4 ms·
As long as the ACM continues using copyright to restrict access to the intellectual heritage of humanity, they are in no position to comment on the ethics of co
by kragen 5y ago
As long as the ACM continues using copyright to restrict access to the intellectual heritage of humanity, they are in no position to comment on the ethics of corporate behavior.
In this article, Vardi says, "I have seen practically no serious discussion in the ACM community of its relationship with surveillance-capitalism corporations;" well, that's because people who take ethics seriously avoid participating in the ACM community.
- kurthr 5y agoYou know what... I think both can be true, and it's good for you to point out the hypocrisy. ACM has been around a long time and they've gotten some stuff right and missed a lot of stuff, but when they come out to talk about ethics, it's time to hold their feet to the fire.
- kragen 5y agoDo you know anybody in the current ACM leadership? Maybe you could talk with them.
- danaris 5y agoThis kind of attitude is detrimental to the overall progress and improvement of ethics in general. Insisting on absolute ideological purity before a person or group is "allowed" (or "in a position to") make any comment on ethics is both hopelessly unrealistic and deeply counterproductive. Yes, there are ethical stances, and records of conduct, that are so egregious they call into question anything else someone says—but to say that the ACM is "in no position" to call for improved ethics in AI and a move away from surveillance capitalism because of a completely unrelated objection you have to their conduct regarding copyright does no one any service. Call out their bad behavior, yes—but when they say something that's genuinely positive, acknowledge that. Reward behavior you would like to see repeated, even if it isn't absolutely everything you want or responding to your personal pet peeve.
- YesThatTom2 5y agoACM is moving to an open publishing model. acmQUEUE is open. (Not speaking for ACM)
- kragen 5y agoI hope so. They own the copyright to a huge amount of their published material, which as adrian_b points out above includes most of the important historical record of the computing field. If they move to an open publishing model, they'd relicense it under Creative Commons Attribution or Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike (CC-BY or CC-BY-SA), which would be an enormous contribution. However, as far as I know, this isn't even being discussed within the ACM leadership or membership.
- kragen 5y agoYou may be right. Certainly purity spirals are enormously caustic. However, I don't think the copyright problem is completely unrelated to the problem of surveillance capitalism. Elsevier's excuse for embedding tracking cookies in their papers is copyright, and the main thing preventing competitors to YouTube from popping up is also copyright. Google's primary excuse for scanning users' cloud files without their permission is also copyright, although they also have kiddie porn, which is Apple's excuse. Copyright is the excuse for the DRM in Amazon's ebooks, Netflix's movies, and XBox games, all of which form extremely powerful surveillance-capitalism platforms—in large part because the users are prohibited from disabling the surveillance functionality. Copyright is a powerful centralizing force in the software industry; without copyright, ex-Google and ex-Fecebutt employees would have a much easier time founding companies to compete with Google and Fecebutt, which would enable users to choose trustworthy companies instead of companies with government-granted monopolies on the software their employees wrote. So I think copyright and surveillance capitalism are deeply intertwined, though the ACM is not itself using copyright for surveillance, to my knowledge.
- adrian_b 5y agoWhile in general I agree with you about those who abuse copyright, of all organizations that I am aware of, ACM is the one who abuses copyright the least. Unlike many other organizations, which might ask you for $30 for each research paper of a few pages whom you happen to want to read, for about $200 (membership fee + library fee) you can have access for a year to the entire ACM digital library, where there are at least a few hundreds of thousands of research papers, or maybe millions, including the vast majority of all which were important in the first few decades of computing technology, and which, in my opinion, are still more relevant today than many people who read only the latest papers believe (because many of the latest papers frequently rediscover already known old techniques).
- DannyBee 5y ago"well, that's because people who take ethics seriously avoid participating in the ACM community." No true scotsman would participate in the ACM community.