3 ms·
I think suffrage is a bit of a one-dimensional way of measuring a democracy. Athens puts all modern democracies to shame in who actually held office, and ensur
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
I think suffrage is a bit of a one-dimensional way of measuring a democracy.
Athens puts all modern democracies to shame in who actually held office, and ensuring that those that did had real skin in the game.
I imagine contemporary politics would look very differently if officials that fucked up risked ten years of exile by public vote.
- hulitu 5y ago> I imagine contemporary politics would look very differently if officials that fucked up risked ten years of exile by public vote. But would be wonderful. You will see an increase in responsability.
- xeromal 5y agoOr every 4 years, we just exile the old president. lol
- toqy 5y agoI don't imagine exile would be as bad today as it would back then. Our national level politicians are fairly wealthy too. Getting exiled as a local level politician would be tough though.
- earleybird 5y agoAssuming that would be exile relative to the jurisdiction of service - you might have to move to the next town :-)
- marginalia_nu 5y agoYou got to keep in mind most Athenian officials were selected via sortition (i.e. random lot), not elected. If you were eligible to vote, you were eligible for a term in office. Only a small fraction of the officials were elected, including for example generals.
- ThalesX 5y agoIIRC, you could basically put your name in the lot, or put the name of whoever you thought would make a fit candidate.
- groby_b 5y ago"Athens puts all modern democracies to shame in who actually held office, and ensuring that those that did had real skin in the game" Well, unless you were a woman, a slave, or under 30, in which case oh well. Let's not exaggerate the glory of Athens.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoRight, but who gets to vote is just one aspect of it. Regardless of the fact more people get to vote in our democracy, our officials almost without exception are from a fairly small socioeconomic elite. This has changed remarkably little since universal suffrage some hundred odd years ago. Despite how a lot of people get to vote, not a lot of people get to rule. The key difference, in Athens, is most political appointments were by random lot. It was literally a government by the people. No matter who you were, if you were eligible to vote, you could end up with political office. This is just not true with our modern democracies. Most people eligible to vote have no realistic path to political office.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- watwut 5y ago> No matter who you were, if you were eligible to vote, you could end up with political office. Point is, this was rather small portion of population. And who you were, who parents were, mattered a lot in whether you was eligible to vote. > This is just not true with our modern democracies. Most people eligible to vote have no realistic path to political office. There is too many of us eligible.
- marginalia_nu 5y ago> Point is, this was rather small portion of population. And who you were, who parents were, mattered a lot in whether you was eligible to vote. Sure, but what does voting matter if the options basically are the same? > There is too many of us eligible. Right, but I'll repeat the criticism you levied above. In modern democracy, who you are, and who your parents are, matters a lot in whether you are de facto eligible to hold office.
- yongjik 5y ago> I imagine contemporary politics would look very differently if officials that fucked up risked ten years of exile by public vote. Imagine Google hires new developers with one condition: if they fuck up they'll never get another job in America for ten years. It will virtually guarantee that the only applicants are those with a delusion of grandeur or those who can't get a job elsewhere.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoThe elegant balance of the system is that everyone eligible to vote in Athens were eligible to be selected for office (through random lot). Officials weren't some distant elite separate from the voters, it could be your neighbor, it could be you next. This sort of creates an incentive to moderate the use of ostracism to the times someone really fucked up bad.