5 ms·
This is a popular view on HN. I have never understood why. Wind and solar are the cheapest sources of power. A decades long propaganda campaign has tried, but
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
This is a popular view on HN. I have never understood why.
Wind and solar are the cheapest sources of power. A decades long propaganda campaign has tried, but failed, to cover that up.
Yet this zombie opinion persists in certain political bubbles that get their information from fossil fuel interests.
And now, when one of those fossil fuel interests invades another nation, the prime culprit is... renewable energy? And it's used as an excuse to talk about how utterly indespendible natural gas is, even though experts want us to dump it as fast as possible? Isn't that oddly convenient for Putin, who seems really well liked by all the same people who tell obvious lies about climate change.
- lazide 5y agoWow, that’s impressively disconnected from reality. The reason why Germany and indirectly most of Europe hasn’t stopped buying gas from Russia is because, despite being a massive (the most massive?) solar and renewable economy, those don’t work very well during the winter. I’m literally pointing out the emperor has no clothes which is why they’re freezing? If they were in a climate with better insolation and more predictable renewable sources, then they’d probably be fine. But they aren’t. If they had adequate storage to deal with peak energy demand during minimum insolation, or had another adequate source, then they would have cut Russia off years ago. But they don’t. They used to, but they have been shutting them down and not building replacement capacity. Instead they’re paying out the nose and scrambling because they don’t have viable options, and resisting the political motions they would otherwise do because Russia has them over a barrel.
- pgeorgi 5y ago> The reason why Germany hasn’t stopped buying gas from Russia is The reason why Germany hasn't stopped buying gas is because there are 12 million gas heaters spread across the country, heating 20 million homes (nearly 50% of housing). We currently bring up 150k heat pumps a year (mostly in new developments). At that rate it takes some 60-80 years to convert all existing gas guzzling real estate over to electric heating. > because, despite being a massive (the most massive?) solar and renewable economy, those don’t work very well during the winter. Last I checked it's winter and we just broke wind power records, multiple times in a row. Wind power has approximately the same installed capacity as solar (60GW each). But it still doesn't help those gas heaters keep people warm.
- lazide 5y agoAnother reason why those gas heaters are still there is because even with those wind and solar numbers, it can’t replace the amount of energy those gas heaters are using - and Germany is already charging insane rates for electrical power. And those numbers are peak, during good conditions. There will be lulls in the wind, clouds, etc. coming over and over again. What then?
- pgeorgi 5y agoThe main reason _this_ house (in Germany) still heats with gas is because it's nigh-impossible to book the professionals who can install a heat pump and modernize the rest of the heating system in a sensible time frame. As mentioned by another comment: even if we were to send all that gas used for heating into gas turbines instead and use the generated electricity to operate the heat pumps, we'd use less gas (because it's using environmental heat energy in addition to the intrinsic energy of the gas). That brings the bonus that we could look into alternative power sources (of whatever kind: I'm sure France would be more than happy to assist bringing up nuclear reactors again, although that's unlikely to happen in Germany for a whole bunch of reasons) when gas is difficult to obtain because electricity is electricity. But apparently we don't have a sufficient number of people who could do the installation, plus it'd be expensive, and even discounting that, I'm not sure if "We need 12 million heat pump systems. Next quarter?" is something that could _possibly_ work even under normal circumstances (nevermind the supply chain issues we're currently dealing with globally). That's why I brought up the 150k installed units per year: There's probably room for improvement (I've been thinking that there must be a very profitable career in heating installations), but even if we can install 600k a year, we're still looking at 20 years before we get all the old cruft converted.
- lazide 5y agoLet’s say all non-trivial natural gas usage (for simplicity) is heating, and due to heat pumps you could reduce energy required to 1/3 of the energy currently provided by burning natural gas (and at 100% efficiency) you’re still looking at about 4 trillion kWh of energy/yr (possibly a month - hard to get good data) that would be needed to do that switch. most of it during winter. Germany currently produces a little over 500 billion kWh of electrical energy a year. So to replace natural gas for heating in this scenario, Germany would need to produce 9x the electrical power it currently produces. Most of it during the winter. And not having enough production would kill people. It isn’t a matter of not having enough heat pumps or people to install them, that’s just the immediate road block if you individually wanted to switch. It’s a fundamental economic issue that would require investment on a scale heretofore not considered outside of world wars. And maybe not even then. Right now, we don’t even know of a storage technology that could even work at that scale, let alone what it would cost to do it. And depending on which way climate changes go, the size of storage needs to be potentially arbitrarily large. The more uncertainty you have, the larger it needs to be. Unlike a fossil fuel, we don’t have (essentially) arbitrarily large reserves we can pull from, it all has to be made and stored in advance by the same infrastructure that produces your normal production.
- muttled 5y agoMy theory is that nuclear worked best in Sim City and that's where most of us draw our governmental experience from.
- emteycz 5y agoNuclear works well and economically in many countries around the world. You're just acting like everyone with a different opinion is an idiot.
- yyyk 5y ago>Wind and solar are the cheapest sources of power. A decades long propaganda campaign has tried, but failed, to cover that up. Even if Wind and Solar could supply 100% of demand tomorrow, we cannot convert all uses of oil and gas quickly. Renewables may be the future, but they are not today. The attempts of some misguided politicians to reduce Western extraction* of fossils merely subsidize Putin and dictators like him. * As opposed for attempts to reduce demand and switch supply to clean fuels which are useful.
- ZeroGravitas 5y ago> "Decades long propaganda campaign"
- lazide 5y agoAnd the reality is, even if nameplate capacity is sufficient - effective capacity is not often enough it would be foolhardy to depend on it during the winter. Natural Gas has a mind blowing amount of thermal energy, and per unit is essentially free compared to anything else. 42-45MJ/kg. Near as I can tell, Germany imported 119 billion cubic meters of natural gas in Jan/Feb of last year. A cubic meter of natural gas has approximately 38MJ of energy in it, so that is around 4.5 x 10^18 joules of energy or 1.2 x 10^13 kWh. Something like 12 trillion kWh. About 40% of that was from Russia (near as I can tell). Natural gas and Electric heating probably have similar end efficiencies (taking into account electric transmission losses).
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoYou seem a really big fan of natural gas. Have you heard of heat pumps? If you burn the gas in electricity plants you can get 3x the efficiency of burning gas for heat. So if the heating power of gas is that impressive to you, then renewable backed heat pumps must be about 10x as impressive. You can even hook them up to the nuclear plants that you were supposedly advocating for before this turned into a love letter to natural gas, Russia's biggest export.
- lazide 5y ago
- babypuncher 5y agoThe cost of wind and solar skyrockets when you factor in the need for energy storage, since neither of those sources operate 24/7.