3 ms·
What makes Russia position understandable? What gives them right to occupy Ukraine?
by watwut 5y ago
What makes Russia position understandable? What gives them right to occupy Ukraine?
- Wiseacre 5y agoUnderstandable does not mean justifiable.
- rmu09 5y agoSuppose canada tried to join china and north korea in some kind of military pact. USA would not possibly tolerate that.
- runarberg 5y agoYou are absolutely right. However, consider now that USA invades Canada as a result of this. This is infinity worse and always unacceptable. Nobody—not even American citizens—would tolerate that.
- RobertoG 5y agoSure, because American citizens don't accept USA invading other countries. Two week of 24 hours news with the proper perspective and the people would be asking in the streets for the invasion of Canada.
- runarberg 5y agoThe last time USA invaded a foreign country under a false pretense we saw the biggest protests in US history. But then I do have to admit that Bush was reelected in the next election, so perhaps you are right and I am wrong.
- RobertoG 5y agoBy the way, I don't mean that American citizens are special in this. We are all brainwashed in supporting what was already decided.
- DocTomoe 5y agoGiven what we have seen American citizens tolerate in the past, I expect public opinion not only to support such an invasion, but for Americans to enthusiastically participate. In fact, some redneck militia trying to invade Canada is a common trope in US entertainment (from South Park over to The West Wing, even a whole movie exists), implying that it would be pretty easy. It's played for laughs, but it adds to the desensitisation of the public opinion about such an endeavour. Consent is manufactured.
- sofixa 5y agoThe position is understandable because Russia is playing a Grand Strategy Game in the past, and doesn't want the enemy ( NATO) to be at all their borders. Justified? Right? Humane? Absolutely not.
- watwut 5y agoThat is not understandable. "I don't like nato at the border, therefore I will push my border toward nato". Russian "nato is ennemy" exists, because Russia wants nato be ennemy. It prevents further expansion.
- hef19898 5y agoOf those two, Russia and NATO, the only expansion since the end of the cold war and the fall of the USSR was done by NATO. That's just a historical fact. Which doesn't justify anything, but explains a lot. All that is purely academic now so, with people in Ukraine dying over this shit.
- watwut 5y agoAnd Nato expansion was done by allowing coutries who wanted to do join Nato to go in. Yes, some of their motivation was to prevent Russia to attempt to expand again into their borders. > All that is purely academic now so, with people in Ukraine dying over this shit. That is not purely academic. Framing what Russia is doing now as kinda similar to Czech voluntary joining Nato is word class propaganda. It is in fact a lie.
- hef19898 5y agoNot sure where I compared the NATO expansion, a peaceful one, to Russia's invasions of Georgia and Ukraine. All I'm saying is that Russia, pretty much since German reunification, worried about NATO expansion to the East. And personally, I get that. After all, NATO and the USSR (along the Warsaw Pact) used to be sworn enemies for decades by then. This escalation started decades ago, and was totally foreseeable. And yes, the discussion about the root causes, what-ifs and past errors becomes pointless once bullets fly and people start to die.
- RobertoG 5y agoUkraine is in the middle of two "powers" and the proper role would be one of buffer. They could even benefit from that. Unfortunately, the Russian and the USA have both tried to take that part of the board for them and the Ukrainian population is split on their loyalties. Russian, simply can't allow more of the board, specially one part so close, to be dominated by the opponent. Anyone that think this conflict in terms of "good" or "bad" have been drinking the kool-aid. My prediction: A repetition of Crimea. The Donbas will be incorporate to the Russian area of influence, but not the rest of Ukraine, some noises will be done by the West about sanctions or whatever and in five years nobody will remember. Hope to be right, because other scenarios are really scary.
- watwut 5y agoOne country is attacked by neighborhooding country with history of expanding into neighborhooding countries. > Russian, simply can't allow more of the board, specially one part so close, to be dominated by the opponent. Russian in fact could allow that. Whether Ukraine joins Nato should be between Ukraine internal debate and Nato internal debate. That Ukraine has both opinions present does not excuse nor explain Russian war.
- RobertoG 5y agoThat's all very nice, but, unfortunately is not how the world works. What about the Donbas region, do they have the right to decide in an internal debate? Instead of trying to be pro-Russian or pro-West, Ukraine have lost a chance of become Switzerland and make a live getting presents from both sides. Now, I think, it's going to be split.
- watwut 5y ago> Instead of trying to be pro-Russian or pro-West, Ukraine have lost a chance of become Switzerland and make a live getting presents from both sides. Now, I think, it's going to be split. Bullshit. And yes, I am anti-Russian expansion. This is a threat to myself, my family, my friends and my kids, actually. I am very pro-western and very happy my home country managed to be nato member. Stop paining equivalence between Russia and Nato now.