6 ms·
That's a great read. What's striking, in his description of the conference, is the total lack of any connection to real world activity. None of these people se
by Animats 5y ago
That's a great read.
What's striking, in his description of the conference, is the total lack of any connection to real world activity. None of these people seem to be trying to get enough Bitcoin together to build a steel mill or a wafer fab or a smartphone factory or, indeed, any kind of startup that does something. Bitcoin is expected to somehow generate wealth without actually doing anything that generates revenue. All it can really do is move money from one group to another.
The world changed this week. Things just got real. Russia is taking over a big chunk of eastern Europe by force. That's what real authoritarianism looks like. Not mask mandates. Over the next few months, the tolerance for bullshit, especially in politics, will go way down.
- once_inc 5y agoThere are actually quite a few companies doing things with bitcoin that generate revenue. Bitcoin isn't supposed to make you money; it's supposed to be money. Dollars on their own don't generate revenue, nor is gold locked in a safe. Bitcoin has qualities that make it better than fiat and better than gold, at the cost of an established history. Perhaps the author just spoke to the wrong people, didn't get the fundamentals, or didn't ask fundamental questions.
- uoaei 5y ago> Spoke to the wrong people. So either the conference didn't have the right people, or this journalist is shit at their job. Which implication do you claim?
- majormajor 5y ago"Bitcoin is supposed to be money" isn't the only pro-crypto position out there. A lot of its current value is driven by people holding and purchasing it from a perspective including things like "this will be the new backing infrastructure for every transaction in the world" not just "this is digital gold."
- wmf 5y agoIsn't the point of Bitcoin precisely that it naturally becomes more and more valuable? If people want money that doesn't make money they can use stablecoins.
- majormajor 5y agoThe fixed number of bitcoins doesn't help you if people decide they want ether instead. Or if either are fine. Or something else in the future. That risk is very alive and well. (I'd argue that the spread of multiple cryptocurrencies has had a major inflationary effect overall in the world economy in the last five years. Lot of people with suddenly fat bank accounts out of nothing.)
- kragen 5y agoI certainly hope not! That's what the article's author was hoping for, but presumably Bitcoin will reach a long-term stable price level at some point. Maybe it already has, or did two years ago when it was at US$8000, or maybe at some point it will rapidly fall to $0 as investors switch to Ether or Grin or ZCash or whatever is popular ten years from now. Its volatility unfortunately appeals to get-rich-quick speculators, but hopefully at some point they'll get burned enough to quit and leave it to serious people. Assuming it doesn't evaporate completely! The problem with "stablecoins" is that they reintroduce the single point of failure that sunk Digicash and e-gold, which Bitcoin was specifically designed to eliminate. Holding Tether is a bet that neither Bitfinex nor the Federal Reserve will decide to make their money machine go brrr. I don't know how you feel about the Federal Reserve but I wouldn't trust Bitfinex with my lunch money, much less my savings or my country's foreign reserves.
- ephbit 5y agoAgree. Many people critize bitcoin for its current volatility and entirely neglect that it can totally change in the long-term. It appears reasonable to me to expect the system dynamic along a pathway towards (possibly) wide adoption to go through various changes. Yes there are probably phases of hype and there's the influence of block reward halvings but there can also be effects in the long-term that stabilize: the more widespread and integrated in various parts of finance and the economy and actual day to day transactions or people's savings bitcoin were to become the more it would dampen volatility. Why that? Because unlike purely speculative financial transactions, day to day transactions are very much restricted and influenced by and thus coupled to rather constant human needs, so a lot less volatile than the former. Now don't get me wrong. I know bitcoin can't directly be used to replace cash because of settlement time and transaction fees. But that's why protocols on top like Lightning exist.
- lawn 5y agoBitcoin can't function well as money as it's too clogged up. That's why the narrative switched from money + adoption to digital gold + number goes up.
- astoor 5y agoI haven't seen any profitable cryptocurrency companies which do anything genuinely useful for non-crypto people in the real world - all the profitable ones are inward-looking, i.e. engaged in "building out the ecosystem" (or "extending the pyramid scheme" depending on your perspective), e.g. the cryptocurrency exchanges. That's a big difference between the internet and cryptocurrency - the internet can be said to have started benefitting ordinary people within a few years, but there's no sign of cryptocurrency ever doing anything useful for the proverbial "man on the Clapham omnibus" after 13 years. In that sense cryptocurrency is more like the gold rush - some people find gold, most people make money selling the shovels, but the vast majority of the world are so far removed from it all that it doesn't impact them in any way whatsoever (except perhaps for the negative effect it has on their environment).
- Animats 5y agoWell, let's see what was pitched at that conference. There's a list.[1] - 24 Exchange Bermuda Ltd. - cryptocurrency exchange - 5 Day Forecast - can't identify, name too widely used - Bitex - cryptocurrency exchange in UAE. - Bitmatrix - "High Risk Merchant Account Solution" - Citizens of Bitcoin - "Global Mobility Assets for Bitcoin Hodlers" - D2X Group - "The pan-European digital derivatives exchange." - DIBA Global Inc - "The future of Digital Art building on #Bitcoin." - Liquid Ventures - hydroelectric powered Bitcoin mining - Moon - probably "Moon Bitcoin", a Bitcoin faucet app - Satoshi’s Games - "integrate blockchain-based play-to-earn economies into ... games" - Sazmining - crypto mining - Shock Network, Inc. - ambiguious, but possibly "Shock Wallet", a hosted crypto wallet So, not one of the companies pitched at the conference described in the article operates outside the crypto bubble. [1] https://b.tc/conference/pitch-day https://b.tc/conference/pitch-day
- igorkraw 5y agoShow me one company that "does things with bitcoin" that 1. does things which aren't already solved for cheaper using standard finance (for example, splitwise makes splitting bills easier, there are disposable credit card solutions, within crypto multi-sig accounts for the masses could be one idea) 2. is not just enabling other people to do something with crypto or building out the "doing something with crypto" capabilities (i.e., the product is used to do what real finance does - facilitate and simplify services and manufacturing of goods. Not trading, not infrastructure for trading, not derivatives, not loans...) 3. Is profitable or generates organic revenue (i.e., has customers actually using their product and paying them for it) Alternatively, show me one company or freelancer denominating their prices in bitcoin, without tying it to the dollar indirectly.
- ephbit 5y ago> 3. Is profitable or generates organic revenue (i.e., has customers actually using their product and paying them for it) Does an e-mail provider accepting payment in bitcoin count?
- igorkraw 5y agoFails number 1
- landemva 5y agoIn my experience in usa it is cheaper and easier to buy real estate with btc. Can still use closing company, if you want to pay those fees. This is just starting, and your tastes may vary. It's nice to have choice.
- igorkraw 5y agoIn Europe, we just have functioning wire transfers. Fails number 1
- landemva 5y agoIn USA closing companies use certified checks. BTC is cheaper and faster than literally having the closing company clerk drive certified checks to various banks. You don't have to use it, though it works well in some situations and very well in big transactions. But you must be in a position to pay the entire purchase price and not rely on fractional reserve lenders to provide the funds to purchase the property. Since I don't need lenders, why would I use the structures that are in place to protect the lenders?
- Mondialisation 5y agoAs opposed to other technologies out there, bitcoin does a very poor job as being money.
- kragen 5y agoAs it turns out, moving money from one group to another† is pretty useful in modern society. It's really all that money is good for, after all. Some of my comments from the last week and a half about what Bitcoin is good for: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30469595 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30469595 when your country's central bank suspends electronic cash transfers, suspends the foreign exchange market, limits cash withdrawals, and prohibits the issuance of foreign currency from retail bank accounts; or when you want to fund a militia in a war zone https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30435990 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30435990 when your bank account gets frozen because your family member supported a political protest in Canada https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30446703 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30446703 in case the government of the current global hegemon imposes economic sanctions against your company or your country; right now that's the US, but probably ten years from now it will be the People's Republic of China https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30408611 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30408611 as an alternative to a bank when "whistleblowers" send the bank history of 30,000 "legitimate clients who had done nothing wrong" to journalists so they can comb through them looking for something to pin on the accountholders https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30375671 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30375671 when five Canadian banks mysteriously have an hours-long outage at the same time I also wrote a bit last year about my observations of how Bitcoin gets used in practice today, outside the world of hoity-toity speculative finance the Harpers article is about: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27448744 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27448744 ______ † Or preventing it from being moved without its owner's consent, which is the value proposition both of safe deposit boxes and the Bitcoin guarantee of a limited money supply.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoBut can you do it without going to jail when sanctions or similar are in place against you? Technically, you can, but you face the same consequences if you were able to get a wire or SEPA transaction through. That's the point. The tech doesn't change the policy or the law. You still go to jail or your country gets shelled. Miners get chased out of countries. Russia is reportedly exploring crypto for transfers if they get knocked off of SWIFT. That does not bode well for crypto when it becomes a weapon of a an enemy combatant state. (obligatory xkcd about getting beaten with a wrench for your private key here)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CodeMage 5y ago> Over the next few months, the tolerance for bullshit, especially in politics, will go way down. Maybe I'm too cynical, but I think it's way more likely that the next few months will allow those politicians who relied on that bullshit in order to push their agenda, to instead push that agenda quietly and with little or no opposition. For example, you don't see a lot of outrage on Twitter over Greg Abbott's persecution of trans children anymore, because Twitter is abuzz with what's going on in Ukraine. This is a thing that is just as "real" as Ukraine, but the collective attention gets focused on one thing at a time, which is why "bullshit in politics" is usually needed.
- ypeterholmes 5y agoCounterpoint- this was yet another tired critique of Bitcoin. How many of these smug, superficial boomer oriented rants must we endure? It's easy to attend conferences and mock people. Meanwhile BTC is playing a meaningful role in the realpolitik you mention, and quickly integrating into the entire banking system. You say BTC has no connection to the real world, as if the Canadian truckers didn't just get their accounts frozen, and cutting Russia off from SWIFT wasn't being discussed. How do you maintain that view in the face of such events?
- AniseAbyss 5y agoHow many rants from young people do we have to endure? You're not going to start the revolution you will become a boring boomer like all the generations before you. The crux is that you are cashing out your bitcoin for £€$ to buy things in a store.
- ypeterholmes 5y agoLet me translate your comment: 1 - The young people are just annoying and don't know anything 2 - Nothing will ever change 3 - Nothing will ever change Needless to say, I disagree with you. Life is constantly changing, and in a few years, likely you will be able to buy almost anything with crypto.
- waffle_maniac 5y ago"Bitcoin Donations To Ukrainian Army Surpass $4 Million" https://archive.is/9YTVe https://archive.is/9YTVe
- uoaei 5y agoUkrainian army is provably infested with neo-Nazis. Right-libs gonna right-lib.
- jmstfv 5y agoWhat the hell are you on about?!
- antifa 5y agoIt is a thing, there are pictures circulating about it, I don't know what conclusions you should draw, but it is something you can read more about. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-cohen-ukraine-commentary/commentary-ukraines-neo-nazi-problem-idUSKBN1GV2TY https://www.reuters.com/article/us-cohen-ukraine-commentary/... https://jewishunpacked.com/can-ukraine-have-a-nazi-problem-with-a-jewish-president/ https://jewishunpacked.com/can-ukraine-have-a-nazi-problem-w...
- uoaei 5y agoExactly the text in OP. Ukraine made some shifty and tenuous alliances with Neo-Nazi militias to expand their ranks. Obviously they're not needed anymore since the entire population is conscripting themselves, so their influence is greatly reduced. I think the deal was made to protect the eastern border but either it didn't work or the Nazis gave up quickly in defense of Ukraine.
- Karrot_Kream 5y ago> That's what real authoritarianism looks like. Not mask mandates. Over the next few months, the tolerance for bullshit, especially in politics, will go way down. I disagree. If you look at the Cold War period, there was all sorts of bitter politics over culture wars throughout the world. The US experienced the Free Speech Movement [1], violent leftist extremist group bombings [2] (concomitant with the rise of leftist extreme violence in the rest of the Americas with groups such as the FARC [3] in the backdrop of some pretty frightening authoritarian leaders), the Civil Rights Movement [4] and several other culturally and politically destabilizing events. All of these things happened in the background of a global conflict between capitalism and communism, when one could argue that left-wing authoritarianism was in full display in the Eastern Bloc. The US only got its act back together politically after the end of the Cold War with the rise of some awkward form of Pax Americana that lasted from roughly from the fall of the Berlin Wall to September 11, 2001. I doubt the events in Ukraine are going to _decrease_ the amount of political sectarianism in the US. If anything, it'll add an additional pressure as groups will be called out to be sympathizers of authoritarianism much as McCarthyism attacked folks for being suspected Communists. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Speech_Movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Speech_Movement [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weather_Underground https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weather_Underground [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolutionary_Armed_Forces_of_Colombia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolutionary_Armed_Forces_of_... [4]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_rights_movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_rights_movement
- naveen99 5y agoLanguage is somehow expected to generate wealth without actually generating any revenue. All it’s good for is moving ideas from person to another, or uttering promises… Math is somehow expected to generate wealth without generating any revenue. Some of it is not even rational, real, or computable.