4 ms·
Seems like around Windows 95 was the last time designers put a thought to designing for usability and around the actual constraints in the medium. Most modern
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
Seems like around Windows 95 was the last time designers put a thought to designing for usability and around the actual constraints in the medium.
Most modern UIs seem to focus almost entirely on clean aesthetics, usually mindlessly drawing on conventions that serve limitations that exist in mobile, such as being really conservative about using screen space.
I think desktop Firefox is an excellent example of this. A lot of very useful features are hidden behind an additional click on a minuscule ≡-button (What does that symbol even mean? Why doesn't it have a label?) All, it appears, to save hundreds pixels of screen space, while desktop displays are getting bigger and bigger and bigger. You can't even use full screen windows on many desktop displays, you'll get neck pain from literally having to turn your head to read.
- projektfu 5y agoWorth mentioning that you can turn the pull down menus back on in Firefox.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoRight, but my point is this: What is the point in saving some sub 1% of screen space from a screen that is typically too big to even be fully utilized? Why are all the buttons tiny and hard to click, why do they have hieroglyphic symbols with no labels? A button for opening an ad for a third party app (Pocket) is important enough to be immediately accessible. Why aren't my bookmarks deemed as important? Makes a lot of sense on a mobile device where screen space is very limited. But on desktop?
- prmoustache 5y agoHow many times do you really use that ≡ "burger" menu button of firefox in a day really? And after how many times do you end up having learned the keyboard shortcuts? There are only a handful of them that don't have a keyboard shortcut.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoIs there a keyboard shortcut for the ≡ menu? How do I open the bookmarks bar?
- prmoustache 5y agoafaik ctrl+shift+b show/hide you the bookmark toolbar. I think there is none for the ≡ menu nor for settings* which is sad but most submenus are covered. I actually wish I could unmap or change the inspector menu shortcut (ctrl+shift+c) as I often use it by mistake if trying to copy/paste stuff from browser to my terminal. * I actually do ctrl+t then type pref and find preferences in the history usually instead.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoHonestly, maybe I just don't get design, but if having to use a search field to find basic features in an application isn't just resignation as an interface designer, then what is?
- prmoustache 5y agoFor a feature you use once every other week/month I don't see it as a resignation. Don't see the point from a UI perspective to show me everything, including features I may never ever use, each time I want to access features used on a more frequent basis.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoDon't you think you would use them more if they weren't hidden behind a menu within a menu behind a tiny button that's almost impossible to click because it's so small?
- prmoustache 5y agoDoubt that, I know they exist.
- hjkl0 5y agoThe “Hamburger” button or “≡” represents a list of options, which is what a menu is.