4 ms·
Tangentially, if you appreciate being able to read raw, unfiltered OSINT like OP (@OAlexanderDK) dug up, you'd be interested to know Twitter mistakenly suspende
by perihelions 5y ago
Tangentially, if you appreciate being able to read raw, unfiltered OSINT like OP (@OAlexanderDK) dug up, you'd be interested to know Twitter mistakenly suspended his account twice in the past three days [0] -- one among a large number of legitimate OSINT people covering Ukraine. The existence of this kind of HN thread is fragile.
You can also read Twitter Site Integrity's apology and response [1], or independent reporting about this [2].
[0] https://twitter.com/OAlexanderDK/status/1496513006657839108 https://twitter.com/OAlexanderDK/status/1496513006657839108
[1] https://twitter.com/yoyoel/status/1496544199478583297 https://twitter.com/yoyoel/status/1496544199478583297
[2] https://www.ft.com/content/5b23938b-49b8-426f-97af-640ba40c9922 https://www.ft.com/content/5b23938b-49b8-426f-97af-640ba40c9... ("Twitter admits it mistakenly removed Ukraine open-source intelligence accounts")
- capableweb 5y agoTo add to the list of unfiltered OSINT straight from Ukraine/Russia, Telegram channels/groups are invaluable (but treat everything as unconfirmed rumors until confirmed elsewhere): - https://t.me/uniannet https://t.me/uniannet - https://t.me/ukrpravda_news https://t.me/ukrpravda_news - https://t.me/istorijaoruzija https://t.me/istorijaoruzija - https://t.me/dumskaya_net https://t.me/dumskaya_net - https://t.me/idelator https://t.me/idelator Beware, some of these are literally Russian propaganda, so again, don't take anything being said/shared as truth until verified elsewhere. In case you need a translation service for the channels, I wrote a Telegram bot that translates anything you send to it/forward to it to English (via DeepL, so higher quality translations than Google Translate), accessible here: - https://t.me/transtel_bot https://t.me/transtel_bot - Source: https://codeberg.org/CapableWeb/transtel https://codeberg.org/CapableWeb/transtel
- reitanqild 5y ago
- isoprophlex 5y agoWhat the actual flying fuck happened there, that's intensely horrible. War is hell.
- reitanqild 5y agoWhat happened is Russian soldiers, either cocky or terrified depending on how much they knew came driving down the road and suddenly the entire thing shook violently, (the rest is my best understanding based on things I learned years ago): temperature rose quickly to become unbearable as the missile stuck the the armour and the warhead sent a payload of molten brass (or something) through the solid metal. As the poor blokes try to escape it seems like something more has gone ablaze as you can see they are frozen while trying to run. Russians going into Ukraine should just as well put sunflower seeds in all pockets and write "this side up" on the front, then at least the grave can look nice in the summer. It's insanely ugly and I have tears in my eyes even if this is the best outcome. Edit: read for yourself, seems the Javelin missile kills the tank crew somewhat more humanely by just sending a multi atmospheric shockwave into the box instead of how these seems to have had time to fear and try in vain to escape. Edit 2: My bigger point is, if you can somehow avoid being part of the attempted invasion of Ukraine it might be worth going some distance to avoid it.
- User23 5y ago> temperature rose quickly to become unbearable as the missile stuck the the armour and the warhead sent a payload of molten brass (or something) through the solid metal. As the poor blokes try to escape it seems like something more has gone ablaze as you can see they are frozen while trying to run. Sounds like a shaped charge[1]. I know a man who was drafted during the Korean War and at first he thought it would be lovely to be in a tank protected from harm. Then he got trained on using shaped charges on old German panzers and decided he was happy to be infantry. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shaped_charge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shaped_charge
- reitanqild 5y agoExactly. I had forgotten the name. And yes, the man you knew probably had learned the same lessons as my dad. Again, this was years ago and I was never equipped with one of these but based on what little I learned and what I see it seems those poor guys where roasted, not knocked dead.
- lostlogin 5y ago> I understand why my dad urged me to not go voluntarily to artillery. Can you explain this further?
- reitanqild 5y agoHe told me that armour is not protection. It is instead a death trap: It is loud, valuable for the enemy and if they shoot at you using shape charges you'll be roasted alive.
- lostlogin 5y agoThanks. I’d assumed that ‘artillery’ would be back from the frontline and slightly safer than some of the other ground based roles.
- reitanqild 5y agoYes, I'm mixing the words here. Heavy artillery stays behind, tanks advance. However heavy artillery is also a target for the opponents heavy artillery, airstrikes etc.
- KarlKemp 5y agoI fail to see what purpose posting gore such as this serves. Nobody needs proof that war is bad.
- reitanqild 5y agoI'm afraid a lot of people have no clue. Their only idea is action movies and FPS games. I don't have much more myself. But I do care deeply and this - while tragic for the poor souls and their poor parents back in Russia - isn't that bad.
- Zababa 5y ago> I'm afraid a lot of people have no clue. Their only idea is action movies and FPS games. The horrors of war is like half of the history classes. It's hard to miss.
- reitanqild 5y agoNot everywhere. I remember intense descriptions of the death camps in primary school books (pictures of a bulldozer moving a pile of corps, detailed descriptions of murdering etc) but about war it always focused on the terror of the civilians (rape, killings, famine, becoming refugees), not the terror of the soldiers: flame throwers, the endless waiting, the fear of killing someone innocent, ambush, mine fields etc. I think a whole lot of people think of war through the lens of the Battlefield series and CSGO where there is Valhalla style mechanic where you go out to fight every day, get slain and become alive to feast in the evening before starting the cycle anew next morning. Also there are no stench, no terrorized faces om of friends or enemy fighters etc. Real war is brutal on a whole different level than games. Note: I'm not saying we shouldn't teach the horrors civilians face, just that I think people have extremely unrealistic views of what war is like. If anyone is in doubt: stay out of wars if you can avoid. And a very effective way is to 1.) train for war so you become a scary target 2.) don't start a war.
- dijonman2 5y agoIt needs to be shared and break through cognitive dissonance. So many people sit comfortably in their chairs at home opining and spew thoughts online without any real idea of how bad things really are. This is real life.
- jazzyjackson 5y ago> don't take anything being said/shared as truth until verified elsewhere. Then what is the possible value of following it? I spent an hour or so trying to get updates on twitter and spent the whole time flagging the same fake videos posted over and over.
- capableweb 5y ago> Then what is the possible value of following it? The same value you get from following any other news source?
- ComputerGuru 5y ago> You can also read Twitter Site Integrity's apology and response [1] What apology? Vague explanation but no even “sorry for the inconvenience” at the link you shared: We’re closely investigating — but mass reporting is not a factor here. A small number of human errors as part of our work to proactively address manipulated media resulted in these incorrect enforcements. We’re fixing the issue and reaching out directly to the affected folks.
- perihelions 5y agoThe "reaching out" part included directed apologies. (Is this really the important part?) https://twitter.com/OAlexanderDK/status/1496452673008279552 https://twitter.com/OAlexanderDK/status/1496452673008279552 ("...we apologize for any inconvenience this may have caused")
- ComputerGuru 5y ago> Is this really the important part? I'm not sure if I'm understanding you right, but if you're asking whether I think it's important that twitter either apologized or at least "apologized," I do indeed. The major social media institutions have touted themselves to be champions of getting the word out and a replacement for all other avenues of communication, leading to the demise of self-hosted (or, at least, self-moderated) blogs, websites, irc, regular discussion forums, and everything in between. But they continually screw up this responsibility at the times when it matters most, and we have to hold them accountable for this. Look at how all of Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter accidentally blocked OSINT coming out of Israel and Palestine after similarly being DDOS'd with "report this tweet/image/post" from either employees of intelligence agencies, paid shills, or just "the other side" to hide the ground truths. It's not OK for this to happen. It keeps happening. The lack of remorse indicates that regardless of intention or motive, there's no real vested interest in actually keeping avenues of grassroot journalism open on these platforms (it's probably not the kind of content that makes them muchmoney, so no surprise there). In this case, there was no public apology (or "apology") - the "sorry for the inconvenience" was in one-on-one correspondence with the blocked OSINT account.
- mzs 5y agoI support OSINT but this particular person has repeatedly been wrong and alarmist - plus he toots his horn for being right even when he's wrong: https://twitter.com/badc0fee/status/1495914223427276804 https://twitter.com/badc0fee/status/1495914223427276804 This particular case is likely armor kicking-up radioactive dust, and since the ground is wet it's not much of a problem: https://twitter.com/badc0fee/status/1497253041854025728 https://twitter.com/badc0fee/status/1497253041854025728
- ineedasername 5y ago>he's wrong It's a bit surreal that the 3rd entry down in the more "more tweets" suggestions (for me*)for that link is as follows: Credit it where it's due: Hyundai have knocked it out of the ballpark with the Potato Storage Capacity (PSC) on the Ioniq 5 Good job there Twitter, really hit the nail on the head trying to surface other relevant tweets. *And that's me not logged in, with no Twitter account at all, cookies cache etc. cleared. (With respect to this particular person, being wrong or alarmist still shouldn't be sufficient to get banned. Heck, a few days ago there were reasonable people saying that speculating on a Russian invasion was alarmist. [0] She has expressed regret for that view now, though she still claims [1] that U.S. raising the alarm is possibly what caused the invasion. It's a strange line of reasoning: "Putin was just putting 100k+ troops there, not invading, but because you think he was going to invade he now had no choice" ) [0] https://www.democracynow.org/2022/2/22/nina_khrushcheva_on_putins_ukraine_moves https://www.democracynow.org/2022/2/22/nina_khrushcheva_on_p... [1] https://www.npr.org/2022/02/24/1082746202/did-the-u-s-push-putin-into-a-corner-forcing-him-to-invade-ukraine https://www.npr.org/2022/02/24/1082746202/did-the-u-s-push-p...
- mzs 5y agoOSINT should be imagery and/or audio with a place and time, speculation should be limited and reasoned. Here are some accounts doing that instead: https://twitter.com/RALee85 https://twitter.com/RALee85 https://twitter.com/IAPonomarenko https://twitter.com/IAPonomarenko https://twitter.com/GirkinGirkin https://twitter.com/GirkinGirkin
- 5y ago
- ineedasername 5y ago>apology and response Twitter: We do not trigger automated enforcements based on report volume, ever That really isn't reassuring when whichever methods Twitter uses failed nonetheless. And they merely stated that volume isn't the trigger for automated enforcements. I'd be very surprised if it wasn't one of the factors considered. Regardless, it comes down to either bad algorithms or bad human interpretations, or both.