4 ms·
Non-error-message link: https://birdsite.xanny.family/EstonianGovt/status/1496728085890273284 https://birdsite.xanny.family/EstonianGovt/status/1496728085... T
by kragen 5y ago
Non-error-message link: https://birdsite.xanny.family/EstonianGovt/status/1496728085890273284 https://birdsite.xanny.family/EstonianGovt/status/1496728085...
Text, 57 minutes ago:
"#Estonia unequivocally condemns #Russia's military attack on #Ukraine and we have decided to launch #NATO consultations under Article 4 of the North Atlantic Treaty with Latvia, Lithuania, Poland and other Allies."
Crepuscular photo of some buildings and link to https://valitsus.ee/en/news/estonian-government-requests-consultations-under-article-4-nato-treaty https://valitsus.ee/en/news/estonian-government-requests-con....
This could be the key escalation that turns the Russian invasion of Ukraine into World War III.
- bremac 5y agoThat's rather hyperbolic. Article 4 has been invoked six times since 2003 (including in response to the Crimean invasion.) None of those cases triggered World War III.
- throwaway5752 5y agoThis is orders of magnitude different than those prior invocations.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- baby 5y agoWorld wars start from something small. Not saying this is it, but there are all the reasons to be concerned about today’s events.
- darebak 5y agoI don't think that any of the world wars started out of small things, can you clarify?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- selfhoster11 5y agoWorld War 1 started because a guy was assassinated, for one. The tension was there, but the assassination was what set everything into motion.
- polotics 5y agoMany historical analysis of the start of WW1 highlight the slow communication and mobilization processes as the main cause of why European military leaders thought they had to move first, just in case the other side had already started and they hadn't heard... Another way to see it is that oligarchies of the time thought it expedient to have yet another 19th century war, and didn't factor in advances in technology: machine guns, artillery, chemical warfare... A bit like with drones and AI now: the outcome and shape of the Ukraine conflict wil inform us all of the specific bloody taste of 21st century resource wars. To anyone reading this in countries dependent on Ukrainian wheat imports (eg. North-Africa) Stock up on the pasta!
- gattilorenz 5y ago"a guy" to describe the future emperor of the Austria-Hungary is an understatement. It's like saying that the world was shocked because in 1963 a guy was shot. Yes, technically true, but...
- ricardobayes 5y agoYes. Tough to believe, but Austria-Hungary had the biggest army in the world, at the time.
- selfhoster11 5y agoI deliberately phrased it this way. Yes, he was an important guy. But ultimately, just a normal guy, like the rest of us.
- oblio 5y ago
- atoav 5y agoSo hasn't any crown prince murder since the first world war.
- kragen 5y agoIt's not hyperbole. There were plenty of political assassinations in the years before 01914 that didn't trigger World War I, too. Hopefully this is another time Article 4 is invoked without triggering World War III. But it may not be.
- ricardobayes 5y agoI agree, Article 4 is nothing more than a consultation request. The real big thing is Article 5, which means if any ally is attacked, the others will help. Blinken confirmed US commitment to this is "ironclad".
- kragen 5y agoI don't know a lot about these issues, but here's the way I see it. Ukraine isn't part of NATO, and Estonia hasn't been attacked, so Article 5 can't be invoked. Therefore, this is roughly the maximally aggressive possible response from Estonia. Of course the US Secretary of State says US commitment to Article 5 is "ironclad"; if he doesn't say that, NATO basically stops existing, and with it much of the US's influence in the world. Therefore the fact that he says this conveys almost zero information.
- sgjohnson 5y agoI'll believe the US "ironclad" commitment to Article 5 when they build an air base and a naval base in the Baltics. Because if Putin was to attack the Baltics tomorrow, they would cease to exist before any NATO ally would manage to get their warships past the Kaliningrad Oblast in the Baltic Sea.
- chrischen 5y agoPrevious World Wars were not one-sided. Pretty much the majority of the developed world (probably all of the developed world?) is against Russia right now.
- querez 5y agoI think China is still pretty neutral about the whole thing. Putin payed respects to China (e.g. at the Olympiads), while (at least afaik) no western nation tried to get China onboard with sanctions -- or at the very least, they didn't send their presidents over to talk to Xi.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mise_en_place 5y agoOf course they would be neutral, if not covertly supporting this action. This is testing the waters for China to invade Taiwan.
- ricardobayes 5y agoGotta hand that small remark to Putin, he upheld the tradition of no war during Olympics. Olympics were actually created to act as a pressure release valve in ancient Greece, which constantly fought wars between the Greeks, Spartans and Persians.
- jb1991 5y ago> Gotta hand that small remark to Putin, he upheld the tradition of no war during Olympics Putin hardly cares about that tradition. "In 2008, Russia launched a military intervention into disputed regions of Georgia in eastern Europe. The conflict unfolded at the same time as the opening ceremonies at the summer Olympic games in Beijing—with Putin, then prime minister and Russia’s leader in all but name, in attendance alongside US president George W. Bush, who did not look pleased. Six years later, Putin had an opportunity to repeat the trick, during the 2014 Winter Olympics hosted by Russia. At the time, the pro-Russian government of Ukraine was collapsing, with protestors demonstrating against Ukraine’s withdrawal from ties with the European Union. The night before the games’ closing ceremony, Putin took part in a lengthy meeting with his security team to plan an intervention in Ukraine." https://qz.com/1203504/2018-winter-olympics-russia-probably-wont-start-a-war-during-this-years-olympics/ https://qz.com/1203504/2018-winter-olympics-russia-probably-...