2 ms·
Are we actually learning new bits of fundamental science from these experiments? Are there still bits of these fusion reactions we can't simulate accurately en
by londons_explore 5y ago
Are we actually learning new bits of fundamental science from these experiments?
Are there still bits of these fusion reactions we can't simulate accurately enough due to insufficient compute?
Or is it just a matter of ironing out engineering issues?
- jillesvangurp 5y agoI think given recent progress from several companies and research institutes, we might be seeing an increasing shift to solving engineering challenges indeed. Fusion has definitely moved beyond the proof of concept stage. It's no longer just a theoretical possibility. Many challenges still remain of course. But it might be a lot closer than the 20-30 years that people have historically assumed it would take. It seems there are a couple of companies shooting for working power plants a lot sooner than that that are getting a lot of funding. Maybe even this decade. From there to commercialization might still take a lot of time of course.
- willis936 5y agoIt's both in every case so far. Machines are made and operated to discover empirical data, but we invent the engineering along the way. Computation is woefully insufficient for particle level simulation. If we had a proper model of turbulence that issue would be lessened. We don't have a full grasp on plasma physics. If we did we could point to a single stellarator geometry and say "that one". The physics and engineering also interplay at many levels. Optimal decisions at every level take both the plasma physics and engineering into account.
- regularfry 5y agoIt depends where on the "fundamental science <-> engineering" spectrum you think materials science sits. Some of the thorniest problems in reactor design are "wtf do you make it out of and can such a thing exist". There's some science going on confirming material theoretical properties under reactor conditions. Mind you, insufficient compute is also a problem. Although "insufficient" is probably underselling the scale of the issue. Simulating plasma is horrid. It's all the worst bits of both fluid dynamics and electromagnetics all rolled into one: you've got a potentially chaotic fluid where all the particles aren't just interacting with the things they bounce off, they're also interacting with other particles all throughout the body of the fluid through electromagnetic effects. Everything affects everything else, and (because chaos) the details matter.