex. The banks have to find other ways to communicate, which isn't easy in practice, but not impossible. The fact that Russia has its own Swift competitor, to which some international banks might switch over time, would probably help with that. But by freezing bank accounts at the Fed, the actual settlements - the events at which money actually changes hands - could be prevented in the first place, no matter the way in which banks agreed over those settlements. Switching back to good old telex (or another financial communication network) wouldn't help in such a scenario. Banks would have to fall back to exchanging big suitcases of dollar bills, which obviously wouldn't practically work. Because no bank would survive this, they would immediately cooperate when confronted with such a threat and freeze any Russian-held funds, even if those funds weren't actually held in USD in the first place and thus would theoretically be unaffected by the Fed account freeze.
- lxgr 5y agoYep – I suspect that when people say "block them from SWIFT", they really do mean "put them on international embargo lists and/or block anybody violating these at the various currency's settlement layers". But as a short-term measure, revoking SWIFT access is probably also somewhat effective. As you say, setting up alternatives is not impossible, but not easy either.
- kzrdude 5y agoWith the already agreed sanctions (so not swift, but the ones about transactions in USD and EUR etc) - it was also written that the russian banks have up to May 24 to settle their transactions. Is that the last level of inter-bank settlements that's about? Or does it mean that the sanctions are ineffective until then?
- TeeWEE 5y agoSo reading this: Banks are basically a necessary "evil" to make the current money system work. When I read how banks works, their technology, and how money works in general.. It makes me think: Is this really the way we want it to work. I'm not sure if crypto is currently ready. But one BIG reason for it to succeed, is that the current system is just old... We have all these fintech startups improving money flow, and transfer times, and easy of payment... But it seems like tech build upon tech. centralized startups/companies owning payment systems (Apple Pay, Stripe, Adyen).... Man, i'm going to buy some more ETH :p
- mohanmcgeek 5y ago> Is this really the way we want it to work Yes. This is not a technology problem. This is how banks have been working for the last 400 years. You can't get rid of banks because banks are what create the money. The crypto people have a terrible understanding of what money is.
- kmeisthax 5y agoWell, no: this isn't the way we want it to work. It's how it has to work. Banks aren't just a necessary evil - any functioning financial system needs intermediaries. Furthermore, in all but a small handful of cases, those intermediaries need to be trusted and trust-worthy. Bitcoin, and all other protocols based on Satoshi's design[0], are limited to maintaining a secure ledger of "on-chain assets". Any interaction with the real world still requires a trusted intermediary to feed data back into that ledger; and once you do that the downsides of maintaining a distributed trustless global ledger for the virtual side of those assets becomes apparent. [0] Including Ethereum.
- 7steps2much 5y agoSee, the thing is that you will need trust at some point. Back in the day you had to trust that your business partner didn't just whip out a sword and kill you to take your money. Then you had to trust that they didn't hand you false coins. After that came false checks. Nowadays you need to trust that online shops aren't trying to scam you. Essentially whenever you do business there will be one person that needs to make the first move, crypto or fiat, someone always needs to deliver first. But if these two business partners don't trust one another then they need a third party they can both trust. In our world these are most often banks or notaries. People that will take money from person A hold it till person B delivers then pass it on. If person B doesn't deliver person A gets their money back, if person A doesn't pay person B doesn't deliver. Now, crypto is trying to claim that smart contracts will solve this in crypto world but that raises the question of who executes these smart contracts and who feeds them information. After all this once again feeds back into the trust problem. Essentially you need banks not because they are modern or technologically up to date or fast, but because they are in fact fully capable of clawing money back if the laws allow them to, unlike crypto where your money is secured by math. Because even if some people don't like it, the chance of the average person being scammed is far higher than your bank or the government misusing the trust you have given them and taking your money.