3 ms·
There was a time when RAR was extremely popular because it dealt very well with splitting things across multiple diskette-sized archives, and because it edged o
by rcarmo 5y ago
There was a time when RAR was extremely popular because it dealt very well with splitting things across multiple diskette-sized archives, and because it edged out PKZIP in compression.
Regardless of its origins and... "traditional" use, these days it has zero relevance given that Windows and MacOS (as well as some Linux file managers) allow you to handle zip files without any additional software - and also because many file formats have evolved to support built-in compression.
I do find it extremely annoying, though, when I have to help someone rifle through old backups and need to expand a RAR archive, or when someone (for whatever reason) decides to package downloads in that way (the last culprit I remember was a Chinese company who packaged their MCU tooling that way).
- vbezhenar 5y agoMail servers still have restriction on attachment size. RAR is the most convenient way in this situation.
- vetinari 5y agoAlso, when mail scanners became too nosy, it was convenient that rar could encrypt metadata, so the archive could not be scanned. It lasted only for a while. Gmail drops such files entirely for the last few years.
- exmadscientist 5y agoRAR is still the only format that has PAR2 (?) recovery records trivially available. So it's still the best for long-term archiving.
- ihateolives 5y agoYeah, I don't know why this is never mentioned in comparisons. This is nice to have feature. I wouldn't care at all about speed for long term archiving, because it's one time occurrence, but I would care whether archive format has extra safety feature against bit rot.
- adrian_b 5y agoPAR2 can be easily used with any other archive format and any compression algorithm. For example I am using it with a pax archive format (which unlike tar handles correctly all file metadata, e.g. extended attributes) and with lrzip compression (better for large files, e.g. movies, which do not compress well with more usual algorithms). I assume that WINRAR may have a simpler interface for inexperienced users, but a knowledgeable user can easily write a pair of simple scripts with all the command-line options needed to combine PAR2 with any archive file format and any compression algorithm and arrange them to be invoked e.g. by right-clicking on a directory or on an archive file.
- nix23 5y ago>So it's still the best for long-term archiving. No it's not, lzip is it and war, as written by archive.org and the European-IT-department
- Karunamon 5y agoOS built-in zip handling is extremely limited. You're allowed to create archives and... that's it. You have no control over the compression level or anything else. And frankly, 7z has terrible ergonomics. Both the UI and the CLI are uncomfortable and ugly.