10 ms·
They consider their security to be threatened, and requested NATO to discuss it. Officially. Which is kind of a big deal. Article 5 can be invoked once, intent
by hef19898 5y ago
They consider their security to be threatened, and requested NATO to discuss it. Officially. Which is kind of a big deal.
Article 5 can be invoked once, intentionally or by accident, e.g. a NATO plane is attacked over Ukraine. This whole thing is a mess. Despite history since the end of the cold war (which makes some of Russia's positions somewhat understandable, and the fact that NATO didn't do anything different in Iraq and Afghanistan), if Western-style democracies don't want to loose their freedoms they have to act. Appeasement usually doesn't work with expansionist powers.
- ajmurmann 5y ago> Despite history since the end of the cold war (which makes some of Russia's positions somewhat understandable, and the fact that NATO didn't do anything different in Iraq and Afghanistan) Can you expand on this? I'm entirely unable to understand why Russia after the cold war didn't become like any other European country and aimed to join the EU etc.
- raverbashing 5y agoBecause Russia has a complicated history. Democracy is a lot of work
- hnbad 5y agoConsidering the EU currently includes at least one literal dictatorship and NATO includes Turkey, I think pretending this has anything to do with morals and shared values is a bit dishonest.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- int_19h 5y agoIt actually did consider joining the EU, and even NATO at one point, but it wasn't taken seriously by either. The NATO intervention in Kosovo was also a major stumbling block. Internally, democratic reforms in the 90s became associated with 1) corruption far worse than Soviets had, and 2) right-wing economic measures ("liberalization") that messed up the economy and created a lot of hardship for the population at the time. The very words "democrat" and "liberal" became profanities for some. So when Putin appeared, the popular sentiment in the country already in favor of a "strong hand" for a while. He only needed to fit the image, which he did quite easily with his KGB background. After that, he gradually deconstructed the civil society, starting with free press.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoYes, the US did not get this right. At all. Russia could have been Germany-fied with a friendlier and supportive hand. Instead it was handed over to evangelical neoliberals, whose imposed economics guaranteed that only the most feral opportunists and violent gangsters would thrive. Russia could have become a modern social democracy, but now it's a crumbling militaristic dictatorship state run by a raging senile paranoiac with delusions of empire. It's one of the worst foreign policy failures in all of history. Ukraine will not be the end of it. If the invasion succeeds Russia will demand a slice of Lithuania to reunite Kalingrad with Belarus. That has huge implications for all Baltic-adjacent states. But worse, Putin has claimed the RF has a number of nuclear superweapons, including a strategic nuclear-tipped torpedo and smart hypersonic warhead delivery systems. He also completely renovated Moscow's civil defences. The US has failed to keep pace, and its weapons systems are either old and outdated or over-designed, high maintenance, and relatively fragile. Putin also been running a very successful program of subversion and political interference. And building up cyberwarfare capabilities. Even allowing for hyperbole the worry is that Russia is capable of a zero-warning decapitation strike, combined with remote mass infrastructure attacks and internal terrorism. Any response would be relatively ineffective. This completely undermines MAD as a doctrine. No mistake - the US is in very, very serious danger now, from both internal and external threats.
- desmosxxx 5y ago
- kavalg 5y agoJoining any organization usually comes with strings attached. Maybe they didn't like the strings...
- darebak 5y ago>if Western-style democracies don't want to loose their freedoms they have to act. Can you clarify on this? How does recent Russian action threaten freedoms in Western style democracies?
- reitanqild 5y agoRead modern history. Especially 1936 to 1940. If you are in a hurry you can start here: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peace_for_our_time https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peace_for_our_time
- darebak 5y agoI think I am well versed in European history, thank you for your snarky comment. There's no reason to believe some local conflict will undermine "democracies" all over Europe, notwithstanding the media that is always preying on people's fears.
- watwut 5y agoWhat makes Russia position understandable? What gives them right to occupy Ukraine?
- Wiseacre 5y agoUnderstandable does not mean justifiable.
- rmu09 5y agoSuppose canada tried to join china and north korea in some kind of military pact. USA would not possibly tolerate that.
- runarberg 5y agoYou are absolutely right. However, consider now that USA invades Canada as a result of this. This is infinity worse and always unacceptable. Nobody—not even American citizens—would tolerate that.
- RobertoG 5y agoSure, because American citizens don't accept USA invading other countries. Two week of 24 hours news with the proper perspective and the people would be asking in the streets for the invasion of Canada.
- runarberg 5y agoThe last time USA invaded a foreign country under a false pretense we saw the biggest protests in US history. But then I do have to admit that Bush was reelected in the next election, so perhaps you are right and I am wrong.
- RobertoG 5y agoBy the way, I don't mean that American citizens are special in this. We are all brainwashed in supporting what was already decided.
- khazhoux 5y ago> They... requested NATO to discuss it. Officially. Which is kind of a big deal. I'm totally ignorant on NATO procedures, so forgive me that I don't understand the Big Deal here. Obviously, NATO nations will discuss this. They didn't need Estonia to draw attention to what Russia is doing. So this seems to me a bit like: The exact thing that obviously would happen next (NATO nations discussing) will still happen, but now it's dressed up in a formalism?
- hef19898 5y agoNATO, like every other organisation, is discussing things all the time. Article 4 is the equivalent of not just inviting to a meeting about about a topic but raising a formal JIRA ticket and invoking a formal process involving senior management to discuss the severity (and not the mere existence) of that ticket. So yeah, invoking an official article is a big deal, because it forces the whole of NATO to formally address this issue. No NATO member nation can easily weasel out of this now.
- khazhoux 5y agoThe formality had to be done. But the Article 4 invocation is not (I claim) itself a significant event. To extend your analogy, this is like creating a JIRA ticket when your website with 100 million daily users suddenly goes offline. The shit has already hit the fan and it’s already all hands on deck.