4 ms·
Any abject suffering that occurs over the next hours, days, and weeks doesn't excuse the historical record of abject suffering imposed by the US military. It's
by woodruffw 5y ago
Any abject suffering that occurs over the next hours, days, and weeks doesn't excuse the historical record of abject suffering imposed by the US military.
It's perfectly consistent to be opposed to Russia's invasion of Ukraine and also reject the myth that the US's military is the only thing that maintains world peace.
- wernercd 5y ago"abject suffering" And what about some of the most peaceful decades in human history? That means nothing, eh? "only thing" Not the only thing by any stretch... but definitely a major reason and a hugely stabilizing force.
- woodruffw 5y ago> "abject suffering" And what about some of the most peaceful decades in human history? That means nothing, eh? The US, in a brief moment of national clarify, participated in exactly two just wars in the last century. The outcome of one of those wars was the establishment of liberal democracies across Western Europe, which is indeed a tremendous stabilizing force. But it's not clear to me that the US gets to claim outsized credit for the subsequent years of peacemaking under those nations.
- watwut 5y agoUs participated in Vietnam War too which would made it third War. In Korea War too, four. Plus, supported various guerrilas (taliban) and dictators materiály. And that is me being lazy to lookup whether there were other conflicts.
- lnxg33k1 5y agoAlso because what Russia is doing right now is the same thing that US tried to do in the Bay of Pigs, settling a puppet government in a portion of a country then make it ask for help? That's CIA 101
- eganist 5y agoThis isn't an intelligence organization or unlabeled fighters. This is an actual, state-backed military and a declared invasion.
- lnxg33k1 5y agoYeah but my point was that the declared invasion is happening due to the rebels that took over Donetsk and Lugansk asking for help from Putin to defend themselves from the ukrainian govt
- distances 5y agoThat is a very naive take. It's abundantly clear that Kremlin orchestrated the rebel areas to "ask for help" so they have a pretext for the invasion. I mean that was so transparent that I honestly thought it was only meant for Russian local audiences and absolutely nobody would buy that in the West.
- brightstep 5y agoI don’t think the residents of an invaded country care very much if they are killed by regular armed forces or intelligence. They’re dead either way.
- jollybean 5y agoIt's not a 'myth' that the US maintains world peace, it's a most obvious reality and it's disturbing that anyone wouldn't be able to see it plainly. The world is not a 'peaceful place' with a bunch of wars now and again. It's held together by force. Peace is a balance of, and righteous management of power. The US+NATO+Allies form the basis of that power. Unfortunately, without the US, that 'Team' would basically be dysfunctional and wouldn't really work. The Panama Canal, Suez Canal, the Gulf, S. China Sea - all of it would be controlled by various regimes if it were not for US power basically keeping it all open for everyone. Israel and Egypt the 'lynchpin' of peace in the ME is kept that way because of US power. All of he Middle East would be like Syria were it not for US/West. Obviously Taiwan would be in China and Korea would be vanquished by N. Korea. It's hard to know exactly how the cards would fall, but they would definitely fall one way or another. Unfortunately, we don't have a solution for Ukraine, but thankfully, this will be mostly contained in Ukraine thanks to NATO.
- jacquesm 5y ago> Unfortunately, we don't have a solution for Ukraine, but thankfully, this will be mostly contained in Ukraine thanks to NATO. The same sentences were written two weeks ago with respect to Ukraine. You can't make any assumptions about what Russia will or will not do. Taking over the Suwalki gap could easily happen. The frog is best boiled slowly, and with ample time to get used to the new temperature.