5 ms·
Dear Nature
- michael_dorfman 18y agoIt was (predatory) pricing policies like this that led Knuth and the entire editorial board of the "Journal of Algorithms" to resign en masse, and start a new journal with the ACM. For those interested, the statement from the board can be found at http://www.cs.colorado.edu/~hal/s.pdf http://www.cs.colorado.edu/~hal/s.pdf, and Knuth's (long, fascinating) letter to his colleagues can be found at http://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/joalet.pdf http://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/joalet.pdf
- wheels 18y agoI consider the ACM just as bad. Their membership pricing is restrictive for casual users and their conferences are worse. I also consider their restrictions on who is able to become a member insulting (though they don't apply to me). Wait, so a physicist who's taken up programming in the last year isn't supposed to be able to read papers on computation?
- arebop 18y agoRE: restrictions on who is able to become a member: "Membership Qualifications You must satisfy one of the qualifications below: 1. Bachelor's Degree (in any subject area); or 2. Equivalent Level of Education; or 3. Two years full-time employment in the IT field." --- https://campus.acm.org/public/ProfQJ/qjprof_control.cfm?form_type=Professional https://campus.acm.org/public/ProfQJ/qjprof_control.cfm?form...
- jgrahamc 18y agoSorry, Michael Faraday you don't have the relevant experience or degree so you can't have access to that information. Huh? You mean you attended _free_ lectures by Sir Humphrey Davy and then went on to become one of the greatest scientists of all time. Wow. Those were the days.
- wheels 18y agoI know a number of OSS contributors that would fall foul of that. Think for instance of somebody that dropped out college and is working in something non-IT, but still likes to sling code. It's just a really useless requirement, especially given that you have to pay $200 on top of it. If there were real, you know, proficiency requirements or something that would be one thing, but anybody who's had any job in IT for two years?
- michael_dorfman 18y agoThey can read the papers, and subscribe to the journals-- they just don't get the member's discount. Seriously: do you know of a (useful) professional organization that has no restrictions on membership?
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- apu 18y agoThis happened again, more recently, in the machine learning community. Here is the resignation letter from the editorial board of the _Machine Learning_ journal, as they left to start an open journal: http://www.sigir.org/forum/F2001/sigirFall01Letters.html http://www.sigir.org/forum/F2001/sigirFall01Letters.html The new "Journal of Machine Learning Research": http://jmlr.csail.mit.edu/ http://jmlr.csail.mit.edu/
- jgrahamc 18y agoI should have added that this sort of thing is why PLoS is so important. http://plos.org/ http://plos.org/
- mechanical_fish 18y agoI seriously believe that this -- the fact that you need access to a university library, a research grant, or several thousand dollars worth of discretionary income just to read the primary source materials of the last 70 years of science -- is the reason why so much of the planet is scientifically illiterate. We ask why the hilarious notion that science is just a species of religion -- a collection of essentially arbitrary dogmas handed down by priests in white coats -- has taken such hold among the populace. But, really, what does the public see of modern science but dogma? The state of the art -- the debate, the argument, the statistical calculations, the brilliant conclusions, the idiotic conclusions, even the raw data itself -- is all locked up behind paywalls and private conferences and university tuitions. 99.5% of the world never sees actual science being done. At best, they do toy science in their classrooms and read prepackaged science-flavored PR in their magazines. The best the public can hope for is a bunch of documentaries and popularizations, some of which are great. But nearly all of them are second-hand, many of them contain major omissions, mistakes, or distortions, and they feel constrained by their need to maintain their mass audience of businesspeople on planes -- they tend to not publish graphs or, god help us, equations. Of course, most of the public wouldn't understand Nature even if it became free and open tomorrow. Many of the papers are written in barely-comprehensible jargon. But that's not a coincidence; it's a side effect of allowing journals to evolve into niche publications for a handful of graduate students. Perhaps, in the world where scientific publications are available to anyone to read, journals will slowly evolve toward a standard of writing that allows interested fans to follow along. Or a genre of annotated journal articles might arise.
- DaniFong 18y agoAlternatively, people will just start publishing online, on blogs or wikis or something else. It's already starting to happen; math is leading the way. Much of my website is somewhere in the space between 'blog entry' and 'paper'.
- robg 18y agoFurthermore, where else do content creators pay for the privilege of publishing their work (over $1000 usually per paper), then have those outrageous rates for visitors to access that work?
- andreyf 18y agowhere else do content creators pay for the privilege of publishing their work Do they really? I've never heard of this...
- mechanical_fish 18y agoThey're called "page charges", they are absolutely real, and yeah, they're often like $100 to $150 per article page, plus extras. Here's the price quote for the Journal of Dairy Science (which just won the Google lottery and is being rewarded with a link): http://jds.fass.org/misc/ifora.shtml http://jds.fass.org/misc/ifora.shtml
- robg 18y agoForgot to mention that for the privilege you also give up publication rights. So, let's review: You pay to publish. They charge outrageous fees for access. You retain the copyright, they retain the publication rights. To be fair, I can't imagine their business model is making anyone rich. They pay professional editors and they pump out alot of PR that's good for science. But the original complaint - access on old manuscripts - is very valid.
- michael_nielsen 18y agoThe largest journal company, Elsevier, made about 1.5 billion in profit last year, on about 5 billion in revenue. Not bad.
- robg 18y agoWow - link? Are they publicly traded?
- aswanson 18y agoMr. Graham-Cummings, Amen. Kindly forward a similar letter to the IEEE and ACM. Regards, aswanson