5 ms·
That... seems like a mistake. The West appears willing to let Ukraine go. They don't like it, but having gotten themselves exhausted by recent wars (especially
by jfengel 5y ago
That... seems like a mistake.
The West appears willing to let Ukraine go. They don't like it, but having gotten themselves exhausted by recent wars (especially the US), they seem to be willing to consider it not-their-problem.
But Finland and Sweden are decidedly aligned with the West, and not only would they not tolerate threats to them, but that re-casts what the situation in Ukraine means. The West might be willing to choke down what could be seen as appeasement, but they need to be able to believe that it's not going to be immediately followed by more. If they're going to be forced to fight, they'd rather do it earlier rather than later.
It's entirely possible that I'm wrong; I'm far from an expert and even the experts seem unclear. But this statement strikes me as extremely dangerous, even in an already tense situation.
- hourislate 5y agoRussia is the product of European Cowardice. Finland needs to prepare for War, If anyone thinks Russia is going to stop at Ukraine, you're terribly wrong.
- jfengel 5y agoI don't think Russia is going to stop at Ukraine, but things get much more difficult for them after that. Ukraine is a war they can win, but only if nobody else cares too much. Finland is not. A war on Finland really is an all-out war, and he will not win that.
- hourislate 5y ago
- tim333 5y ago>How much effort do you think it will take Putin to take Finland? The Russians tried that around WW2 and it didn't go well for them.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoAll of Europe needs to prepare for war. It's not just going to hit Finland.
- hourislate 5y agoSadly you're correct, unfortunately too many European countries are run by people who have a personal vested interest in Russia. It's alarming how many German (ex)politicians have business relations and this isn't just confined to Germany. The German response to Russia is laughable, we are not going to certify a pipeline that was not certified and lets shut down more reactors so we can become more dependent on Russian gas which makes us politicians who work for Gazprom and other Russian companies richer. Don't think I am not including the USA, Wall St is sweating bullets hoping this all goes away so they can get back to licking Russia's balls. It's easy to spot which governments are in Russia's pocket. They don't even try to hide it. Today the world can openly see who stands with freedom/Ukraine and who is in Russia's pocket.
- salawat 5y agoI'm not so sure on that. We didn't offer Ukraine entrance to NATO because we were already appeasing Putin, and Putin wants buffer states. People aren't going to leave NATO... Unless their faith in the mitual defense pact is shaken. Honestly, I don't see this stopping. I see plenty of different scenarios arising out of different levels of commitment to in-theater action. I have this horrible feeling that it'll be war. A-bloody-gain. And possibly a two-fronter.
- jfengel 5y agoThe difference, I think, is that Ukraine wanted NATO to defend them, but NATO wasn't sold on the idea. Ukraine isn't culturally aligned with the rest of Europe; they might like to be but they have a long way to go. Finland and Sweden never asked to be in NATO, largely because they assumed that it would never be required. They are culturally aligned with Europe, but figured they could avoid conflicts without having to commit themselves. This might change their minds. If Putin doesn't take that for an answer, it will indeed be war, and a much, much worse one.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> That... seems like a mistake. It's not a “mistake”, it's the central point. Ukraine is leverage, not the end goal. The end goal is a vast Russian-dominated sphere of influence covering all of Europe in proximity to the borders of Russia (even as Putin also expands those borders.) I mean, yes, the whole strategy leads nowhere but disaster, with only the scope and timescale on dsipute, but this isn't like something that started aimed at a manageable little imperial conquest and then lost focus and got carried away in error; the broader goal has been telegraphed in Putin’s demands and speeches.
- jacquesm 5y agoIt's interesting that even though the truth is out there and has been out there for quite a while that some of these coins just won't drop.
- dragonwriter 5y agoI think the reality, even despite being fairly openly announced, is so far out of many people’s mental model of the relevant conflicts in the modern world that it gets instinctively rationalized into something that seems more reasonable.
- jacquesm 5y agoYes, that's exactly it. I see this around me: 'no, but they said they would not invade' -> they invade. 'they will just take the east' -> they advance direction Kiev. Currently we are at 'they will just take Kiev and then negotiate'. Still in the wings - they take all of Ukraine - they install a puppet government - insurgency will take a couple of years, anybody's guess how it will turn out - and then there are too many forks to list here, but not a single one of those ends well other than the one where Putin is deposed and sent to the Hague for trial, which I give about 0% chance of happening. The rest goes from 'just bad' to 'extremely bad'. Whether we realize it or not: today Ukraine is fighting for the rest of Europe and possibly the world as we know it, this is an avalanche now and when and where it will stop is anybody's guess.